Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Homeless or Luxurious

By Kim Levine

  • Career Technical Education
  • Mathematics
  • English Language Arts
  • Senior
Activity Time
5-7 working school hours
Materials
Internet Access
Concepts / Topics
Careers and Consumer Science
Resource Type
Lesson Plan

Students research living expenses for assigned cities and incomes, record and compare budgets, then choose a city and budget on a $23,000 income.

Lesson overview

Business–Workplace Readiness, Grades 9–12

Students draw a city and an annual income from a hat, using the city and income assignments below. They use the Internet to research the expenses of living in that city and record their findings on Checklist 1. When finished, students put their work on the board and compare costs from city to city.

For the culminating activity, students receive a set annual income of $23,000, choose the city where they want to live, and complete Checklist 2. The purpose is to show students how their career choices can affect where and how they live.

Purpose and learning goals

  • Function as economically literate citizens by developing personal consumer economic skills, knowledge of social and government responsibility, and an understanding of business operations.
  • Select and apply technology tools to personal and business decision making.

Our mission statement at East Buchanan is: “To challenge students to think critically, communicate effectively, develop values, and contribute to society.” This project connects with developing values and contributing to society. Students examine how their occupations and earnings relate to their contributions to society. Someone who makes little money can still contribute to society, though in a different manner.

The project simulates a real-world experience. Students make a monthly budget, make appropriate choices to live within their means, and hear about the trials and tribulations of classmates working with less fortunate circumstances.

Consumer skills

  • Compare prices, services, variety, and quality for the same or similar items and decide which is the best choice.
  • Explain the value of advertising to consumers and give an example of deceptive, misleading, or illegal advertising.
  • List specific guidelines for selecting affordable housing, choosing a roommate, signing a lease, and furnishing an apartment or home.
  • Name and explain the purpose of laws and groups that protect consumers.
  • List specific criteria that will help with a prudent automobile purchase.
  • Describe various types of insurance and explain why insurance is important for protection from certain risks.

This learning connects to Math, Family Consumer Sciences, and English.

Preparation and instruction

Chapter 18, “Being a Consumer: So Many Choices,” in Preparing for Career Success lays the foundation for this project. It addresses food, clothing, and high-ticket items; the effects of advertising and media on consumers; finding a place to live; renting and deciding whether to have a roommate; apartment hunting; tenant and landlord rights and responsibilities; furnishing an apartment; buying a home; consumer rights and responsibilities; writing complaint letters; consumer contacts and information; consumer fraud; and purchasing, financing, and insuring a first automobile, used or new.

Concepts to discuss

  • The difference between gross pay and net pay.
  • How much it costs to take two or three showers per day.
  • How much it costs to leave the lights on for two or three days.
  • How much groceries cost for a week or a month.

Talk students through each expense. Have them talk with their parents about the monthly cost of running their household. Finally, put the teacher’s actual budget on the board.

Project sequence

  1. Have students draw a city and annual income from a hat. The first part of the lesson is primarily teacher directed, apart from this drawing.
  2. Have students use the Internet to research living expenses in their assigned cities and complete Checklist 1 individually.
  3. Have students put their work on the board and compare expenses across cities.
  4. Give students an annual income of $23,000 and let them choose their own cities. Have them research expenses again and complete Checklist 2.

Teaching strategies

Use hands-on activities with the Internet and a scored discussion. A scored discussion sheet is available at: edservices.aea7.k12.ia.us/framework/strategies/index.html

I believe the Internet research and hands-on activities will excite students about the project and help them consider a possible real-life situation.

Each student has Internet access and a different city and income assignment, so no two completed checklists should contain the same information. Students may listen to others and gather ideas, but they should complete their own checklists individually.

Assessment

Consider how realistically students have represented their circumstances and living conditions. Grade the accuracy of their sheets. Students also evaluate the information their classmates put on the board.

Use the checklists to have students compare their information with classmates’ findings and check its accuracy.

Materials and resources

Books and media

  • Preparing for Career Success, Chapter 18, “Being a Consumer: So Many Choices.”
  • Streetwise, a Chicago newspaper sold by homeless people in Chicago.
  • Homeless in America, a video.

Community resources

  • Rich Roepke — insurance agent, Roepke Insurance Agency.
  • Jerry Slattery — owner of Townhouse Apartments.
  • Kathy Cole — real estate agent.

Technology resources

  • Internet access.
  • National Alliance to End Homelessness: Background and Statistics — http://www.endhomelessness.org/back/index.htm
  • Egrocery — http://www.egrocery.net/
  • Apartment.com — http://www.apartment.com
  • Insurance.com — http://www.insurance.com/

Guest speakers discuss insurance, real estate, and owning an apartment. The project also includes a video about homelessness and copies of a newspaper printed and written by homeless people in Chicago. These different perspectives help give students a sense of the complete project. With so many facets, students who do not enjoy one part may find another part engaging.

Management and support

Students work independently in the computer lab with Internet access, while sharing ideas and information with one another. Each computer carousel has five computers. The lab’s physical layout cannot be changed, but its stations allow students to share information as they find it.

My room is available from 7:30 until 3:30. With special arrangements, the instructor can come earlier or stay later.

Students with special needs receive the same assignment, with website addresses supplied when the project begins. They still need to type in the URLs.

Make sure Internet access is available on every computer in the lab.

In our district, an aide is assigned when a class has more than three students with special needs during the same hour. Otherwise, the teacher gives the assignment to the special education instructor before presenting it in class, allowing extra time for that instructor and the student.

Checklist 1 for Homeless or Luxurious Project

Name____________________________________________________
City_____________________________________________________
Annual Income ____________________________________________
Net Income_______________________________________________
Net Income per month ______________________________________
Food
At Home __________
Dining Out __________
Utilities
Gas/Fuel __________
Electricity __________
Telephone __________
Water __________
Clothing
Personal Care- (include haircut, toiletries etc.) __________
Insurance
Life __________
Health __________
Dental __________
Automobile __________
Mode of Transportation __________
Savings and Investments __________
Recreation __________
Gifts __________
Miscellaneous __________
Total __________ __________

Checklist 2 for Homeless or Luxurious Project

Name____________________________________________________
City You choose the city
Annual Income $23,000
Net Income_______________________________________________
Net Income per month ______________________________________
Food
At Home __________
Dining Out __________
Utilities
Gas/Fuel __________
Electricity __________
Telephone __________
Water __________
Clothing
Personal Care- (include haircut, toiletries etc.) __________
Insurance
Life __________
Health __________
Dental __________
Automobile __________
Mode of Transportation __________
Savings and Investments __________
Recreation __________
Gifts __________
Miscellaneous __________
Total __________

Cities and Amount of Money

CityAnnual income
Los Angeles, CA$10,000
Naples, FL$11,500
New York City, NY$12,000
Minneapolis, MN$14,000
Chicago, IL$15,000
Sioux Falls$17,500
St. Paul, MN$18,000
St. Louis, MO$20,000
Des Moines, IA$22,000
Seattle, WA$22,750
Wichita, KS$23,000
Birmingham, AL$24,00
Boston, MA$26,000
Atlanta, GA$27,000
Winthrop, IA$30,000
Philadelphia, PA$32,000
Las Vegas, NV$35,000
Washington, D.C.$40,000
Dallas, TX$45,000
Fargo, ND$50,000

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1807.html