Danger at the Breaker
- Reading/Writing
- Elementary

- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
Students read Danger at the Breaker, discuss and chart its story elements, complete a study guide, perform assigned scenes, and take a timed oral reading.
Introduction
This four-day lesson is part of an integrated unit on coal mining in the United States. Danger at the Breaker explores the life of a young child working in a coal mine in western Pennsylvania in the 1800s. Students can relate to this historical fiction because it is about a child close to their own age. The lesson also helps students appreciate and understand what life was like for ancestors who may have worked in Pennsylvania coal mines. It is designed to increase students’ comprehension skills and provides a text selection for administering a CBA.
Instructional Objectives
- After reading Danger at the Breaker, students will complete a study guide independently. [Individual assessment]
- After a class discussion and group activities, students will perform a teacher-assigned scene from Danger at the Breaker in groups of three. Each student will be evaluated using a rubric. [Individual assessment]
- After reading Danger at the Breaker, students will read a passage from the story for a one-minute timed oral reading with as few errors as possible. [Individual assessment]
- During class, students will work cooperatively in groups during the think-pair-share and acting activities. [Individual assessment, small-group assessment]
Materials
- Welch, Catherine A. Danger at the Breaker. Minneapolis: Carolrhoda Books, Inc., 1992.
- Chart paper
- Marker
- A piece of coal
- Chalkboard
- Chalk
- Who? Where? What? How? chart
- A transparency of the Who? Where? What? How? chart
- Overhead projector
- ADAPT structured study guide
- Props
- Costumes
- www.teach-nology.com
- Performance rubric
- Procedures for Administering a CBA
- Individual CBA chart
Lesson Initiation
Begin a K-W-L chart on the chalkboard. Ask students what they “know” about working in a coal mine and record their answers. Then ask what they want to “learn” about working in a coal mine and record those answers.
Day 1—Tuesday, December 4
Read Danger at the Breaker
Introduce the story by passing around a piece of coal. Ask students what the object is, how it could be involved in the story they are going to read, and how it relates to Pennsylvania.
Ask the leader of each row to get a book from the bookshelves for each member of the row and distribute the books. Ask a student to read the title and author aloud. Have students look at the front cover and predict what the book may be about.
Read Danger at the Breaker aloud while each student follows along in their own copy. Stop at the following pages to ask these questions:
- Page 6: What do you think a breaker boy is?
- Page 11: How would you feel about going to work every day instead of going to school? Which would you choose, work or school? Why?
- Page 16: Do you think Patrick is a bully? Why or why not?
- Page 27: Do you think Andrew likes his job? How do you know?
- Page 32: What could have caused the explosion?
- Page 37: How would you feel if your dad was still in the mine?
- Page 40: What does “still as death” mean?
- Page 48: Would you go back to the mine the next day?
Paired Reading
Divide students into pairs and ask them to find a quiet place in the room to read. The student whose birthday comes first will be the first reader; the other student will be the listener. Then they will switch roles.
Ask students how they can be good listeners and good readers. Remind them to use their inside voices when reading. When pairs finish, have them return to their seats so the teacher knows who has finished.
Word Wall
After all pairs have finished reading, ask students to look through the story for words they would like to add to the word wall. Write their selections on the chalkboard. Possible suggestions are breaker, youngest, crooked, underground, prodding, stumbled, catwalk, screeching, scrambled, collapse, staggering, and clutching.
Tell students that these words will be added to the coal word wall during language arts class.
Day 2—Thursday, December 6
Think-Pair-Share
Write the following question on the board: If you were Andrew, would you go back to work at the breaker the day after the explosion?
- Ask students to think quietly for a few minutes about the question and how they would answer it. Tell them they may look back in their books if needed.
- Pair each student with the student sitting to their left. Give pairs a few minutes to discuss their answers.
- Have the class gather in a circle at the front of the room. Ask students to sit cross-legged next to their partners. Go around the circle and invite each pair to share its answer with the class.
- Ask students to return to their seats.
Who? What? Where? How? Chart
Give each student a Who? What? Where? How? chart and place a transparency of the chart on the overhead projector. Complete the chart about Danger at the Breaker together as a class. Begin with the title and author, then complete the “who,” “where,” “what,” and “how” sections in that order.
ADAPT
Distribute the ADAPT study guide for Danger at the Breaker. Read the directions and answer the first question together. Have students complete the rest of the worksheet independently. Walk around the room to monitor progress, then review the completed guide with the class.
Day 3—Friday, December 7
Acting
Ask students whether they have ever done any acting, and tell them that today they will be acting! Divide the class into groups of three and assign each group one of the following scenes from Danger at the Breaker:
- Pages 5–8: “The Argument”
- Pages 14–19: “Patrick”
- Pages 20–28: “Brian and Andrew”
- Pages 32–36: “The Explosion”
- Pages 37–47: “A Ray of Hope”
Distribute and discuss the Danger at the Breaker Performance Rubric so students understand the expectations. Explain how to achieve a four in each area: Body Language, Props and Costumes, Poise, and Voice.
Encourage students to practice with their groups for the entire class period. They may work anywhere in the classroom as long as they do not disturb another group. Provide all necessary props and costumes, and monitor each group’s progress periodically.
CBA
Explain that while groups practice their skits, students will be called individually to the reading table at the back of the room for a one-minute timed oral reading. Follow the procedures on the referenced CBA administration sheet.
Students will read pages 6–12 of Danger at the Breaker. Number each word in the passage before administering the reading.
Call students in alphabetical order. When called, each student should collect their red folder from the filing cabinet near the window and bring it to the reading table, along with a pencil for graphing their progress. Students are familiar with the CBA process because they have done it before.
Day 4—Monday, December 10
Lesson Summary
To review Danger at the Breaker, have students perform their scenes for the class using props and costumes.
After the performances, guide the class in completing the “Learned” portion of the K-W-L chart created at the beginning of the unit.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2451.html