Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Mock Trial

By Charlotte Estep

  • Literature
  • Senior
Activity Time
One week
Materials
Mock Trial information from State Bar Association
Concepts / Topics
Integration of Social Studies and Literature

Students use an incident from Beowulf to prepare and conduct a trial, taking roles, investigating and questioning witnesses, preparing a brief, and deciding a verdict.

After the traditional reading and discussion of BEOWULF, we put one of the main characters on trial.

Trial Preparation and Procedure

  1. Freeze the action after one of these incidents:

    • Grendel kills thirty Danes.
    • Grendel kills one of Beowulf’s men, a Geat.
    • Beowulf uses devices to trap Grendel into coming to Heorot.
  2. Students decide which crime will be the trial issue.
  3. After a mini-lesson on trial language and participants, students select the roles they will undertake. I give a quiz on terms from the mini-lesson. Students who score highest on the quiz select roles.
  4. Lawyers for the defense and prosecution conduct an investigation.
  5. Students who choose to be witnesses must go to the text to decide just what they saw.
  6. Investigators question witnesses and the defendant.
  7. Attorneys prepare a brief.
  8. A jury is selected from social studies classes of underclass students.
  9. The trial commences.
  10. The jury retires to consider its verdict.
  11. The jury returns its verdict.

Teaching Notes

I fear I have left out so much “stuff.” But this unit forces students to return to the text—they have to read, discuss, and understand it to prepare for trial.

I encourage as much formality as possible. It would be ideal if an attorney or judge could come to talk to students. I record the entire process, usually on audio.

The jury has been critical and serious about the whole process. I have been doing this for three years. Last year was the first year I had students who had served on the jury. They could not wait to begin the trial.

This is an integrated unit that administrators love. The students love it too. As a side benefit, they learn about BEOWULF, the poem, and can understand the universality of this piece of literature.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1232.html