Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?
Posted by Kevin on 5/05/08
On 5/05/08, Bill of SC wrote: > The point is not global warming, I'm a believer, the point > is shoving one's beliefs down the throat of others. Especially > the captive audience of a classroom. Our job, as teachers, is > not to indoctrinate but to educate. We shouldn't ever get in a > pissing match with a ten year old; after all we are supposed to > be the adults. Liberal or conservative our answer to the child > should have been the same. "Not everyone believes that Global > Climate Change is caused by man, this might be a great project > for a research paper, or science fair." The reason our society > is becoming so polarized is that some try to interject politics > everywhere. Just my opinion. In a science class, it is important to get the science right, not to say "not everyone believes ...". Science isn't about what everyone believes, but about what models work best with the available data. There are both scientific and political questions around global warming, and it does help kids to separate the concepts. Treating the scientific issues as if they were the same as political opinions is not teaching science---it is political indoctrination! When someone lacks the tools to evaluate the models themselves (as essentially all the kids, politicians, and even science teachers do on issues such as global warming), then it becomes necessary to figure out who does have the skills and tools to evaluate the science properly, and get their judgments. Kids do need to learn how to check the quality of their sources, and school is about the only place they are likely to get even a suggestion that they do so.
Posts on this thread, including this one
- What would you do to combat this thinking?, 4/27/08, by cam.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 4/27/08, by anon.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 4/30/08, by Kevin.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/03/08, by BillofSC.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/03/08, by Joseph Stevens.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/04/08, by Darwin.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/04/08, by tamagosan.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/05/08, by Bill of SC.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/05/08, by Kevin.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/05/08, by Joseph .
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/05/08, by anon.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/05/08, by also anon.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/06/08, by Repeat after me: "I'm the boss, applesauce...".
- Re: To "repeat after me...", 5/07/08, by cam.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/07/08, by Darwin.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/08/08, by cam.
- Re: What would you do to combat this thinking?, 5/08/08, by Waski_the_Squirrel.
|