Proofreading and Editing Marks
- Reading/Writing
- Elementary

- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
- Resource Type
The teacher demonstrates proofreading marks, students identify and mark errors together in a charted passage, then practice independently on a worksheet.
Lesson Overview
Topic/Subject Area: Proofreading—Language Arts, Grade 2
Teacher: Carissa Moungey
Students should have previous knowledge of the writing process.
Materials and Equipment
- Proofreading marks chart
- Proofreading example from a story the students have read before: a paragraph or two on chart paper with deliberate mistakes
- Sentence strips with examples of proofreading marks
- Independent practice worksheets
Objectives
Students will learn about editing and proofreading marks.
Students will identify errors in a passage from _______ and then determine and use the correct proofreading mark. Satisfactory performance is 8 out of 11 errors for the first lesson and 10 out of 11 for subsequent lessons.
Motivation and Rationale
Use “Changes, Changes” (from Story Studio) or any book about how “real” books are published that includes information about the editing process.
Directed Lesson Sequence
First, review the proofreading marks. Use the sentence strips to clearly demonstrate the use of each one.
Guided Group Practice
Say, “Now let’s try proofreading and adding the marks together.”
Call on each student to come up to the paragraph chart, find one error, and write in the appropriate proofreading mark. If a student has trouble, allow them to choose another student to help. There are 20 changes to be made. Check for understanding and distribute independent practice.
Independent Practice
Provide a worksheet with a paragraph just like the guided practice, but from another section of the story. Do not give students any surprises in independent practice that were not discussed during guided practice. For the first time around, I tell them how many mistakes there are.
Alternate and Supplementary Activities
- Remedial or ESL: Sentence strips with errors.
- Advanced: Longer paragraphs or a more advanced passage.
Evaluation, Summary, and Closure
Ask a student to give the first step in the writing process, ask another for the second, and so on. Ask which step we learned about today (proofreading). Ask how they can use this knowledge (in their writing).
After two or so more lessons, I usually require students to add this to their writing process in writers’ workshop.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1650.html