Measuring the Earth (Eratoshenes' method)
- Mathematics
- Senior

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
Teacher: Colbe C. Mazzarella • Date: June 27, 2000
Class: Sixth Grade Math & History • Unit: Greek Geometry • Five lessons
Unit Overview
Overview: As we study Greece in Ancient Civilizations, we explore Greek math and science.
Essential Questions
- How was mathematics developed?
- What does math explain about our world?
Student Goal
Students will be able to reproduce Eratosthenes' measurement of the Earth.
Acknowledgments
Material from the following sources has been used in these lesson plans:
- http://k12science.stevens-tech.edu/~ihor/sketch/paper_gsp.html
- http://k12science.ati.stevens-tech.edu/noonday/noon.html
- http://www.ehhs.cmich.edu/~harwoodd/Pi.html
- http://ericir.syr.edu/Virtual/Lessons/Mathematics/Geometry/GEO0004.html
Habits of Mind
Using mathematical skills to interpret information and solve problems, reflecting confidence in ability to do mathematics, exploring the relationship of mathematics to other subject areas, exploring mathematics in the course of daily life, integrating mathematics within a larger network of ideas, appreciating the beauty and fascination of mathematics, viewing mathematics in unconventional ways, generating new ways of thinking.
Massachusetts Frameworks
Students engage in problem solving, communicating, reasoning, and connecting to represent and solve problems, using geometric models.
Prerequisite Knowledge
- Determine pi by measuring circular objects.
- Demonstrate that equal pairs of angles are formed when a line intersects parallel lines. Use the paper-folding method from http://k12science.stevens-tech.edu/~ihor/sketch/paper_gsp.html.
- Analyze data by removing outliers, computing averages, and finding percentage of error.
- Express measurements as a proportion and solve for an unknown.
- Find a website when given the address, and use a mouse to drag and drop.
- Describe the extent of the volumes in the library at Alexandria.
Obstacles and Solutions
This is a unique lesson, and timing could be hard to predict. Timing is especially important because the culminating exercise for the five lessons must take place at noon on the equinox. Students could misuse materials. Keep the pace moving smoothly to minimize gaps.
Do a dry run of the lesson to check timing and spot potential slow spots. Have teams picked out in advance with a mix of skill levels.
Unit Preparations
- Schedule the unit to begin four days before the equinox.
- Contact another school located at some distance from our school, preferably through the Noon Shadow Project: http://k12science.ati.stevens-tech.edu/noonday/noon.html. (Alternatively, use a point on the Equator as a reference location.)
- Ask principal about photo releases. Call local newspaper to suggest that they send a photographer when students measure the earth.
- Prepare press release including diagram and names of all students as Certified Geometers.
- Determine what time the sun will be highest on the date of the equinox; this is not 12:00 p.m. in all locations.
Day 1: Eratosthenes' Method
Listed class time: 40 minutes.
Materials
- Math journals and globe
- The Librarian Who Measured the Earth by Kathryn Lasky. Although this is sold by Amazon for ages four through eight, it has been reviewed as suitable for third through fifth grade, and it uses an engaging, aesthetic approach to an adult-level problem in mathematics.
Learning Objective
At the end of Lesson 1, students will be able to describe Eratosthenes' method of measuring the world from a personal and historical perspective.
Lesson Procedures
10:00 — Introduction. Remind students that we previously learned that the derivation of geometry (geo, earth, and metria, measurement) related to its use for surveying land. Explain that we will now use geometry to literally measure the Earth, making us geometers.
- When was it known that the Earth was round? (By 300 BC.)
- How was that discovered? (Observations such as the circular shadow of the Earth in an eclipse, ships apparently sinking below the horizon, etc.)
- Can we measure the Earth using the methods we have learned for measuring circles? (We can't drill a tunnel through the Earth to measure its diameter.)
- How can the size of the Earth be measured? (Driving, flying, orbiting around the Earth.)
10:10 — Read The Librarian Who Measured the Earth by Kathryn Lasky aloud to students, showing them the illustrations.
Locate Alexandria and Syene on the globe.
- 10:30 — Students sketch Eratosthenes' experiment in journals, with equal pairs of angles labeled.
- 10:40 — End.
Modifications
Walk around to show pictures and globe to students with limited vision or attention span.
Assignment
Students will write and illustrate a two-page story of Eratosthenes' measurement of the world from the point of view of his slave who paced out the distance from Alexandria to Syene.
Assessment
- Walk around the room and review sketches for rough accuracy.
- Read stories in journals for accuracy.
Day 2: A Miniature Measurement
Listed class time: 40 minutes.
Preparations
Rehearse all physical demonstrations.
Materials
- Math journals, protractor, calculator, and safety geometric compass for each student
- Orange, grapefruit, cantaloupe, honeydew melon, toothpicks, flashlight, marker, and knife
Learning Objectives
At the end of Lesson 2, students will be able to conduct a miniature version of Eratosthenes' method of measuring the world and understand the limitations of the miniature. Students will also be able to reproduce Eratosthenes' diagram and use it to find a circumference.
Lesson Procedures
10:00 — Insert two toothpicks into each fruit and use a marker to label them A and S, for Alexandria and Syene.
Dim classroom lights and shine flashlight onto fruit. Turn fruit so that light shines directly on toothpick at S and it does not cast a shadow. Mark length of shadow of toothpick at A. Repeat for each fruit. Write measurements on board (length of shadow, height of toothpick)
10:10 — Have each student diagram all four demonstrations in a journal, using a protractor and compass, and write in measurements for each fruit.
Write the proportion on the board: angle : 360 = distance : circumference.
Have each student use the proportion to solve for the circumference of each fruit, then use the circumference to find the radius of each fruit.
10:25 — Measure the actual radius and circumference of each fruit and post on the blackboard.
Slice orange along the "equator" to show how angles meet at the center.
Ask students what sources of error might exist in this experiment: non-spherical fruit, moving shadow, or mismeasurement.
- 10:40 — End.
Modifications
If students are having difficulty with the concept, have them compare the fruit to the sketch. Redo calculations if necessary.
Assignment
Students recalculate radii and circumferences, underestimating each shadow by one millimeter. Ask them to look for the pattern of error introduced for various-sized fruits. One millimeter is a larger percentage of error in the smallest fruit.
To be graded and redone if calculations are not 100% correct. This will show that students have mastered the basic formula of Eratosthenes' method.
Assessment
- Check journals for accuracy of sketches and measurements.
- Check homework for 100% accuracy.
Day 3: Computer Models and School Results
Listed class time: 40 minutes; the procedure schedule runs from 10:00 to 10:45.
Preparations
- Preparations: Arrange for video player; locate tape at beginning of segment on Eratosthenes.
- One week in advance, and one day in advance, verify that websites are accessible from the computer lab, Java is enabled to make graphics movable, and mice are functioning.
Materials
- Cosmos videotape on Eratosthenes (first episode)
- Worksheets (see the website worksheet below)
Learning Objective
At the end of Lesson 3, students will be able to manipulate computerized geometric models and interpret resultant data showing various approximations of pi and of the Earth's circumference.
Lesson Procedures
- 10:00 — Watch the segment of the Cosmos videotape on Eratosthenes.
- 10:10 — File to the computer lab.
10:15 — Pass out the worksheet with website addresses and questions.
Students visit websites and answer questions on worksheet. Students print out a table of results from schools around the world for use in their homework assignment.
- 10:30 — Give the class a five-minute warning to be sure they have printed out the table for homework.
10:35 — File back to class.
Flag each participating school on world map.
- 10:45 — End.
Modifications
Supervise students to be sure they can and do locate websites. Tutor students who are unfamiliar with mouse drag-and-drop technique.
Assignment
- Estimate the earth's circumference by calculating the average circumference from all schools.
- Cross out the outlying circumferences.
- Re-estimate the circumference by calculating the average of the remaining circumferences.
- Compare your two estimates with the Earth's actual circumference of 40,075.16 kilometers.
- What is the percentage of error for each of your estimates?
To be turned in and redone if calculations are less than 75% correct.
Assessment
- Monitor students for net literacy.
- Check homework for substantial accuracy.
Day 4: Keeping a Meter Stick Vertical
Listed class time: 40 minutes.
Preparations
- Rehearse all physical demonstrations.
- Divide class into teams of three or four with a mix of skills.
Materials
- Professional plumb bob
- Meter stick for each student
- Math journals
Learning Objective
At the end of Lesson 4, students will be able to design and test a mechanism for keeping a meter stick vertical.
Lesson Procedures
10:00 — Demonstrate the use of a professional plumb bob.
Adjust the height of the bob by pulling the string over a finger, and point out that it is a simple form of the pulleys shown in our textbook as developed by Archimedes.
Test doorways, blackboards, walls, etc. for a true vertical.
10:05 — Read team rosters, break into teams, and give one meter stick to each team.
Explain that each team will design and create a mechanism for holding a meter stick vertical, including a method to check for a true vertical.
Teams develop designs and sketch in journals; they could use a bookend or soda bottle.
- 10:20 — Each team presents its design idea to the class.
- 10:30 — Teams reassess designs and re-sketch if necessary.
- 10:40 — End.
Modifications
Review each design for feasibility. If students cannot visualize design flaws, allow them to implement flawed design but have them make a simple backup mechanism in case of failure.
Assignment
Create mechanism as designed.
Assessment
Team review, class review and teacher review of designs.
Day 5: Measuring the Earth
Listed class time: 40 minutes; the procedure schedule runs from 11:40 to 1:00 and may be adjusted for the local sun angle.
Preparations
Rehearse all physical demonstrations.
Materials
- Math journals, pencil, protractor, calculator, and safety geometric compass for each student
- Magnetic compass, masking tape, and legal-size paper
- Empty soda bottles and sand for replacement mechanisms
- String and keys for replacement plumb bobs
- Table of school results printed for previous assignment
- Certificate honoring each student as a Certified Geometer (use card stock; cite Eratosthenes and derivation of word "geometry")
Learning Objective
At the end of Lesson 5, students will be able to measure the Earth's circumference.
Lesson Procedures
11:40 — Time may be adjusted for the local sun angle.
File out to the schoolyard with mechanisms, pencils, protractors, masking tape, and legal-size paper.
11:45 — Teams of three or four students tape paper on the ground, tape the mechanism into position, and measure the shadow of the meter stick at two-minute intervals.
Check meter sticks for true vertical. Announce results to all teams. Outlying measurements should be recalculated to give all students sufficient chance to produce usable data.
Between measurements, students make scale drawings of results and use a protractor to find the angle of the sun on their drawings.
Use a magnetic compass to note which direction the shadow points.
- 12:15 — File back to the classroom.
- 12:20 — Analyze pooled data, estimate the time of local noon, remove outliers, and average results. Results are to be sent to the Noon Shadow Project for their website.
- 12:40 — Using the table of school results from the previous assignment, compute the Earth's circumference.
- 12:50 — Discuss reasons for variations and select the most reliable result.
- 1:00 — Present a Certified Geometer certificate to each student.
Modifications
For students with short attention spans, especially in this outdoor environment, keep up momentum between measurements by monitoring students to be sure that they are sketching results accurately in journals.
Assessment
Monitor measurements as they are taken and compare them to results of other teams. Be sure that the team locates the source of any errors immediately, to guard against the possibility that a team would produce data that the class must discard.
Follow-up Acknowledgment Event
- Link school webpage to "quilt" at http://www.geocities.com/Athens/8231/noonschs.htm
- Check http://www.geocities.com/Athens/8231/nooncal97.htm daily.
- When results are published, have students use measurements from other schools to compute the circumference of the Earth in their journals and write a self-assessment of the results.
- Invite other classes to the classroom to view mechanisms and journals on display for each team. Bring up http://www.geocities.com/Athens/8231/noonschs.htm on the classroom computer, which will show our school on the "quilt" of schools and will play the song "It's a Small World After All."
Worksheet: Websites Related to Eratosthenes' Measurement of the Earth
Visit four of the following websites and answer all questions below.
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/8231/nooncal97.htm
Print out the table of results from schools to use for your homework assignment.
http://k12science.stevens-tech.edu/~ihor/sketch/pi2.html
Use your mouse to adjust the size of a circle, and see how pi is recalculated for the adjusted circle.
What is the highest calculation of pi that you can produce? ______________
What is the lowest calculation of pi that you can produce? ______________
What is the percentage of difference? ______________
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/8231/noongeom.htm
OR http://mvhs1.mbhs.edu/mvhsproj/suncp.html
What could you add to your diagram to make it clearer? ________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
http://k12science.stevens-tech.edu/noonday/story.html
OR http://k12science.stevens-tech.edu/~ihor/sketch/paper_gsp.html
Use the mouse to move the two "cities." Notice what Eratosthenes' results would have been if he had used two cities farther apart or closer together.
What is the highest calculation of the Earth's circumference that you can produce? ______________
What is the lowest calculation of the Earth's circumference that you can produce? ______________
What is the percentage of difference? ______________
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1824.html