Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

"Economics Makes Cents" UNIT for Third Graders

By Vickie DeBruin

  • Social Studies
  • Elementary
Activity Time
about 45 minutes per lesson
Materials
per lesson
Concepts / Topics
learning economics terms

Students explore economic concepts through classification, grocery budgeting, scarcity stories, errand spending graphs, and a seed market, then observe and measure plant growth.

By Vickie DeBruin • Teacher's Academy 2000–2001

Unit Background

Teaching third grade in a self-contained setting lends itself well to interdisciplinary units because teachers provide instruction in all academic areas. Often we underestimate the impact of learning through different kinds of activities. After completing graduate work that involved writing a curriculum using multiple intelligences, I wanted to expand one of our social studies units into experiences in other academic areas. I challenged myself to do this with our third grade economics unit.

Targeted Objectives

I began with our district's economics objectives, derived from the Missouri Show Me Standards by a committee of teachers and district coordinators. I specifically targeted the following objectives:

  • Learn applications of these terms: wants and needs; public goods, private goods, and services; opportunity cost; scarcity; savings and banks; and natural, capital, and human resources.
  • Create a cost-benefit analysis chart for solving a problem.
  • Identify economic principles in real-life situations.

These terms and principles are complex, so the challenge was to create tangible situations for this age group. Teaching economics in context led us to integrate social studies with math, language, and science. Our third grade team incorporated the following activities into the regular curriculum.

Wants and Needs: Galileo the Hamster

We began by reviewing wants and needs through our previously studied science unit on habitats. Galileo is our class pet hamster. I brought in his wheel, clear tubes to crawl in, food, water, a bowl, a paper towel tube, wood shavings, peanut butter, and other objects, and laid them on a table. I reminded students of the basic needs of all living things and asked them to classify the items as wants or needs.

Most items were easily grouped, but wood shavings and peanut butter prompted debate. Students argued that peanut butter was food the hamster liked. I played devil's advocate, saying that he could eat pellet food instead. They finally decided that because food was a basic need, peanut butter should remain in that category. For wood shavings, I argued that Galileo needed them to be comfortable in his shelter. Some students countered that basic needs were for survival, not comfort.

Working through this gray area took students beyond simple definitions they probably already knew. Most combined their existing science knowledge with new economic principles and reached the analytical level of Bloom's taxonomy. We then connected our conclusions to our own lives and choices: food is a necessity, but eating at a five-star restaurant is not; clothing is a need, but Nike shoes are not. Because money is limited, choices remain after basic needs are paid for.

Opportunity Cost: A Grocery Budget

This discussion led directly to opportunity cost and students' own spending. Students quickly drew pictures of their favorite breakfast and dinner. Some drew a simple bowl of cereal; one drew pancakes, sausage, orange juice, scrambled eggs, and hot cocoa. I also asked how many ate nightly snacks. Students used their pictures to create a shopping list of ingredients, then considered other meals for the week.

I created a reasonable price list of common grocery items, including necessities and frivolous purchases. Students received a $20 budget to buy a week's groceries for two meals a day—breakfast and lunch—and any snacks they wanted. Most were astonished by how many groceries their pictured meals required.

Two students asked to pool their money, giving them $40 for the week, and split items such as milk and eggs. I encouraged their plan; they had also made the math more complex by needing to divide everything in half. I added coupons to the problem: students could clip coupons from the newspaper, bring them in, and deduct the savings from their grocery costs.

After some work, with most students falling short of cash for their hungry bellies, we discussed opportunity cost. One student said, “If I eat just pancakes and no eggs, then I'll have money to buy chips for my snack.” Another added up coupon savings to try to afford both orange juice and milk for breakfast. Students quickly grasped the idea of trading something they wanted for something they wanted even more. They also practiced adding money up to $20 without going over and subtracting coupons. Finally, we made a decision tree—a basic T-chart—of the pros and cons of different purchasing scenarios.

Resources and Scarcity Through Literature

Next came the difficult task of distinguishing among three types of resources. Natural resources were an easy review because we had studied them in science. To make the distinctions more concrete, I turned to stories, beginning with The Sea Breeze Hotel. In the story, a small hotel business is failing because of high winds on its oceanfront property. The owners' grandchild begins making kites in his free time, and soon people flock to the hotel because of the beautiful kites.

We made a three-column chart headed Natural Resources, Capital Resources, and Human Resources. We reread the story and placed details in the appropriate columns:

  • Natural resources included wind and wood for the kites.
  • Capital resources included the boy's saws and tools and the sewing machine his grandmother used to sew the cloth.
  • Human resources included the characters' jobs: housekeeper, accountant, groundskeeper, and greeter.

The story also gave us a way to discuss scarcity. At first, the hotel had a scarcity of customers. To solve this problem, the boy and his grandparents created something desirable that drew people there.

Writing Scarcity Stories

Students thought about a time when they had a scarcity problem and wrote their own “scarcity stories.” Once they had written a basic problem, we created a web of possible solutions using our opportunity-cost decision tree. Students chose one solution and used it to conclude their story.

When students typed their stories, they added a legend at the bottom of the title page explaining the print colors: human resources in green, natural resources in red, and capital resources in blue. This let me check their understanding of the three resource types at a glance.

While students wrote, we read other literature to reinforce the concepts: Once Upon a Company, Take Me Out To The Bat and Ball Factory, and Little Nino's Pizzeria. A guest speaker from Ralston-Purina discussed her job and the resources used to produce pet food. Later that day, students were encouraged to look for economic principles in their silent-reading books. A few were able to apply their knowledge.

Goods and Services: Weekend Errands

Although goods and services were taught in the previous grade, we reviewed them. Students made a weekend errand list with their parents, including stops such as the grocery store, dry cleaners, haircut appointment, Wal Mart, or mall. They took the list on a clipboard and shadowed their parents during a Saturday errand run, recording what was purchased, whether it was a good or service, and its estimated cost.

Back at school, each student made a bar graph of money spent on goods and services. We analyzed spending trends: Was more spent on goods or services, and why? We also examined the types purchased. I asked each student to identify one purchased good or service that everyone could use—a public good. Most purchases were private.

We introduced public goods by imagining that people paid for them individually. How much does the fire department charge to put out a fire in your house? How much did you pay to borrow a county library book? Have you received your bill for having a mayor? We discussed how taxes pay for these items and services, which are then generally available without a direct charge to community members. Some things do not have to go on a shopping list; they are there for everyone who needs them.

During a walk at free recess, we looked for private goods, such as playground balls, personal items, and teachers' cars, and public goods, such as the school, a nearby fire station, a police car monitoring speed with radar, sidewalks, and streets. We connected public goods and services to tax revenue.

Culminating Activity: Buying and Growing Seeds

Earning and Saving Bunny Bucks

Throughout the unit, students earned “Bunny Bucks”—small tickets—for doing jobs, exhibiting good behavior, and similar activities. They wrote their names on the tickets and saved them in their “Bunny Bank,” an envelope kept safely in their desk. From the beginning, they knew the bucks would be used to buy something.

The Seed Market

On the final day, I set out cups, a bucket of dirt, and about seven types of seeds donated to our school by Wal Mart. Students counted their Bunny Bucks to determine what they could spend. Each type of seed had a price:

SeedPrice in Bunny Bucks (BB)
Watermelon—the all-time favorite10 BB
Sunflower—the second favorite for most8 BB
Marigold6 BB
Cucumber4 BB
Petunia3 BB
Tomato2 BB
Dill1 BB

I explained that there was only one packet of each type of seed and that students could outbid another customer, introducing supply and demand. As luck would have it, no one did, and everyone got what they wanted. Students also had to reserve 2 BB for sales taxes.

One by one, students bought seeds and paid their tax. It was interesting to hear them use cost-benefit analysis: “If I buy one watermelon seed with my money and it doesn't bloom, I wasted my money,” and “I want to buy tomatoes because they will make something I can eat and flowers can't.”

I explained that their taxes paid for the cups and dirt, so every student would receive a cup of dirt for planting. In our classroom model, the seeds were private goods and the cups of dirt were public goods.

Upon reflection, I could also have added that students living in the central portion of the room would pay 3 BB in tax and receive two cups of dirt because they lived in a more “exclusive and affluent” part of the classroom.

Observing Plant Growth

We predicted when the seeds would sprout and made a pictograph for each kind of seed and its estimated sprout date. Students observed their plants every other day, practicing a scientific process skill. Once the plants sprouted, students measured their growth and plotted the heights on a line graph. At the end, they took their plants home.

Assessment and Reflection

This kind of learning is difficult to assess with a pencil-and-paper test. Instead, we borrowed a performance module from our district curriculum document—the type of module that forms the basis of Missouri's M.A.P. tests. It presented similar situations involving economic principles. Using the supplied scoring rubric, all students scored above 80%, and approximately half earned 100%.

Students seemed to enjoy being actively involved in the unit and its activities, which, as any teacher knows, supports retaining knowledge. Economics makes “cents” after all.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2343.html