Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Classrooms That Work, Chapter Three Mailring Discussion

By deb

  • 4 Blocks
  • Elementary

The mailring discussion gathers teachers’ reflections and examples for teaching children to think while reading, including modeling, book previewing, questioning, journals, and stop-and-say strategies.

Classrooms That Work is written by Patricia Cunningham and Richard Allington. The 4 Blocks mailring is discussing the book chapter by chapter.

Thinking While Reading

On page 50, Cunningham reminds us that in order to think while you read, you must:

  1. Have a mindset that reading is thinking and a determination to make sense of what you are reading.
  2. Have sufficient background knowledge that you call up and try to connect to the new information.
  3. Be familiar with the type of text and be able to see how the author has organized the ideas.
  4. Be able to identify almost all of the words.

Knowing that these four conditions must be in place in order for reading/thinking to take place, we can now consider what kind of lessons and activities we might engage children in that will ensure that they will learn to think while they read.

I find as I talk and write about implementing guided reading, I become lost in the details of implementing it. This is a good passage to keep posted in my lesson plans so that, as I plan my 30–40 minutes of guided reading activities daily, I remember my focus.

Shared Reading Criteria

Shared reading has four criteria (pages 51–52):

  1. Very predictable text, without too much print, with repetitive sentence patterns and pictures to support those patterns.
  2. Very appealing to children.
  3. The book should go somewhere in your curriculum.
  4. Print large enough that the kids can see it.

Flexible Groups in Guided Reading

Vicki’s Question

Hi all—I have a question regarding chapter 3. As I am new to 4 Blocks, perhaps I don't quite understand the guided reading block. I thought I understood that it was not done in groups. However, on page 76, directions are given to “call 4–5 children together” for a lesson. Am I not understanding how this block works, or have I just missed the point completely? HELP! Also, if any of you teach first grade and want to guide me through the first few weeks of school, I'd appreciate it! Thanks.

Vicki

Deb’s Response

I asked Dottie about this specific question. She said the answer lies in understanding the philosophy of 4 Blocks. You can pull a FLEXIBLE group of kids of all abilities during guided reading, maybe SSR, maybe writing too, even during a non–4 Blocks time like centers. But the difference is that you would have kids who can read included in the group, not just the low kids. Haven't we all had low kids in previous years who really didn't make great gains? If we stick them together in the guided reading F&P way without a model, they are the low group with a different name.

Her point was that the children need direct instruction in all the blocks, not just the guided reading block. She also reminded me that guided reading focusing on the comprehension aspect only works WITH all three of the other blocks.

Dottie Hall probably explained this better than I did.

deb

Explicit Instruction and Comprehension

I have been reading chapter three, as many of you have also. I was struck by the second paragraph on page 47 of Cunningham and Allington's book:

"Making sure that children are reading and writing is necessary for their growth. For many children, this essential component, while necessary, is not sufficient. Research (listed in book) clearly demonstrates that struggling readers make more rapid progress when given explicit instruction in how to read and write."

The next paragraph goes on to say:

“Comprehension is the focus of this chapter. Specifically, it will describe how teachers carry out lessons and how they structure activities that teach children how to ‘think as they read.’ The focus on thinking is inevitable because that's what reading really is—thinking stimulated by words on a page.”

I loved the example at the bottom of the page that reminds us that children are able to think about a ballgame. I too wonder why some children don't think while they read. What can I do to ensure that students are thinking about their reading? What are the techniques that I use to teach thinking?

Listening/Reading Transfer

Deb’s Request for Examples

Many of us have read Mosaic of Thought by Ellin Keene. That book focused on teaching kids to think about thinking. I think the listening/reading transfer lessons (pages 69–71 of Classrooms That Work) tie together with Mosaic of Thought. I am wondering how you teach the listening/reading transfer lessons. I would love more examples of using L/RT (Listening/Reading Transfer). Does anyone have a book they used with this that they could share? How did you do it? What did you say? What books were good books to use?

deb

Diane’s Suggested Approach

Deb, I just read your post and then reread pages 69–71 in Classrooms That Work. I have never really done an L/RT but am very interested in hearing if others are and what they do.

As I think of this along with Mosaic, I wonder if we couldn't do this with the questioning that Ellin describes in chapter 6. It actually is what she has done.

Listening

Read something, then ask the kids what questions they have. Read a little more, then ask if questions were answered and what new questions they have. This process of questioning/answering/questioning is kind of like the predicting/confirming/adjusting/predicting process we go through as we read.

Reading Transfer

Tell the kids to read a selection, then jot down their questions. Remind them to do the same kind of thinking and listening to the questions in their heads as they did when they listened to the teacher read.

I've never done this but think I will try very soon in the school year. Think it could work?

Diane/3/IL

MJ Solomon: Ways to Teach That Reading Is Thinking

Well, I have already weighed in on this subject, but since things are quiet, I will post again. This is the point where the strategies we learned in Mosaic of Thought come in. This is where we teach kids that reading is thinking.

Some things I do (sorry if you've heard it before):

Listening to Ourselves Read

I tell my kids the true story of the little first grader who just couldn't learn to read. His teacher was very frustrated because he just couldn't figure out reading. They worked all year, but he couldn't do it. Well, one day late in April, the little boy came running up to the teacher's reading group and said, “I can read! I can read!” Even though he was interrupting her reading group, she stopped everything to hear him read. He read from a book: “The man went out on the lake in his yellow boat.” Well! The teacher was impressed and the child was beaming. But being a teacher, she couldn't help but ask the little boy a comprehension question: “What color was the boat?”

Well, the little boy got mad. He said, “You told me I had to READ what it said! You didn't tell me I had to LISTEN!!”

So this always gets us started on how we have to listen to ourselves as we read. When I'm at storytime, I find myself distracted by kids playing with their shoelaces or playing with each other's hair. I stop and tell them that I have to reread because, even though they couldn't tell, I had been watching the distraction and not listening to a word that I read—even though I didn't miss a beat or even lack expression as I read.

Previewing Books

We practice previewing books before we read them. We do picture walks and make observations and wonderings about a story before we read it. They like to do this as a small group on a large sheet of paper with markers. Just by browsing the story, they write:

  • Two things they observed about the story.
  • Two things they wonder about the story.
  • Two things they predict will happen in the story.

Then we share the posters with the class. Then we read the story and see if any of our predictions were right and if any of our wonderings were answered.

Reading Journals

One of the journal activities I ask the kids to do is to tell me what they were thinking as they were reading. One little boy was reading about the snowfall in Little House in the Big Woods, and he wrote that he was thinking about going to visit his sister in Maryland when it was also snowing.

A lot of my kids wrote that they were thinking how they would do things differently than the character. For example, in the scene in Little House in the Big Woods where Pa doesn't shoot the deer at the end, some of my kids said they were thinking that they understood that, but felt he should have done it anyway because he had to feed his kids.

Modeling Thinking

I model what I'm thinking as I read all the time. It's pretty easy to do. If you are listening to the story, your brain is telling you all sorts of things—what we learned in Mosaic of Thought—and all you have to do is share it with kids so they get the idea.

Say Something Strategy

We do the Say Something Strategy, which I mentioned already here. Students determine chunks of text they will read before they stop and “say something” about what they read. They either say it to a partner, write it on a sticky note, or just say it to themselves. This is a check because if they can't think of anything to say about what they just read, they need to reread that chunk.

Judy Folster: Thinking Aloud

Hello. One thing that I do to “teach thinking” is to think aloud as I read to them, so I'm modeling what I want them to do.

Blah, blah, blah…

  • This reminds me of my first day at school.
  • That must have felt terrible when everyone laughed at her.
  • I wish I could do that.
  • I wonder how this problem will be solved.
  • Now why did the author do that?
  • I enjoyed another book by this author.
  • Can't wait to see what happens next.
  • Oh, I think I know what they'll do!
  • I don't know this word, but I know what this part says.
  • I don't know what this word means, but I know that tri means three, so…

Cheryl Ristow: Everyone Read to Find

Another little trick to teach thinking while reading is, after reading a story or passage, have everyone ERT—“everyone read to find ________” (What is the name of this character? How does he/she feel? Where are they going? etc.). I really like doing this technique.

Cheryl Ristow, Fullerton, CA

Btillman: Conversation and Curiosity

“btilllman” sent this to deb regarding thinking while reading. I thought it would be of interest to the whole 4 Blocks mailring, so I am sending it to the ring:

btillman wrote:

Regarding thinking while reading, many students who have had this problem with me are from families where interaction is at a minimum. The parents rarely speak to their children, and as a result, they have very poor language skills. Sometimes referred to as “mother talk,” I prefer to consider it “parent talk,” but the talking we do to our toddlers at home during daily work builds the foundation for these thought patterns.

For instance, my 3-year-old and I made a cake for my mom's birthday. She had a million questions to ask, and all during the process we were talking. In a sense, her questions were causing me to think out loud as I baked. “What's that?” “It's coconut.” “Where does it come from?” “A tree.” Etc., etc. Children who miss out on this come to school without that wild curiosity—they've never had anyone to listen to their questions or answer them, so they just quit asking. Maybe our thinking out loud can reawaken that curiosity.

Kathy Carson: Different Ways of Thinking While Reading

I have a few thoughts about thinking and reading. My husband can read a novel in about one-quarter the time that I can, and remembers the plot and motivations of characters well enough to discuss it with me if I read the same book after him. He is obviously thinking while he reads, but I doubt he hears the words. I read slowly, hearing the accents and intonations, often rereading to try to figure out where people are or why they do what they do. We both think while we are reading, but differently.

My children can't stand to have my husband read to them. He reads out loud in a very monotonous voice, with little excitement. The sound of the words isn't important to him. They love me to read to them because I get into the sounds of the words.

When my 8-year-old son reads to himself or listens to me read to him, he becomes the characters. I can see his body posture change as he reads and experiences the story. He has even been known to dress in a costume to read. But spoken language is difficult for him. He can't always get his point across easily with words. But he loves to read. My intelligent, A-student sixth grader hates to read. She likes to think, but she doesn't like to imagine. She's logical.

I love all of the strategies that have been discussed this week for helping people think while they read. We just have to remember that everyone thinks differently. I think we have to be sure to cover strategies for the visual reader and the auditory one, as well as those who “become” the character and experience the stories as they read, and those who don't really imagine much. If we make a conscious effort to cover all kinds of thinkers in our strategies throughout the year, we'll really be teaching everyone!

Kathy

Laura: Higher-Level Thinking in the Primary Grades

Page 47:

“There is a myth about children who have difficulty with reading comprehension, which is that they ‘just can't think!’ In reality, everybody thinks all the time and some struggling readers, who must take care of themselves (and often younger brothers and sisters), are especially good thinkers and problem solvers. If children can ‘predict’ that the ballgame will be canceled when they see the sky darkening up and can ‘conclude’ that the coach is mad about something when he walks in with a scowl on his face, then they can and do engage in ‘higher-level’ thinking processes.”

This really gets back to the practice of underestimating what children are capable of doing. We need to challenge our children, even the younger ones, and allow them to work through higher-level comprehension strategies. Yes, I know what we were all taught in college about Piaget's theories; however, time and time again, when presented with the option to do just this, children amaze us. I was truly amazed at what my first graders were able to accomplish this year. When presented with a task in guided reading, and given the opportunity and freedom to explore, they really rose to the occasion. Discussion groups during guided reading were a key element to my success.

I've also found that the ideas we were presented with in Mosaic of Thought really complement this chapter. They lay the groundwork for using these higher-level thinking skills in primary classes. When I asked the author, Ellin Keene, when she would begin teaching these types of skills, she responded, “Day 1 in Kind.” She further stated that they are researching the results of doing activities in PreK.

As the focus of education now shifts to the early childhood years, I think we will see a move to introduce these strategies at an earlier age than once deemed appropriate. Personally, I applaud such a move, but we must remember to keep it in perspective. In the early years we are laying the foundation that will be further developed in later years. This would be the immersion and exposure that is so lacking in today's curriculum.

Laura

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1217.html