Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?
Posted by Not an appropriate book for my suburban school on 2/16/08
I know there is another thread about the use of the f-word in the book, but what concerns me are discussions of things that I would not be comfortable discussing with students such as: "The exhilaration of the moment vanished and he sought it in vain, like seeking ecstacy's memory an instant after jacking off and encountering only shame and guilt." This is not a book that I could justify to a parent. I'm not saying no teacher should teach the book, just that I personally could not do it. On 2/04/08, jdiamond wrote: > I disagree wholeheartedly. I do agree that 1984, and Lord of the Flies (btw, never use > etc. when listing the basis of an argument) along with Fahrenheit 451 and Catcher in > the Rye are excellent books. I, however, do not see why you would place The > Chocolate War underneath them. I don't believe that Orwell, Golding, Bradbury, or > Salinger deserve a spot in the halls of education, while Mr. Cormier does not. He was > one of the original radicals, writing the truth instead of sugar coated, morally neutral > claptrap. I think that Cormier's novels still have a place in the modern classroom. I > teach 7th grade ELA in New York, and I think the Chocolate War appeals to the stark > reality of my students lives.
Posts on this thread, including this one
- Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 1/31/08, by heather.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 1/31/08, by Chuck AP Eng.
- Re: Still Teaching It, 2/01/08, by Steve.
- Re: If you could only assign one book, what book would it be?, 2/01/08, by Sara.
- Re: If you could only assign one book, what book would it be, 2/01/08, by 7.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 2/01/08, by sb.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 2/04/08, by jdiamond.
- Re: To Steve from PA, 2/10/08, by Lauren.
- Re: Chocolate War Teachers, 2/10/08, by Lauren.
- Re: Chocolate War Teachers, 2/11/08, by Meg in VT.
- Re: Chocolate War Teachers, 2/16/08, by Lauren.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 2/16/08, by Not an appropriate book for my suburban school.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 2/17/08, by Moe.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 2/18/08, by heather.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 2/18/08, by Malice.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 5/07/08, by Terra.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 5/08/08, by Charlotte.
- Re: Anyone still teach The Chocolate War?, 5/09/08, by Strunk & White.
|