Charlotte,

I am in the same position as you are. I use Gameplan for
1rst-5th grades and wanted something for Kindergarten. I
bought Musicplay thinking that it would be a good substitute
until Jeff and Randy came out with K. I do not really like
it. There are a lot of songs in there, however I think many
of the activities lack the focus that Gameplan is so
wonderful for. IMHO Musicplay is just OK. I have used some
of the activities, but they just aren't as awesome as
Gameplan. Just my .02.

On 11/04/09, Charlotte wrote:
> I posted a while back that I had purchased Gameplan for 1st
> and LOVE it. I'm planning to buy the 2nd grade book as
> well. However, now that I'm enjoying this so much, I don't
> feel that I'm as strong as I should be with kindergarten. I
> know lots of people use Musicplay. Is it similar to
> Gameplan in that it's set up sequentially AND really good?
> (So much of Making Music is good, but the sequence is
> really strange in my opinion.) I love the way Gameplan is
> sequenced and feel like I hardly ever have to "plan" for
> 1st anymore! I'm not looking for more resources, just for
> the sequencing help. Is it good for that? Thanks!!

Share This Post | Report This Post

Next Post >>

Posts on this thread, including this one