Classrooms That Work Chapter 6 Mailring Discussions
- 4 Blocks
- Elementary

- Concepts / Topics
A collection of teacher-contributed approaches for using nonfiction texts in science and social studies, including text-feature hunts, literature circles, guided reading, and online astronomy reading.
Previewing a Science or Social Studies Chapter
Cheryl did this great lesson on a social studies text at a workshop. It would work for science, too. I can't wait to try it this year.
- Have the kids read the title of the chapter and close their books. On a web on the overhead or board, write the chapter title in the middle. Ask them what they already know about the topic. (We did it on the subtropics.) Make the spokes coming off the center circle in black pen. Record their responses in black.
- Next, have them open their books and read just the subtitles. Close their books and have them tell you any new knowledge they learned. Record this in a different color of ink.
- Have them open their books and read any boldface or italicized words and the sentences they are in. Close the books and add what they learned to the web in a third color.
- Have them look at any pictures, graphs, charts, diagrams, etc., and read the captions. Close the books and add what they learned to the web in a fourth color.
By this time you have recalled background knowledge, discussed vocabulary, given them a mental framework of the sequence of the text and previewed important information they will read about. Pretty nifty, huh?
Diane/3/IL
Nonfiction Scavenger Hunt
This past year I worked really hard to teach my third graders how to “read” nonfiction. I taught mini-lessons on the text structures common in nonfiction texts: headings, subheadings, labels, diagrams, charts, guide words, captions, etc. I used big books to show them actual examples. We posted these in a list on chart paper as we discussed how they help us “read.”
I then gave each student a different nonfiction book (from Rigby, Newbridge, Sundance, etc.) and had them do a Nonfiction Scavenger Hunt. I wrote a several-page guide listing all the components of nonfiction that might be in a book and had students search for them. They had to put the page number and describe each one they found. Some books did not have all the elements, so look through the books yourself first.
For the most part, the students seemed to really like this activity. It was one way I could assess whether they understood what I was hoping to teach. I did not “grade” these. I skimmed and searched at random to give ME feedback on whether I had accomplished my goal.
After doing this lesson, spread out over 2–3 days, I put all the books used for the scavenger hunt together in a book basket. The kids seemed to gravitate to these books for SSR. I was surprised how many more of them were choosing to read nonfiction after that.
Ginger
Literature Circles for Nonfiction
Here is something I'm going to try this year after reading Harvey Daniels's book Literature Circles. I have used a form of this in the past, but after reading his book, I think the process will be much better defined in my mind and have more structure for the kids.
Organizing the Reading
Form groups of 4–5 kids each. Divide the text into logical parts, usually using the subtitles. I will have each group read the same section, later coming together to share and compare. Students should use sticky notes to help them locate the parts of the text they wish to bring into the discussion.
The text can be read in class or assigned to be read outside of class. Either way, assign the role sheets first so students have a purpose for reading. The role sheets will give this more structure this year; I didn't use them last year.
Role Sheets
- Discussion Director: Your job is to develop a list of questions that your group might want to discuss about today's reading. Try to determine what is important about today's text. Try to think of the BIG IDEA here.
- Passage Master: Your job is to locate a few special sections of the reading that the group should look back on. The idea is to help your group notice the most interesting, funny, puzzling, or important passages.
- Vocabulary Enricher: Your job is to be on the lookout for a few especially important words—new, interesting, strange, important, puzzling, or unfamiliar words that the group needs to remember or understand.
- Connector: Your job is to find connections between the material you are reading and the world outside, and to other things in the text that we have previously discussed.
- Illustrator (optional): Your job is to draw some kind of picture related to the reading. It can be a sketch, diagram, flow chart, or stick figure scene.
Discussing the Text
After reading the text, the group meets and the Discussion Director leads the group. As the director asks the questions on the role sheet, the others bring their assigned roles into the discussion to answer the questions and discuss the text.
The next day, I plan to have a whole-group discussion to determine what was important about the text. This can be noted on a graphic organizer.
I highly recommend this book to help teachers teach nonfiction as well as fiction.
Diane/3/IL
Science and Social Studies in Guided Reading
I used my science books last year for guided reading, and it worked out great! I also have an older set that is better than our current science book, so I use both. Both have lots of decent, simple experiments.
Sometimes I let the students take the books home and do the experiment there. Actually, they usually beg me to let them do this, and I act like it's their idea and that I'm “giving in” to them. Heh! Heh! Heh! Seems to work out pretty well. The supplies are usually household items, and the parents have been enthusiastic. Seems to be like spelling—something the parents can really grab onto.
We also have quite a few sets (6 each) of good science-related books that I can use, too. The same goes for social studies. I use my book for the first few chapters—maps, continents, landforms. Then I switch to biographies and history-related books for guided reading.
I have the book Daily Oral Geography, and I use it about once a week in our morning activities. Since I'm a geography freak, I have lots of maps around for students to use.
Astronomy Picture of the Day
Another thing I use for science is the Astronomy Picture of the Day website. It's got a huge archive that can be loaded with thumbnail images. I turn the students loose on that. They pick a picture, and it loads the bigger version with an explanation. They have to read that to find out what the picture is. Most are motivated enough to give it a pretty good try. I let them do it in pairs on their own.
Becky
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1250.html