Pearl Harbor Vs September 11 Attack
- Social Studies
- Middle

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
- Resource Type
Students compare the Pearl Harbor and September 11 attacks in a class discussion, then write an opinion supported by at least five facts.
Goal
Students will compare and contrast the Pearl Harbor attack and the September 11, 2001, attack by examining their similarities and differences. They will then form an informed opinion about whether a comparison between the two events is valid.
Domains: Affective, Cognitive.
Objectives
The student will be able to:
- Recall the events of December 7, 1941, in Pearl Harbor, Hawaii.
- Recall the events of the September 11, 2001, attack in New York and Washington, D.C.
- Find similarities between these two events.
- Discover differences between these two events.
- Form an informed opinion about whether these events have more similarities or differences.
Materials
- Board and dry erase markers
- Paper and pencil
Anticipatory Set
On the board, write the quote “A day that will live in infamy…” Ask students if they have ever heard these words before. Talk about who said them and why (President Roosevelt after the Pearl Harbor attack). Discuss the attack on Pearl Harbor and answer any questions students may have. Explain what Roosevelt meant: that this event will be remembered forever in our history and that it altered our lives.
Ask students if they can think of other events these words could describe. Let them answer, with a little description of each event mentioned, until students come up with the September 11 attack. Explain that this event will be discussed in history books and that the people who lived through it, including them, will never forget where they were and what they were doing when they discovered what had happened.
Remind students that after the September 11 attack, some people compared these two events. Tell them that today they will examine whether this was a valid comparison.
Activities
Brainstorm: Write December 7, 1941, on the board. Write September 11, 2001, on the adjacent board. Make a column for similarities and a column for differences, one on each board. Ask students to suggest similarities or differences between the two events. Discuss their ideas in detail and decide as a class whether they are truly similarities or differences. Continue until students run out of ideas. Use guided questions to help them identify similarities or differences you have thought of that have not yet been addressed.
Class discussion: Ask students whether they think the events can be compared based on what has been written on the board. Allow them time to explain their conclusions and debate their answers if necessary.
Assignment: During any remaining class time or as homework, have students elaborate on one of these two statements:
- September 11, 2001, can be compared to the Pearl Harbor attack on December 7, 1941, because:
- September 11, 2001, cannot be compared to the Pearl Harbor attack on December 7, 1941, because:
Explain that there is no right or wrong answer. Their answers are right if they can support their statement with facts discussed in class. They must include at least five supporting facts to back up their opinion.
Follow-Up
Offer extra credit to students who can identify another historical event to compare with the September 11 tragedy and explain why. Alternatively, make this an activity at a later date.
Helping Students with Special Needs
Have these students write down all the information on the board if they think it will help them. Allow them to discuss their ideas individually with the teacher before writing their essay. Give individual instruction if they need further assistance.
Assessment
- Participation: 5 points
- Assignment: 50 points
- Total: 55 points
- Extra credit: 5 points
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2456.html