Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

American Literature Perspective Debate

By Amy Lepore

  • Literature
  • Senior
Activity Time
2-3 class periods for reading, comparing, writi
Materials
Various excerpts and writings from both Native Americans and Colonial authors
Concepts / Topics
Colonial America

Students read Native American traditional poems and creation myths alongside Colonial works, compare their tone, purpose, and point of view, then debate Native American and settler perspectives.

Read and Compare

For years, I have introduced American literature with recordings of Native American traditional poems and creation myths, as well as the usual Colonial pieces by Smith, Byrd, Bradstreet, Rowlandson, Knight, Columbus, Edwards, etc.

I ask students to compare the tone, purpose, point of view, etc., of these pieces and their authors.

Stage a Debate

Then we stage a debate where half the class represents the Native Americans and half represents the settlers. We consider these questions:

  • Which group is right in their way of thinking?
  • Whose point of view and way of living is correct?

I use a basic debate format and ask members of the gifted English or debate class to come score my students’ performance. We learn a lot and have great fun in the process!

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1500.html