We're Alike, But Different
- Reading/Writing
- Elementary

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
Students sketch homes associated with studied Texas tribes, gather words about similarities and differences, then use those words to draft an organized compare/contrast essay.
From Studying Tribes to Planning an Essay
After studying various Indian tribes in Texas, I wanted my students to write a compare/contrast essay. Unfortunately, they were having difficulty finding what they wanted to say.
We stopped the lesson to draw (yeah, right).
Draw and Gather Words
- I gave each student a large sheet of construction paper, which they folded into thirds. In the middle, they drew a tepee, because most thought of tepees when they thought of housing.
- After coloring the tepee, they wrote only words about how the Indians we had studied were alike.
- On the left side of their paper, they drew the type of home a Karankawa Indian would build. After designing and coloring it, they wrote only words about the Karankawa Indians.
- Next, they drew the type of home a Caddo Indian would have. After designing and coloring it, they wrote only words about the Caddo Indians.
Plan the Introduction and Conclusion
Now they were ready to begin the essay. We discussed words to use in the introductory paragraph. On the back of their paper, which had been divided by a horizontal line, they listed these words at the top.
We wrote words for the conclusion at the bottom of this divided page.
Write the Rough Draft
When students began their rough drafts, they looked at the words for the introduction and went to work.
For the comparison paragraph, they looked only at the words on the tepee. For the next paragraph, they used words from the Karankawa side to describe differences, then used words from the Caddo side for the following paragraph.
They had a really nice rough draft ready when we began our elaboration activities.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2238.html