Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Stars and Wishes Conferencing in Writing Workshop

By deb

  • 4 Blocks
  • Elementary
Concepts / Topics
conferencing in writing

The teacher models stars and wishes responses as learners share writing, listen, and offer positive observations and questions about what they wonder or want clarified.

Conferencing Using the Stars and Wishes Technique

A Writing Workshop mini-lesson on conferencing using stars and wishes.

1. Focus on Stars

The author shares a piece, and the class listens carefully. When beginning this process, remember that modeling—showing kids how—is what will make or break it.

Use questions and comments such as:

  • What was interesting?
  • What surprised you?
  • Wow, that's good!
  • I liked the part about ...
  • Tell me what you liked about the story.
  • This reminded me of when ...
  • Why did the author do this?
  • What did you like about ...?
  • What did you remember?

At first, use a book, a poem, or nursery rhymes instead of a student's writing to model conferencing about what was memorable and what readers want more of. Ask questions such as, “What did you like about the book?” or “What did you like about the poem?” Model a response: “I liked the part of the book/poem that ...” Practice as a whole group, in small groups, or with partners sitting knee-to-knee or shoulder-to-shoulder.

The next day, read another poem. Ask students to tell you what they liked about the poem, then tell another student. Ask: “Why did the author do this?” “What did you like?” “What did you remember?” “If the author could change something, what would you change?”

Remember to MODEL! Work with the whole group, then small groups, then peers.

2. Focus on Stars and Add Wishes for More

Remember, these children are vulnerable! Be careful of their egos. Writing is really personal.

Use these conferencing steps:

  1. The author reads the piece.
  2. Listeners share stars (see section 1).
  3. The author reads the piece again.
  4. Listeners share wishes: “I wonder about ...”

The teacher should model for the whole group how to make helpful, appropriate comments. Ask: “What part was confusing?” and “What part needs to be clearer?” Start by having students say one thing they wonder about.

Don't tolerate negative comments. How does “stupid” help the writer? Model comments and questions such as:

  • This is what I like.
  • This is what I wonder.
  • When you wrote ________, then ________. How did that happen?

Teachers can write the kids' comments on paper and give them to the author. Ask: “How can we talk about the piece and make changes?”

In third grade, use sections 1 and 2. Follow the sequence: read the piece, discuss what was memorable, read the piece again, and use “more” to push plot development.

In fourth grade, use sections 1 and 2 at the beginning of the year. Continue modeling until students no longer need it.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1132.html