Tuesday, August 29, 2000
Early Childhood/Elementary
Kid Writing
with
Isabell Cardonick
Visit the ChatBoards at the
Mentor Support Center
http://www.teachers.net/mentors/
Join a Mailring at the
Teacher Mailring Center
http://www.teachers.net/mailrings/
Check the meeting schedule for future meetings
Debbie - Isabell,
welcome
Isabell - Has everyone
here read Kid Writing?
Connie - NO
beanie*jeanne - I
recently purchased it but have not read it yet
Ruby - Yes, I just
read it and loved it
Isabell - May I begin
with a plug for my website?
Isabell - Ruby, thanks!
Isabell - The website
is http://www.kidwriting.homestead.com/
beanie*jeanne - If
I dont have time to read the whole book is there an area that you recommend
me to start with.
Isabell - It's been
my pet project this summer.
Sarah - Isabell,
how soon in kindergarten do you ask a child to write without a drawing?
Ruby - How often
do you recommend the children write each week?
Isabell - I'd say
that you should save the section on Writing Workshop across the curriculum
for last.
Isabell - Otherwise,
follow the sequence of the book.
Isabell - Kindergarten
kids need to draw before writing to organize their thoughts.
Isabell - Sometimes,
they become so adept at writing that they decide on their own to skip the
drawing stage. The decision is theirs.
Isabell - Ruby, the
children write every day, beginning on the first day of school.
Julia - Isabell,
if a child doesn't apply what he knows about letters and sounds, and becomes
stubborn and frustrated about writing, (kindergarten) how would you encourage
him to write. Would you begin by simply transcribing his dictation until
late in the k year in hopes he will develop the confidence or motivation
or whatever is holding him back?
Isabell - I don't
take dictation from children unless I'm doing some sort of modeled writing
(whole group)
Isabell - We encourage
the children to write by giving them confidence.
Isabell - We let
them know that they already are writers.
Isabell - We show
them the many forms of writing that they can already do.
Isabell - We also
guide them through the entire writing process.
Ruby - My main concern
is being able to get to each child after they write to transcribe their
writing? How do you manage doing it all?
Isabell - We don't
just tell them to go and write on their own. We help them with the stretching
out process. Kid Writing explains how to do that in great detail.
Isabell - Ruby, remember,
the children are not writing on their own. The management issues are fully
addressed in the book. I can go into them here if you'd like, but it will
take a while to explain.
Sumr - What about
the children who just aren't ready to sit long enough to draw a picture?
~rsok~ - Isabell,,,,have
you heard of a program called,,,,,"Johnny Can Spell/Write"?????? I am looking
for a program to help my kids...Is Kid Writing too young for this age????
Sarah - Isabell,
do you provide any printed information to send out to parents (even administrators)
to explain Kid Writing?
Isabell - rsok, I'm
not familiar with the program you mentioned, but I'll see what I can find
out about it. Kid Writing is meant for Kindergarten and first grade, but
has applications for upper grades as well.
Lissa - Is it important
to make sure you do the transcription every day?
Isabell - Yes, there
is a letter to parents describing the stages of writing. There is a set
of directions for volunteers. And there are recommended articles for parents
and administrators.
~rsok~ - I will share
Kid Writing with our k-1 teachers!
Isabell - I try to
do both Kid Writing and adult writing with every child every day, and am
able to do so if I have my assistant and one or two volunteers. Keep in
mind though, I have 30 students.
Sarah - Isabell,
is Kid Writing implemented in any school districts district wide as the
official writing prgram?
Isabell - I've just
addressed this particular issue in the Q & A section of the Kid Writing
website.
Isabell - The Philadelphia
School District is using it on a cluster by cluster basis.
Isabell - Many of
the clusters have adopted it.
lin - i'm in my room
alone in a half day session..how should i begin
Isabell - Eileen
Feldgus and I are also working with several school districts across the
country which are using it.
Jean - Why do you
not worry about letter fromation. Our 1st grade teachers expect us to teach
this.
Darcy/K - HI Isabell,
I am a Philadelphia S.D. teacher. Do you know if they are using it in the
King Cluster?
Isabell - Teachers
using Kid Writing are writing to tell us how excited they are about the
results.
Ruby - How important
is it to use paper without lines. It seems to me that the lines give the
kids a framework to use.
Isabell - Hi Darcy.
Eileen would be the person to answer that question.
Isabell - Why don't
you email me at KTeachMSC@aol.com
and I'll forward your question to her.
Isabell - Lines?
Well, lets talk about DAP!
Isabell - At a kindergarten
level, I feel that lines are not dap.
Jean - what about
letter formation?
Isabell - As the
children begin to write in greater volume, I do put lines on their papers,
just to provide guidance in keeping their letters small and writing in
a line. Please note the difference between writing in a line and writing
on a line. Pat
- How do you keep their handwriting skills going and yet concentrate on
writing with no lines in first grade - or should lines be used from day
1 in 1st grade.
Jean - How important
is letter formation
Isabell - Also, we
want the kids to concentrate on the content of their writing
Isabell - Letter
formation is definitely not my top priority!
Jean - our district
is starting writing without tears
Isabell - Think about
this. We spend all that time teaching kids to write from top to bottom..
Then we teach them cursive and they learn to write from bottom to top!
Isabell - I teach
letter formation incidentally - while doing modeled writing.
Julia - Isabell,
is it difficult for a first grade teacher to use Kid Writing if kids come
from a Kindergarten that uses just free writing, invented spelling?
Kathy - What kind
of markers and paper do you use for journals?
Isabell - Kid Writing
advocates invented spelling. But, we also expose the kids to conventional
spelling - constantly. It's amazing how quickly they pick it up.
Pat - Are lines appropriate
for 1st grade writing?
Isabell - I ask the
parents to send in the washable broad tipped Crayola markers.
Lee - I model writing
by using Daily News, is that still applicable?
tracy - Isabell,
why do you advocate letting the kids write in markers? Isn't it harder
for them?
cheryl - ? How do
you promote correct spelling with journal writing/rough drafts?
Isabell - We use
xerox paper. We simply staple 30 sheets together with tagboard covers.
Debbie - I found
Liquid Mark to be great markers. They last a week with the lid off.
Teddi - I have a
concern about "underwriting" using adult spelling.
Isabell - We use
markers because they are fun, vibrant and they can't be erased! We don't
want the kids spending their time erasing.
Darcy/K - you can
also use file folders instead of tagboard.
beanie*jeanne - Concerning
lined paper, what do you think about about using it but not having them
really adhere to them.
Isabell - Lee, yes,
I do daily news, but I call it a secret message.
Darcy/K - you can
also use file folders instead of tagboard.
Ruby - What is your
ratio for student to adult while the children are writing? Do all the kids
write at the same time?
tracy - Do you let
the kids write on the backs of the journal pages? Why or why not?
Darcy/K - ok, I use
storybook paper for journals. It allows for freedom to write wherever they
want. According to kid writing, is this wrong?
Isabell - Regarding
the ratio of students to adults. Ideally, it would be one to six or seven.
Yes, all of the kids write at the same time.
Isabell - The book
explains the management issues. It would take too long for me to explain
them here.
Jean - How important
is spacing between words?
Isabell - Darcy,
I'm not sure what you mean by storybook paper. With Kid Writing, the children
are encouraged to follow book sequencing of their pages.
Isabell - a page
for their drawings and they write on the opposite page.
Sue - What if you
do not have any help? Will the program still work? If so, do you have any
tips.
Regina/K/NY - Any
suggestions for volunteers who automatically answer with adult spelling
when a K asks "How do you spell ...?". I find that weaker writers clue
in on this and look to these adults for help instead of working it through.
Darcy/K - storybook
paper is a blank space covering half the page, and lines on the other half.
Isabell - Regina,
it's important that we train our volunteers. We have to let them know not
only how to coach the children but why.
Ruby - I was thinking
of having the kids write about a special event during the summer vacation.
They bring in a photo of something special that they did during the summer.
Do you think this would be a good follow to the introduction to kidwriting
in your book (I really wish I was at the beach)?
Isabell - We need
to share our philosophy behind the Kid Writing approach.
Isabell - We don't
advocate giving the children prompts for their journal writing. We let
them draw and write about their own agenda. Freedom of choice is one of
the reasons Kid Writing works as well as it does.
Debbie - articles
in the June and July Teachers.net Gazettes by goint to http://teachers.net/gazette/backissues/
And read the transcript of a chat with Isabell and co-author Eileen Feldgus
in the early childhood section of http://teachers.net/archive
Isabell - You've
got it! The Wright Group.
Jean - HOW IMPORTANT
IS SPACING BETWEEN WORDS
Isabell - Debbie.
You are very welcome.
Sue - Is there any
chance that you might do a column on teachers.net. I just bought your book
and I love it, but I would love to hear more.
Isabell - Jean, we
teach the children to use"spaghetti spaces between the letters within a
word and "meatball spaces" between words.
tracy - Isabell,
what do you do to motivate the child that does not want to write? I really
had one like that this year and it was extremely frustrating. I have the
book and have read it but I haven't really found the answer to this question.
Isabell - We used
to think that it was too difficult for kids to have to worry about spacing,
but now we know they can do it!
Isabell - Tracy,
there is such excitement in the air about the children's writing. I find
that they really do want to write because they have an audience for their
writing and their writing is honored and appreciated in so many ways.
Isabell - It really
is about creating a joyful, risk free environment.
Lou - Is Isabell
writing a column for Teachers.Net? Where is it? I'd like to read it.
Julia - I read some
articles with questions and answers at http://teachers.net/gazette/backissues
Debbie - there are
articles in June and July's Teachers.Net Gazette.
Lissa - do you use
a word wall in conjunction with kid writing, or just the word family houses?
Jennifer - Isabell,
will you be writing more columns with our questions and your answers in
the gazette?
Isabell - Yes, Lissa,
we do advocate using word walls, but only for high frequency words.
tracy - Isabell,
do you recommend the kids using one sheet of paper to write and the other
for drawing or both writing and drawing on the same sheet? Thanks!!!!!
chris - debbie, did
you get my message about kinds of journaling paper?/
Isabell - Jennifer,
I'm not sure that I'll have time to do another column. But, I'll try to
keep the website updated.
Isabell - I like
to give the kids lots of room for their writing and their drawings, so
we do separate (facing) pages for each.
tracy - Isabelle
are you familiar with the Rebecca Sitton spelling program and if so do
you feel it works with kid writing?
Debbie - Isabell
thank you for presenting this evening.
Lou - Thanks Isabell
and Debbie too!
Jennifer - Isabell,
do you go to schools to do workshops?
Isabell - Thanks
for inviting me!
Isabell - Jennifer,
yes I do workshops, but can't schedule many of them because I'm still teaching
full time.
Jennifer - OR do
you have a video about Kid Writing?
Isabell - But, I
recommend that you contact Eileen Feldgus, who is really the genius behind
Kid Writing.
tracy - A video is
an excellent idea
Isabell - There is
information about her staff development at the Kid Writing website.
Isabell - We have
submitted a proposal for a video and the Wright Group is considering it.
Isabell - We have
loved working with the Wright Group and are hoping to do several more projects
with them.
Isabell - I'd like
to wish everyone a wonderful school year.
Debbie - Thank you.
Isabell - Thanks
for your interest in Kid Writing. It really is so exciting!