Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Civil Rights Movement: Investigating Nonviolence

Original contributor: Kim Clymer and Cheryl deMember

  • History
  • Senior
Activity Time
20-30 Minutes
Materials
Handouts of examples and non-examples of the “non-violence “ approach
Concepts / Topics
Non-Violence vs. "Any Means Necessary"
Resource Type
Concept-Attainment Lesson

Explore a Historical Concept

Use examples and contrasting cases to help students investigate nonviolent approaches during the Civil Rights Movement. The lesson asks students to recall prior learning, form hypotheses, test those hypotheses against new information, and identify the defining features of a historical concept.

Begin with an open question: What do you know about the Civil Rights Movement from our reading and discussion? Record students' responses. Explain that they will receive information in stages and use it to infer a concept, rather than being given the definition first.

Present the First Set

Give students these two sets of discussion cards. The cards summarize ideas for analysis; they are not historical quotations.

Set A

1. A movement calls for equal rights and an end to racial segregation.

2. People gather in a peaceful public demonstration to draw attention to injustice.

Set B

1. A statement claims that one racial group is inherently superior to another.

2. A statement questions whether moving into another neighborhood or school system should be necessary to obtain equal opportunities.

Ask students to suggest possible concepts represented by Set A. What appears in those cards that is absent from the others? List the hypotheses without immediately confirming one. Ask whether each card describes a goal, a tactic, or a judgment about society; those distinctions matter when testing a hypothesis.

Test and Revise the Hypotheses

Present a second set of cards.

Set A: Activists seek integration and equality while refusing to use violence to humiliate or destroy opponents. They aim to change an opponent's understanding.

Set B: A speaker threatens violent retaliation against racial attacks. Another statement argues that a community should fight back when attacked.

Ask which hypotheses should be retained, revised, or rejected. Require students to explain what new evidence supports each change.

Present the third set.

Set A: Martin Luther King Jr. is associated in this lesson with a nonviolent approach to achieving racial justice.

Set B: Statements associated in the source handout with Malcolm X and Stokely Carmichael raise questions about integration, resistance, and self-defense.

Have students reconsider their hypotheses. Do not treat a person's name, a criticism of integration, or a statement about self-defense as sufficient by itself to classify every action or belief of that person. Ask students to explain what evidence about the particular tactic or goal they would need.

Identify the Attributes

Invite students to combine the remaining hypotheses into a broader explanation. Ask what the Set A examples share. Draw out peaceful demonstration, integration, and equality, and connect those features to the approach examined in class.

Students then state a definition of the nonviolent approach and distinguish its essential attributes from details that merely appeared in a particular example. Revisit any card that students found ambiguous and explain why it was difficult to classify.

Apply the Concept

Present additional cases connected to Rosa Parks, the Black Panthers, events in Birmingham, busing, and Plessy v. Ferguson. For each, give enough historical context from the class's readings to identify what is being evaluated: an action, an organization, a policy, or a court ruling. Ask students whether the specific case illustrates the concept, contrasts with it, or needs more evidence. Have them justify their conclusions.

Assess students through their hypotheses, explanations of revisions, final definitions, and responses to the application cases. Use the class readings and verified historical sources to support the discussion.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2227.html