Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

(DR-TA) Poe's Cask of Amontillado

By Kirk T Walker

  • Literature
  • Middle
Activity Time
Full Period
Materials
multi-colored paper/index cards
Concepts / Topics
characterization, irony, critical thinking

Students rotate topic and quotation cards in groups, read Poe’s story in sections, and discuss predictions, character, irony, setting, and revenge.

Name: Kirk T Walker Class: RDG 474 Professor: Dr. Nixon Date: April 30, 2001

Activity: Directed Reading-Thinking Activity (DR-TA)

Work: “The Cask of Amontillado” by Edgar Allan Poe

Evocation

Students form groups of three or four. Give each group a colored index card with one of four topics written on it: Edgar Allan Poe, irony, Italy, or carnivals. More than one card may be needed for each topic; cards with the same topic should be the same color.

Students discuss their knowledge of and experiences with the topic they receive. After two or three minutes, they switch cards with another group and discuss a new topic. After four rotations, each group should have discussed every topic.

Realization of Meaning

Students read the story in sections. At each stop, the teacher leads a discussion, using open-ended questions to draw out key ideas and students’ personal reactions, emotions, and predictions.

First Stop

Students read the first section, stopping after “…my smile NOW was at the thought of his immolation.” The next section begins, “He had a weak point…”

Discussion questions should include:

  • How do you feel about the narrator?
  • Do his feelings seem justified?
  • What does Fortunato’s name seem to imply about his character?

Second Stop

Students read the second section, stopping after “…stood stupidly bewildered.” The next section begins, “A moment more and I had fettered him…”

The teacher again leads a discussion. Questions include:

  • Which character seems more likable?
  • What does Fortunato’s dress imply about his character?
  • How does Fortunato seem to feel about the narrator?

Final Discussion

Students read the rest of the story. The teacher leads a final discussion. Questions should include:

  • How was this story ironic?
  • How do you feel about the narrator?
  • How do you feel about Fortunato?
  • How would you change the ending?
  • How does Poe make the narrator’s character seem more sympathetic than we would expect him to be in this story?
  • How is setting important in this story?
  • Did you think that Montresor’s actions were justified? Why or why not?

Reflection

Students return to their groups. Give each group a different colored index card with one of the following five quotations written on it:

  • “An eye for eye only ends up making the whole world blind.” — Mahatma Gandhi
  • “Don't get mad, get even.” — Robert F. Kennedy
  • “She got even in a way that was almost cruel. She forgave them.” — Ralph McGill about Eleanor Roosevelt
  • “Success is the sweetest revenge.” — Vanessa Williams
  • “Revenge is often like biting a dog because the dog bit you.” — Austin O'Malley

Students discuss the meanings of the quotations, their own experiences, and how the quotations apply to the work. After five minutes, they switch cards with another group and discuss a new quotation. After five rotations, each group should have discussed every quotation.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2259.html