Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Density

By Sulan Dun

  • Science
  • Middle
Activity Time
1 hour
Materials
hardtop suitcase, tacky vacation souveniers, styrofoam
Concepts / Topics
Density - what is it - an intuitive approach that works

Density lesson plan

Students get confused by density = mass/volume because most of them haven't mastered ratios. Here's a more intuitive approach: do labs to define mass and volume, then show the density = mass/volume formula and do this demonstration.

1. Principle: If you pack more mass into the same volume, it's more dense.

Common experience: going on vacation with a suitcase that's too full to close.

  1. Show an open hardtop suitcase that you're taking on vacation, full of clothes. Close it, then get a student volunteer to come up and lift it.
  2. Open the suitcase and talk about how you always get sucked into buying stuff while on vacation. As you talk, toss in a bunch of tacky souvenirs and other knickknacks you've bought on vacation.
  3. Ask another volunteer to sit on the suitcase to help cram it shut and do up the locks. You want it visibly too full, so students can see that things are getting compressed.
  4. Ask the original volunteer to lift the suitcase again. Is it heavier? (Yes.) Ask the class whether the mass changed. Let them debate until they reach a consensus: yes, it increased.
  5. Ask whether the volume changed. (No, it's the same volume inside.) Is it more or less dense? At this point, only a few students will know it's more dense, so state the principle: if you put more mass into the same volume, it's more dense. Write this principle on the board.

2. Principle: If you pack the same mass into a smaller volume, it's more dense.

Common experience: crushing Styrofoam—for example, putting teeth marks on a Styrofoam cup.

  1. Show a block of Styrofoam. Get an energetic volunteer to jump on it until it's crushed a bit.
  2. Ask the class whether its mass changed. (No, it would still weigh the same on the scale.) Then ask whether its volume changed. (Yes, it's squished; it's smaller now.)
  3. Ask whether it's more or less dense. Let people hash it out for a while, then say, yes, it's more dense. Write the second principle on the board.

3. Principle: Just because something has more mass doesn't mean it's more dense.

Common experience: Styrofoam packing chips and a paper clip.

Preparation

Stuff a big, big plastic bag with Styrofoam packing chips until, to you, it feels obviously heavier than a paper clip.

Demonstration and discussion

  1. Get a student volunteer to hold the bag in one hand and the paper clip in the other, and say which feels heavier. If you have a strong bag and some time to kill, it's fun to have students toss the bag around the room at this point to get an idea of its weight.
  2. Ask students which is more dense: the paper clip or the bag of Styrofoam chips. At this point, I got an almost unanimous class vote for the paper clip, since it was obviously metal.
  3. Ask whether you could assume something was more dense just because it had more mass. Write the third principle on the board.
  4. Ask how you could tell whether one substance was denser than another. Try to avoid saying much here; let students debate and ask questions. It depends on how much mass is packed into a volume: if you had the same volume of two things, the one with more mass would be denser.

At this point, the students ruminated and asked me about possible scenarios—for example, if I smushed the bag down to be really, really small, could it be denser than the paper clip?

Summary

After the activity, ask students what they think the word density means. Collect their answers and list them in point form as notes on the overhead. Restate and rewrite the three principles.

Connecting density to math and ratios

This is a nice time to show the formula and integrate it with math and ratios. Run through the three scenarios above. Ask whether mass or volume increased and whether density increased. Ask whether the numerator or denominator is changing in each scenario and what effect that has on the ratio.

Speculate about:

  1. What sorts of changes in the numerator or denominator could increase a ratio?
  2. What sorts of changes in the numerator or denominator could decrease a ratio?

More teaching resources

See www.dun.org/sulan for more teaching-related stuff: the New Teacher Survival guide and shareware for teaching the elements and balancing equations.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/116.html