Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Debate as a Media to Analyze and Share Opinion

By Frida D. Widjaya

  • Social Studies
  • Elementary
Activity Time
70 minutes
Materials
One article from a magazine
Concepts / Topics
Introductory to the function of "Debate" as a media to share opinion and appreciate other's

Students read a magazine article, take opposing positions in a structured debate, and reflect on listening to and appreciating others’ opinions.

Topic and Lesson Context

The topic was “The Invention.” This activity took place in lesson 4. Previous lessons covered inventions over time, technology at home and in class, and famous inventors who influenced our lives. Students already had an understanding of inventions, inventors, technology, and the reasons for or functions of inventions.

Objectives

  • To understand the current issue regarding the invention.
  • To appreciate others’ opinions.
  • To share ideas and give their own opinions.
  • To respond and be a good listener.

Lesson Procedure

I divided lesson 4 into three main parts: the introduction, the teaching-learning process, and the closing summary.

Introduction

I reviewed the previous discussions for a few minutes. Then I asked students to read an article that I had cut from a magazine. It was about the invention of a killing machine (a suicide machine) by a doctor from Australia. Students read silently and identified the main point of the article.

I then split the class into two large groups based on their own opinions: whether they agreed or disagreed with the invention. Together, we established these rules:

  • Raise your hand before speaking.
  • Listen while others are speaking.
  • Keep emotions out of the debate.
  • Understand that people differ from one another.

From the beginning, we established that people may respond differently to the same problem.

Teaching-Learning Process: Debate

Students shared what they wanted to say and gave their opinions, creating a lively class discussion. We spoke in both English and our mother tongue, Bahasa Indonesia.

Closing Summary

I brought students back to the idea that inventions must provide positive benefits and improve the conditions and situations of our lives. I did this because they were grade 3 students—still young, but so enthusiastic about learning about the world around them.

Reflection and Future Use

For assessment, we reflected together.

I concluded that this activity could be used again with a different lesson in another subject. Students also became aware of the current situation. I suggest discussing the daily problems we face as well.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2817.html