|
|

Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?
Posted by Carolyn on 10/11/08
I would send a letter home to the parents indicating my
intentions and explaining why it is relevant to the
curriculum. I am curious to know what your agenda is here. If
it is your way of taking an "anti war" stance, it might not be
appropriate. If it's your way of saying "this is how today's
world is, let's discuss the horrors of it all", then it is
appropriate. It depends on what the message is you are trying
to give to your students -- which becomes the difference
between indoctrination and education.
On 10/11/08, Anthony Newby wrote:
> I am showing slides of the holocaust, iraq war , civil
> rights etc. I found a stunning picture of a child on a
> bike in iraq and his leg has been blown off somehow at
> the knee. His father is helping him up. It could be too
> graphic, but kids see this stuff almost every day these
> days on tv and in movies like "SAW". I want to put it in
> a real context and shake up there world a little. Should
> I include the pic in my slide show? Since these are 9 -
> 12th graders who will be in college in 4 years or less, I
> think its ok for them to see this. For younger kids I
> would say no. What is your opinion?
Posts on this thread, including this one
- SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by Anthony Newby.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by Carolyn.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by Cybrary Man.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by Steve.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by Anthony Newby.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by Experienced.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by Anthony Newby.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/11/08, by An alternative.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/12/08, by Craig Levan.
- Re: absolutely not , 10/12/08, by jay.
- Re: absolutely not , 10/12/08, by Anthony Newby.
- Re: absolutely not , 10/12/08, by NewCanadian.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/12/08, by Absolutely Not..
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/12/08, by JH.
- Re: absolutely not , 10/12/08, by jay.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL --Yes, do it, Anthony!, 10/12/08, by Experienced.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/13/08, by Rebecca.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL --Yes, do it, Anthony!, 10/13/08, by Anthony Newby.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/14/08, by tgs/ga/8.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL --Yes, do it, Anthony!, 10/14/08, by Experienced.
- Re: Film violence vs. the portrayal of real suffering, 10/15/08, by Sara.
- Re: Film violence vs. the portrayal of real suffering, 10/15/08, by Anthony Newby.
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/21/08, by maybe "newby" is the way to be....
- Re: SHOULD I SHOW GRAPHIC MATERIAL TO HIGH SCHOOLERS?, 10/23/08, by Experiences to "maybe".
|