Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Evaluating Web Sites

By Carolyn Cowell, Cindy Millett, Linda Tibben, Dave Waskow

  • Computer
  • Senior
Activity Time
2-3 fifty minute periods
Materials
PC and Internet access
Concepts / Topics
Understanding and Evaluation Sites
Resource Type
Lesson Plan

Students receive instruction and guided practice in evaluating websites, then use a checklist to assess sites and discuss their responses.

Internet 101: Using the Internet to Support Teaching and Learning

Final Project Task

Create a student-centered learning activity using the Instructional Framework to connect curriculum, best practice, and the Internet to enhance student learning. Use the following format to create your project.

Project title: Web Site Evaluation/Reference Guide

Lesson Overview

Students evaluate web sites using graphic organizers and a reference guide. This lesson is intended for grades 8 through adult learners.

Provide students with information on web site evaluation, give guided practice, and then provide activities in which they apply their knowledge using an evaluation checklist.

Why Do This?

The general standard addressed is appropriate use of the Internet for research. Becoming lifelong learners is identified as one of our Technology Benchmarks.

Correctly evaluating web sites provides students with tools to better validate and qualify information for research purposes and apply that knowledge to their final projects.

Content and Prerequisites

The central aim of this lesson is to improve students’ use of the Internet for research projects. This content can be used in any classroom where students use the Internet for research.

Students will be limited in selecting content until they have demonstrated proficiency in navigating the Internet. At that time, they will have the opportunity to choose sites that interest them and apply the checklist to determine each site’s worth to their projects.

Students will need a working technology-focused vocabulary, basic keyboarding skills, and a beginner’s knowledge of the Internet.

Concepts that may prove difficult for students include:

  • Not everything a person reads on the Internet is true.
  • Evaluating the information on a site is essential to the research process.

The lesson addresses these concepts by beginning with graphics that define web site terminology, along with examples of various web sites.

Teaching Strategies

Students will learn through hands-on experience, guided practice, reflection, and review. They will discover concepts by interacting with various web sites throughout the world. The lesson will teach students to analyze and evaluate a variety of sources and look for possible bias.

Materials and Resources

  • Evaluation checklist
  • Guided practice sheets
  • Graphic organizers
  • LCD projector
  • Overhead projector for presenting the graphic organizers
  • Computers with Internet connections
  • Internet web sites and Inspiration
  • Optional: popular magazines for comparison, to demonstrate purpose in another text source

Classroom Management

After the group is introduced to the concepts, students will work with partners or independently, as their technical skills allow.

The classroom is equipped with sixteen desktop computers, which will be networked soon. Students will work at their computer workstations.

Students who need additional help may be teamed with a peer tutor and/or seated close to the instructor for quick access. Time to process the material will be provided.

Special education/resource instructors may be called on to assist students with special needs. Our teachers are flexible and willing to assist.

Support Services Planning

  • What help will be needed with computer hardware, software, listservs, e-mail, the Internet, or other technology applications? Possible needs identified: Internet access and an LCD projector.
  • What other help will be needed to advise or assist with students with special needs? Help from a special education/resource teacher would be needed.
  • What other needs must be addressed to ensure a successful learning experience for students?

Introduction and Use of the Checklist in Evaluating Web Sites

Grade level: 8–Adult

Goal

Appropriate use of the Internet for research.

Objectives

  • Learn to use the checklist to evaluate web sites.
  • Use the information in student research.
  • Apply the information to a final project.

Procedure

  1. Present the information and graphic organizer #1 to the entire class, then add organizer #2 using an overhead projector.
  2. Move to the computers, either individually or in groups of 2 or 3, depending on the number of computers available. Instruct students to click on the hot link under Purpose on graphic organizer #2.
  3. Discuss URLs on graphic organizer #3, then allow students to click on the hot links.
  4. Use the guided practice sheet with the checklist to practice the skill. Follow up with correction and discussion.
  5. Hand out and review the evaluation checklist as a class so students will be comfortable using it as they continue using the Internet.
  6. Allow time for class discussion of the checklist.
  7. Provide time for groups to generate responses to the questions. Then share group questions and responses with the class.

Assessment and Reflection

Assess throughout instruction through teacher observation, student demonstration, group participation and responses, and written final products.

Guide students in assessing themselves by providing written steps in the reference guide and time for small-group discussion or reflection.

Web Site Evaluation Checklist

Questions to answer when evaluating a web site:

What information does the URL give you?

Domains: Where is it from?

  • .edu
  • .org
  • .k12
  • .net
  • .gov
  • .mil
  • .com
QuestionResponse
Does the site cover its topic?Yes / No
Can you understand the information presented?Yes / No
Is the information up to date?Yes / No

Why was the site created? What is its purpose?

  • Entertain
  • Commercial
  • Advocate an idea
  • Present information

Who is the author of this site?

What makes him or her an expert on this site’s topic?

Evaluating Websites: Organizer 1

I. Purpose

  • Entertain
  • Commercial
  • Advocate ideas
  • Present information

II. Author

Research background.

III. Meta-Website

  • Examine URLs:

    • users
    • ~ (tilde)
  • The link command: add "link:" and then the web address.

Evaluating Websites: Organizer 2

I. Purpose

PurposeExampleAddress
EntertainSports Illustrated Kids Sports Arcadehttp://sikids.com/games/
CommercialeBaywww.ebay.com
Advocate ideasGreenpeace True Food Networkwww.truefoodnow.org/
Present informationweather.comwww.weather.com/

II. Author

Research background.

III. Meta-Website

  • Examine URLs:

    • users
    • ~ (tilde)
  • The link command: add "link:" and then the web address.

Evaluating Websites: Organizer 3

Miscellaneous Thoughts: Domains

DomainExample AddressDefinition
.eduwww.ag.iastate.eduEducation-based sites in the U.S.
.orgwww.uitedway.orgAn organization and/or nonprofit that may have bias
.k12.ia.uswww.hudson.k12.ia.usK–12 school district and state in the U.S.
.netwww.cfu.netInternet service provider
.govlcweb.loc.govGovernment agency
.milwww.af.milMilitary body
.comwww.amazon.comCommercial or corporation

Activity Sheet: Evaluating Websites—URLs, Definitions, and Addresses

Applying What We Have Learned About Websites

Remember to use your checklist!

  1. Click on www.ag.iastate.edu/.
  2. Go to Basics; click on Diversity Programs.
  3. Click on George Washington Carver Celebration.
  4. Scroll down and click on University’s Carter Web Site.
  5. Click on Resources, then click on Related Sites.

Pick three of the following to evaluate using your checklist:

  • http://www.coax.net/people/LWF/carver
  • http://www.nps.gov/
  • http://www.public.iastate.edu/~botony/carver
  • http://www.archives.state.alus/afro/+address
  • http://www.public.iastate.edu/~savage/divweb2

References

Achey Cutts, P. (2000). Five Tips Every Internet User Needs to Know, p. 2. Retrieved June 15, 2000, from Educational Services Area Education Agency 7 Education Agency 7: edtech/classroom/internet5/index.html

Inspiration 6.0 for Macintosh. (1999). Inspiration Software, Inc. www.inspiration.com

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1903.html