chat center
SUBSCRIBE MY LINKS:
Latest Posts Full Chatboard Submit Post

 

Teachers.Net Nav
Chat Center
Teachers |Administrators
Grade Level |Subjects |States
Interest Groups |Projects
Classified Ads |Help Wanted

Report this post


Re: Round Robin Reading
Posted by shoshana on 12/26/07

    On 12/25/07, t wrote:
    > I was working at a school recently in which many of us had to
    > share one very small space. In that space, the remedial reading
    > teacher had a group of three and she did some round robin
    > reading with them. The kids enjoyed it and always wanted to
    > read. However, the "curriculum specialist" (whatever that
    > meant)overheard round robin reading going on and went
    ballistic,
    > quoting something she read on the internet about how damaging
    it
    > was to students. When I went on the site, I discovered that it
    > was some grad students thesis! I really wish that when people
    > demanded that we do certain things with students that they
    would
    > have some REAL evidence to back it up.
    >
    >
    > On 12/24/07, Sk wrote:
    >> On 11/23/07, Deb ms/IA wrote:
    >>> Why has round robin reading gotten such a bad rap to the
    >>> point researchers tell teachers not to do it? Reading over
    >>> several of Rasinski's writings and edited works, I just
    >>> want to disagree with him and his no round robin reading
    >>> colleagues.
    >>>
    >>> In my 8th grade reading classroom my students are told from
    >>> the beginning why I have them read aloud in class. I need
    >>> quickly gauge how 100 kids orally read out loud, so I use
    >>> it as a mini assessment without having to do a full IRI on
    >>> all the students. I want kids to hear themselves speak so
    >>> when they go get that job at the burger joint or the
    >>> grocery store they can use their voice to articulate orders
    >>> and requests from customers plus I want them to see that
    >>> their fluency is key to them being a better reader.
    >>>
    >>> My students are also made to feel safe in making mistakes
    >>> when they read. I model it myself when I read passages. Its
    >>> OK to make mistakes and part of being a good reader is to
    >>> go back and reread and self correct. I can't see that take
    >>> place when I give silent fluency/comprehension tests. I
    >>> also can't guide them to make corrections when they
    >>> silently read their novels. So in class round robin reading
    >>> helps students not hurts them. Tests scores from my class
    >>> shows growth in reading too.
    >>>
    >>> Does anyone else feel like the need to go to "round robin
    >>> reader's anonymous" (quote and self evaluation form from
    >>> one of Rasnski's books) or feel gulity because "research"
    >>> doesn't back round robin?
    >>>
    >>> Deb ms/IA

     
     

You are on the REMEDIAL READING CHATBOARD:   LATEST POSTS   ALL POSTS   SUBMIT POST

Sponsors  

New Moms Wanted!
Join the community for new and expecting moms. Check out Maternityville.com Maternity Chat!

Free Lesson Plans
Thousands of lesson plans and curriculum ideas! teachers.net/lessons

Teaching Jobs
Thousands of teaching jobs and other jobs in education - visit jobs.teachers.net

Other Chatboards in this Category...
  English Center Chatboards
The English Center Chatboards are for educators who teach English classes or educators who have an interest in English curricula.

Reading/Writing
HS English
Books/Literature
Book Talk
 
Remedial Reading
Accelerated Reader
6 Traits Writing
 
4 Blocks Literacy
Building Blocks (K)
Library/Media Specialist
 

Check out the latest additions to the Lesson Bank...
 
Google
 
Web Teachers.Net
  Site Map: Home Search Teaching Jobs Classifieds Lessons Contacts PR Advertise
  © 1996 - 2008. All Rights Reserved. Please review our Terms of Use, Mission Statement, and Privacy Policy.