chat center
SUBSCRIBE MY LINKS:

Latest Posts Full Chatboard Submit Post

Current Issue » Table of Contents | Back Issues
 


TEACHERS.NET GAZETTE
Volume 4 Number 4

COVER STORY
No matter how many hundred of millions of dollars are spent, school reform initiatives will continue to produce unsatisfying results until we unflinchingly address the critical problem of teacher quality.
We're Still Leaving the Teachers Behind...
ARTICLES
We're Still Leaving the Teachers Behind by Vivian Troen & Katherine C. Boles
Bureaucrat's Field of Dreams: If You Test Them They Will Learn -- A Rousing, Rip-Roaring,Raving Rant by Bill Page
That's My Job! Promoting Responsibility in the Preschool Classroom by Mary E. Maurer
War Impacts Preschool Students -- Current events and behavior changes from the Teachers.Net Early Childhood Chatboard
TEAPOT Word Game - What Every Teacher Should Know! by Catherine Schandl
How To Use Anchoring for Accelerated Learning by Stelios Perdios
An Art Historian on Children in the Museum by Erick Wilberding
China ESL, An Industry Run Amuck? by Niu Qiang & Martin Wolff
Editor's epicks for April by Kathleen Alape Carpenter
Egg Hatching - A PowerPoint Presentation by Mechele Ussery
Direction for Teachers of Creative Writing by Dan Lukiv
Tutorial - High Frequency Words (for students who struggle) from the Teachers.Net Chatboard
Vocabulary Activities by Lisa Indiana 2-3
April Columns
April Regular Features
April Informational Items
Gazette Home Delivery:

Niu Qiang & Martin Wolff...

Niu Qiang, PhD was born and raised in Shenyang, Liaoning Province, PRC. She obtained her Bachelor of Arts degree (1991) in English from Jilin University; her Master of Arts degree (1996) in English Linguistics from Jilin University; and her PhD (1999) in English Linguistics from Shanghai International Studies University. She is currently an Associate Professor at the School of Foreign Languages, Tong ji University, Shanghai, China, where she teaches Psycholinguistics, Second Language Acquisition (SLA), and Testing of English as a Second Language. donna_niu@yahoo.com

Martin Wolff, J.D. was born in Rochester, New York, USA. He obtained his Juris Doctor degree (1976) from Loyola University, Los Angeles, Ca. He has taught Legal English, Business English, Business Management, Marketing, Human Relations and English Conversation. He is currently a Foreign Expert at the School of Foreign Languages, the Shanghai Institute of International Exchange, as part of the Sino-Canadian Joint Program. teachbesl@yahoo.co.uk


Teacher Feature...

China ESL
An Industry Run Amuck?

(continued from page 4)

by Niu Qiang, PhD & Martin Wolff, J.D.


  1. Travel Expense
  2. Most schools provide a one-way airfare re-imbursement after you have taught for six months and a full round trip reimbursement after you have taught for one year. They also generally provide 1,200 RMB for vacation travel within China at the end of a one-year contract. However, this varies with the different schools.

    The Central Government guide provides:
    "The inviting party will pay travel expenses to and from work." (1994, Guide for Foreign Experts Working in China, State Bureau of Foreign Experts, p. 52)

    "Invitees working for over one year, or over one academic year, will be provided with an economy class return air ticket for themselves and their families. If invitees wish to purchase their own tickets, the inviting party will pay in RMB Yuan the equivalent cost of an economic class air fare by the most direct route." (1994, Guide for Foreign Experts Working in China, State Bureau of Foreign Experts, p. 53)

  3. Qualifications
    1. Education
    2. Most Chinese schools require a Bachelors degree, at a minimum. Unfortunately the degree does not need to be in English, Literature, Linguistics or Education. There are many circumstances where Native English Speakers have been employed with an Associates degree or as little as a U.S. high school diploma. xinpai@china.com

      "Xin Pai Foreign Language School Date: Monday, 20 January 2003, at 10:08 a.m. More Job Vacancies Four more teaching positions are now available at Xin Pai Foreign Language School … but even those with no experience, who would like to try their hand at teaching, are welcome, as we can provide on-the-job training and assistance" http://www.chinatefl.com/abroad.html.

      "Frequently Asked Questions: 1. What qualifications should one have in teaching in China? The basic qualifications are: being a native speaker of English, having a minimum BA degree and commitment to teaching, loving China and its people. Clear, well-spoken English and a good knowledge of the fundamentals of English grammar.
      Teaching experience/certificate is preferred but not a must."

      A major ESL teacher recruiting web site (www.AbroadChina.com) gives the following advice:

    What if I do not have a degree?

    If you do not have a degree, you must have:
    Qualified Teacher Status and at least one years' recent classroom-based experience of teaching English or modern languages, or a TEFL qualification and one years' classroom-based experience of TEFL or teaching another subject. 
    However, some schools will accept you without degree requested, and in some summer program, they may also accept. But some school will not accept you without a degree, so your options will be restricted.

    What if I have limited teaching experience?

    With TEFL qualifications or equivalent & less than one years experience. If you have a degree, some host schools still will accept you.

    The above directly contradicts, at least as to public universities and institutions of higher learning, the following official position of the Chinese Central Government.

    The Central Government guide provides:

    "Those in search of language teaching positions in universities and institutions of higher learning should have a good grasp of their native languages and literature and should have at least three years' language teaching experience. They should be able to speak their native language in standard pronunciation and intonation." (1994, Guide for Foreign Experts Working in China, State Bureau of Foreign Experts)

    Note that the above is advisory and applies only to universities and institutions of higher learning, presumably public colleges and private Business Institutes, but not kindergartens, primary schools, middle schools or high schools, public or private. The use of the word "should" and not "must" should also be noted. The final and most important observation must be the lack of any requirement that English be the native language of the foreign expert hired to teach ESL.

  4. ESL Training and/or Teaching Experience
  5. Most schools request a TESOL, TEFL, TOFL, ESL or CELTA certificate, but actual teaching experience or business experience is an acceptable substitute. (See above.)

    Although many schools claim to offer training once the FE is in China, in fact only a handful of private schools provide any pre-employment or on-the-job training specifically for ESL teaching in China.

    Most Chinese schools prefer some teaching experience but some do not, let alone ESL experience. Likewise, most schools do not provide any type of teacher training, either on the job or on-line. They use the learn as you go by "trial-and-error" method of teacher training.

  6. Recruiting Inducements
  7. Most ESL teachers are recruited to China with very attractive bait.

    Travel/Teach English: The Global TESOL Institute, http://www.eslcafe.com; Looking for a well-paid job to explore China? Come to TDM! Posted By: TDM Language College woody@tdmlanguage.com Date: Thursday, 16 January 2003, at 10:04 a.m. But you are very well paid. Your salary will be more than enough for you to live comfortably, to explore the exciting China, its history, its nature, its people, its culture, its language and its food.)

    Teach in China

    … Harbin Star Foreign Language College provides a pathway to exploring China whilst taeching within a Sino-British University environment. ...

    teach-in-china.com.view.php?company_id=59 -- Cached -- Similar pages (Google)

    The recruit is usually very young with no prior teaching experience, away from home for the first time, in their first cross-cultural experience, and under the belief that they are about to embark upon a China vacation, which of necessity, must be interrupted occasionally for a little work.

    "Too many people with no real interest in the job come here (China) for a good time (very easy to do) and leave the real teachers trying to clean up the mess and repair their image. A white face and a degree, even a fake one, land a job." (Andrew Tamblyn, 1/15/03, www.ESLcafe.com)

    "The tragedy is that some folks come here not to teach, but to travel, so they get all romantic and misty eyed. They can't teach, don't want to teach, and want to party like in the good old USA. This devil-may-care, happy camper attitude unfortunately leads them to make immature decisions and to be placed in schools that can not wait to capitalize on these "Rage against the Machine" look-a-likes. They also give serious teachers a bad reputation." (H. Jones, 2/25/01, www.ESLcafe.com)

Click for next page of this article

 

#