|
|

Re: Is this for real?
Posted by Susan on 4/04/08
Have you ever taught? If not, then you have NO IDEA what teachers deal with. You don't think we try every method possible? Good kids are getting cheated out of an education because of parents like you who are afraid to discipline their kids. Thus, they come to school and are brats. I have paddled my kids twice. That is all it took to know there is a line that they shouldn't cross. They are happy, well-adjusted and I can take them anywhere. You have to balance discipline and love. There is absolutely no evidence that paddling, when done right in schools, leads to domestic violence etc. That is plain non-sense. SUSAN On 4/03/08, To Susan wrote: > Susan -- I have a couple of questions for you. > > 1. Do you have children? > 2. If so, do you paddle them? > 3. Do you know any other way than paddling? > 4. HAve you tried any other behavior management method? > 5. If not, would you try? > > Regards, > An onlooker that is pretty appalled > > > > On 11/22/07, Susan wrote: >> I guarantee schools that paddle have less classroom problems than >> ones that don't. It is not fair to good students to have teachers >> constantly trying to gain control of a rowdy class in a non- > paddling >> setting. >> >> >> >> On 11/21/07, Yes, some Arkansas schools still paddle and we do > wrote: >>> On 11/18/07, Not an Arkansas teacher wrote: >>>> On 11/14/07, Paddle in the Saddle wrote: >>>>> If you hang a paddle on the wall in your classroom with a >>>>> list of infractions and the number of corresponding whacks >>>>> to go with each, and use it, you will find very few >>>>> disciplinary problems. >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> On 11/13/07, Susan wrote: >>>>>> Hi, I am thinking of doing a discipline chart for classroom >>>>>> management. I will first give a warning to a student to >>>>>> correct behavior. If they disobey again, they get an X on >>>>>> their chart...3 Xs equals one swat with the paddle, 6 Xs >>>>>> equals 2 swats. They can earn Xs by not doing homework, >>>>>> talking too much, swearing, etc etc... >>>>>> >>>>>> I am convinced now that paddling is extremely effective. I >>>>>> have watched it work with other teachers as I was reluctant >>>>>> to use it much. Thoughts? >>> >>> not, for the most part, have the major problems other states >>> have. At least I don't think we do. At my school the paddle >>> cannot be left out in sight.
Posts on this thread, including this one
- Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 11/13/07, by Susan.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 11/14/07, by Paddle in the Saddle.
- Re: Is this for real?, 11/18/07, by Not an Arkansas teacher.
- Re: Is this for real?, 11/21/07, by Yes, some Arkansas schools still paddle and we do .
- Re: Is this for real?, 11/22/07, by Susan.
- Re: Is this for real?, 11/24/07, by Not an Arkansas teacher.
- Re: Is this for real?, 11/24/07, by Paddling is common in my district, and if the parent.
- Re: Is this for real?, 11/26/07, by It's more common in TEXAS than you think!.
- Re: Is this for real?, 11/26/07, by Ryan D..
- Re: This is just sad..., 12/04/07, by JJS.
- Re: This is just sad..., 12/08/07, by Paddle them now, or in a couple years.
- Re: This is just sad..., 12/09/07, by Liz.
- Re: This is just sad..., 12/10/07, by Dr. Spock (sp?) is alive & well on this board!.
- Re: This is just sad...But, 12/10/07, by johnv.
- Re: This is just sad...But, 12/10/07, by Do you really think moving a football on a board will cause.
- Re: This is just sad..., 12/13/07, by No wonder America is labeled 'STUPID IN AMERICA'.
- Re: This is just sad..., 12/13/07, by Maybe if Jonesboro had had a lovely positive incentive .
- Re: Jonesboro, 12/16/07, by JSS.
- Re: This is just sad..., 12/19/07, by Sandra.
- Re: Is this for real?, 12/19/07, by Sandra.
- Re: Paddling/Whipping in the early 1900s., 12/19/07, by Sandra.
- Re: Paddling/Whipping in the early 1900s., 12/20/07, by secondary teacher.
- Re: Well, guess what...., 12/21/07, by JSS.
- Re: Jonesboro, 12/24/07, by Nut, who said all schools in Arkanas paddle?.
- Re: Paddling/Whipping in the early 1900s., 12/24/07, by Let's just wait and let the police do it for us. They'll go.
- Re: Well, guess what...., 12/24/07, by Maybe you'll be the next one they'll kill. Lovely, huh?.
- Re: This is just sad..., 1/08/08, by children learn by example.
- Re: Is this for real?, 1/12/08, by Paddline causing more violence (read inside).
- Re: Is this for real?, 1/20/08, by Gosh, Singapore paddles adults. As I said before,.
- Re: Is this for real?, 1/25/08, by Sue- High School Teacher.
- Re: Is this for real?, 1/26/08, by We have 10-year-old females.
- Re: Is this for real?, 1/27/08, by Sue.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 3/26/08, by Amy.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/03/08, by OPPOSED TO PADDLING.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/03/08, by To Susan.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 4/03/08, by ooops -- the secrets out in Arkansa.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/04/08, by johnv.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/04/08, by to johnv.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/04/08, by Susan.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/05/08, by To Susan.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/05/08, by Dear Susan.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/06/08, by sharon.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/06/08, by Laura.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/07/08, by Why?.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/07/08, by It is called ignorance.
- Re: To Laura, 4/07/08, by Chuck E.
- Re: To Laura, 4/07/08, by some just don't get it.
- Re: To Laura, 4/07/08, by Laura.
- Re: To Laura, 4/07/08, by What doesn't Laura get?.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/07/08, by You did WHAT!!!.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/07/08, by You asked your superior for a paddling??!!.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/07/08, by susan.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/07/08, by susan.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/07/08, by Chuck E.
- Re: To Laura, 4/08/08, by IF this is true, which I doubt.
- Re: Is this for real?, 4/08/08, by A Typical non answer.
- Re: To Laura, 4/08/08, by Chuck E.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/08/08, by Sane Displaced Person.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/08/08, by AMAZING!!.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/08/08, by Chuck E.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/08/08, by Try Atlanta on for size.
- Re: Paddling, 4/09/08, by susan.
- Re: Paddling, 4/10/08, by Not Buying It.
- Re: Paddling, 4/10/08, by Regular Poster.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/11/08, by An Apologist for the Bare Butt Teacher!?lol.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/11/08, by Chuck E.
- Re: Sample Paddling, 4/12/08, by Arkansa Education is a Public Embarassment.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/12/08, by dj.
- Re: Paddling, 4/12/08, by Susan.
- Re: Little Rock- No Paddling, 4/20/08, by Little Rock Teacher.
- Re: Little Rock- No Paddling, 4/20/08, by Pulaski County Teacher.
- Re: Little Rock- No Paddling, 4/20/08, by Pulaski County Teacher.
- Re: Sickos in Ark., 4/20/08, by You totally missed his point you silly goose!.
- Re: Little Rock- No Paddling, 4/22/08, by anon.
- Re: Paddling, 4/28/08, by Gumby.
- Re: Paddling, 4/28/08, by susan.
- Re: Paddling, 4/30/08, by Bubba Budda.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by Right Wing Christian Conservative with an opinion.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by Only in Ark. would we be having this big debate!.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by Six months ago it was ISS. Talk about not working!.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by Bubba Budda.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by Bubba Budda.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by yeah right!!!.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by Somebody needs to read the New Testament.
- Re: Paddling, 5/01/08, by a frequent reader and a Christian, proud of it.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 5/08/08, by Jennifer.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 5/10/08, by anon.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 5/10/08, by anonymous.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 5/10/08, by Don't bother coming to Georgia.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 5/11/08, by Jacqui Hawkins.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 5/12/08, by PCH.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 5/16/08, by Seattle Dad & counselor.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/21/08, by John.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/22/08, by anon.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/23/08, by Brittany.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/23/08, by Ashamed in AR.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/26/08, by conservative christian.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/26/08, by time to leave the south.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/26/08, by it can't be for real.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/27/08, by Pick the Interstate with an uneven number!.
- Re: Is this for real?, 5/27/08, by conservative christian.
- Re: Is this for real?, 7/02/08, by Keith.
- Re: Is this for real?, 7/21/08, by dean.
- Re: To Laura, 7/21/08, by dean.
- Re: Paddling/Whipping in the early 1900s., 7/21/08, by dean.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 7/30/08, by Sandra.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 7/31/08, by rick.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 7/31/08, by dean.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/13/08, by Kelly.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/13/08, by DEAN.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/13/08, by Why Dean?.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/15/08, by Stephanie Ar.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/15/08, by dean.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/19/08, by dEbra AP167.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/19/08, by dean.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/20/08, by dEbra AP167 .
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/20/08, by dean.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/21/08, by What do you want to discus, Dean?.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/21/08, by Are you Rick? or Dean?.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/21/08, by Laura.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/21/08, by dean.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/21/08, by Laura.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 8/21/08, by dean.
- Re: What do you want to talk about, Dean?, 8/21/08, by or is it Rick?.
- Re: What do you want to talk about, Dean?, 8/23/08, by Dean.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 11/12/08, by Bob AP.
- Re: Discipline Chart for Classroom Management, 11/12/08, by tom.
|