Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Arab-Jewish Co-Existence

By Nathan Ron

  • History
  • Senior
Activity Time
2 lessons combined Islamic Flags over the Temp
Materials
the article, map, newspapers
Concepts / Topics
learning from hustory to promote peace

An article recounts Jewish-Arab cooperation, the Crusader conquest of Jerusalem in 1099, and later periods of Muslim rule and coexistence.

These are very difficult days for us in Israel. There is a danger of war here, but still many of us believe in peace. Here is an article I wrote about Jewish-Arab cooperation during the First Crusade. Please tell me what you think of it.

Islamic Flags over the Temple Mount

By Nathan Ron

In these turbulent days, when Jerusalem is the heart of the Arab-Jewish conflict, Jews consider it one wholly Israeli and indivisible city, while Moslems claim the eastern part as their capital, wishing to raise their flags on the Temple Mount. It is worthwhile to recall the days when Jews and Moslems fought and fell side by side, defending Jerusalem from a common enemy.

It was July 7, 1099. Morning broke and shed light over the ridge of Nebi-Samuel, from which the assembled crusaders watched, for the first time, the holy city.

Their desired destination, the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, was barely visible among the many houses, domes and minarets surrounded by a wall. A wave of messianic enthusiasm swept over the camp. The crusaders went down on their knees, tears in their eyes, saying their prayers. At that hour they saw themselves as the Children of Israel who were about to inherit the Promised Land. The crusaders were to fulfill the dream of generations: to take the city from the Moslems and raise the flag of the cross over the Church of the Holy Sepulcher. The boundaries of the city in those days were only slightly different from those of the walled city today.

The city’s population reached, according to an accepted estimate, twenty thousand. Iphtichar Adula, the Arab commander of Jerusalem, strengthened the city’s fortifications, increased its supplies and expelled the Christian inhabitants, fearing that they would betray him and join his enemies. The Jews, by contrast, remained and, like the Moslems, were put in charge of defending a part of the wall. This was the northern wall, which adjoined the Jewish quarter of the city.

Jewish settlement in Jerusalem, which was forbidden during Roman and Byzantine times, was renewed with the coming of the Moslems to Jerusalem in the 7th century. Under Moslem rule, the Jews developed prosperous commercial and religious life. Jews had their shops in the market. Banking and money exchange were in Jewish hands. Jews were also engaged in the industries of linen painting and tanning. Copying Jewish holy scriptures and selling them to Jewish communities abroad was another Jewish occupation. The “Yeshiva of Eretz Israel” (the Jewish religious academy of the land of Israel) was very active for a long time in Jerusalem, and Jewish communities all over Europe and North Africa obeyed its religious rules and verdicts.

All this was now under threat from the European troops: 1,200 mounted soldiers and 12,000 foot soldiers.

On July 15, 1099, after a siege that lasted five weeks, the forces of Geoffrey De Buyon managed to draw their tower near the wall and set up a bridge over which the crusaders broke into the city. The Jews and the Moslems withdrew towards the Temple Mount. There they probably thought to stand and fight a last battle, but the way was blocked by the crusaders. The Jews went into their synagogues to call upon their Father in Heaven. The crusaders set fire to the synagogues. The Jews were burned alive while crying out to their God.

The crusaders butchered the people of Jerusalem for two days. The massacre was comparable only to the one carried out by the Romans in the city some thousand years earlier. There were hardly any Moslems left alive. The Jews who survived were sold into slavery.

A new chapter in the history of Jerusalem began: the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem. The new law forbade the return of Moslems and Jews to the city, but not for long. Less than ninety years later, Salah-A-Din, the Moslem leader, won a crucial battle against the crusaders (1187), and Islamic rule in Jerusalem was reinstated.

The Jews were again allowed to settle in Jerusalem. Except for a short period in the 13th century, Moslems ruled Jerusalem up to the end of World War I. During this time, the Jewish settlement in Jerusalem coexisted with Moslems.

A conclusion can be drawn: the raising of Islamic flags over the mosques of the Temple Mount, if it happens again, will not necessarily bring about the end of Jewish life in Eastern Jerusalem. The experience of Jewish-Arab coexistence through the centuries should be learned, remembered and followed.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/1981.html