|
|

Re: Huck Finn a Challenge for 5th graders
Posted by Sara on 7/17/08
On 7/17/08, Athena wrote:
> I've been trying to compile literature for my fifth
> graders this year (I'm relatively new to gifted) and came
> across Huck Finn. I'm in the midst of rereading it
> (haven't read it since middle school) and wondered whether
> the racial references would be innapropriate or offensive.
>
> Please advise me on your opinion.
> Thanks
Huck Finn's language has supporters and detractors. It's an
ongoing discussion as to whether it's appropriate to continue
to assign it. But I've never heard of it being used in the
5th grade. Here we read it in high school and usually 10th or
11th.
Posts on this thread, including this one
- Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/17/08, by Athena.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/17/08, by Debbie.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/17/08, by Raftery.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/17/08, by Rafe Esquith uses it read: There are no shortcuts.
- Re: Huck Finn a Challenge for 5th graders, 7/17/08, by Sara.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/18/08, by HGmom.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/19/08, by Juliana.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/19/08, by you can't possibly have meant that.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/19/08, by Juliana.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/19/08, by Debbie.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/19/08, by Janette.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/20/08, by HG mom.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/20/08, by Juliana.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/20/08, by GT Teacher.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/20/08, by HG mom.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/20/08, by GT Teacher.
- Re: Huck Finn Controversial?, 7/20/08, by Janette.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial?, 7/22/08, by HG mom.
- Re: Anne Frank Controversial? Only the section where, 7/22/08, by She and her friend feel up each others' breasts.
|