Mysteries for Guided Reading
- 4 Blocks
- Elementary

- Concepts / Topics
The author advises a teacher to scaffold chapter reading through clue seeking, partner and echo reading, predictions, clue marking, and discussion.
Fluency and Looking for Meaning
I think fluency develops through rereading easier texts when children get to third grade. The poems and easier books I read with my second graders are the ones I build on for fluency.
Last year, a third-grade teacher was trying to show her students that they could solve mysteries in the books they were reading. The hints were right in the chapters if they noticed them. This is what she did.
Chapter 1: Looking for Clues
The teacher began with a picture walk through the chapter, saying aloud some of the vocabulary the children would need. She set the purpose: “Find clues to solve the mystery.” Then the children read chorally in pairs.
After the partners finished reading, the teacher held a whole-group discussion. It went badly! The children didn't find any real clues and could hardly discuss what the chapter was about. They knew the characters, setting, and problem, but they didn't GET that they were reading a mystery and looking for clues. She wrote “CLUES TO SOLVE THE MYSTERY” on the board and listed their few off-the-wall comments underneath.
At this point, I suggested she stay with the same teaching point: looking for clues. She wanted to reread the chapter to them, stopping at every clue. I suggested that she read Chapter 1 to them if she wanted to, but then go on. Don't emphasize the right answer. We wanted the children to search for mystery clues, not “find the answer the teacher is looking for.” She was reluctant, but she said, “OK.” Her tone implied I was crazy!
Chapter 2: Partner Reading and Predictions
She did the picture walk again. Even though the chapter was new, most of the vocabulary was repeated from the first chapter. Again, the children read with partners, looking for clues to the mystery. This time, the stronger reader read and the weaker reader echoed. They discussed clues, then wrote a quick prediction of what they thought would happen in 3–5 sentences. Those who wanted to share did.
After class, we talked again. She said, “Oh Debbie! This isn't working! They aren't doing it!” I said, “Be patient.” I suggested that the next day she read a page and have them echo read. The book wasn't too hard, but I knew she was worrying that the children didn't know the words and therefore needed more teacher guidance.
Chapter 3: Echo Reading and Revising Predictions
She set the purpose: “Look for clues to the mystery. See if your prediction is coming true.” She had the children sit shoulder to shoulder with their partners; there were only 10 books. She read a page, about 10 lines, and then they read it. She asked, “Any clues? Anyone want to change your prediction?” She continued through the chapter, stopping after each page to ask about clues and changes to predictions.
This chapter was better analyzed, but the children still had ownership. They added to their predictions or changed them.
After class, we talked about the scaffolding she was using. Even though the children could read all the words, they weren't looking for meaning. They could answer the story-map questions, but not the “meat” questions. She was now showing them what she meant by looking for clues in the chapter. She felt the class went much more smoothly.
Chapter 4: Marking Clues
She set the purpose: “Read with your partner for clues to the mystery. Check whether your prediction is coming true or what changes you are making to it.”
For this chapter, she let the children partner read however they wanted. She realized that they knew all the words in this below-level book; they just didn't know the thinking yet. She gave them sticky notes to help them remember where the clues were. During class discussion, the children were making predictions that made sense in the chapter AND finding clues.
After class, she said, “They get it. They really do.”
Chapter 5: Solving the Mystery
For the last chapter, she set the purpose: “Find out about the end of the mystery.”
In the class discussion afterward, the children started talking about how they knew the solution. My friend referred them back to the books: “Where was that clue? What chapter was it in?” They looked through the chapters, giving page numbers. They were so excited, and so was the teacher!
Continuing with Mysteries
I am not naming the mystery series because this would work with any series. The children read more of these mysteries, making lists of clues. They moved on into SSR time, and the mystery basket was very popular.
Remember: model, enable, show them. If it doesn't work on the first day, try it again. —deb
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1271.html