I want to comment on these two different statements below...
[...A student who misbehaves should not be given detention during class
time. This detention should be set on Saturday, which is really
more punishment for the student. ........
.......I believe that ISS should be a learning process for the student. Most
ISS policies only "babysit" the student, they do nothing to help curve
future occurances of innappropriate behavior....]
I am the ISS cordinator (slash) security guard for our small k-12 Alabama
school. These two comments are exactly right, many people in my position
tend to be babysitters, rather than counselers/enforcers for lack of a
better term. I personally did some research and found lots of material
dealing with character education, on several grade levels, with different
themes to work on. Sometimes the students will finish their work early or
not have any assignments at all. I keep a full supply of character ed.
worksheets to give them. I also keep valuable "Thoughts of the Day" posted
around the room and occasionally I will ask the students to write me a
story or examples using one of the sayings. You would be surprised at how
much a student will open up and be honest answering questions about peer
pressure, or drug use; things along those lines. The way I have to look at
this group of kids is the simple fact, what if this were my child? What
would I do to try and help, rather than punish?
Secondly, Saturday school sounds like a wonderful idea. But for schools
like ours, half the families around this rural area would not pay for
Saturday school. Nor would they put forth the extra effort to see that
their child had transportation. There would be more things involved too,
like with the opening of the school building. My principal doesn't want to
drive to work on the weekend, no more than we do. Plus there are rules and
regulations that deal with having access to the school without an
administrator present. And in my opinion, if the parents funded the whole
opperation, the ISS "teacher" wouldn't have state insurance and retirement
as we do now (In Alabama). Again, I want to say it's a wonderful idea, and
I can see why you would suggest it, but I doubt we will ever see it a
reality. :)