Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

What's the Solution?

By Lisa Ann Kwisnek

  • Science
  • Elementary
Activity Time
15minutes
Concepts / Topics
The Difference between acids and bases

Students add vinegar and baking soda to red cabbage juice, observe the color changes, answer questions about acids and bases, and create a presentation with photos of acids and bases.

Introduction

Today in class we are going to learn about acids and bases through an experiment called “What's the Solution? Acid, Base or Neutral.” This lesson takes about 15 minutes. Through this experiment, you will learn how to test whether something is an acid, a base or neutral.

Objective

Students will learn how cabbage juice changes color when they add an acid or a base.

Grade Level

Grades 4, 5 or 6

Materials Required for a Full Cup

For each group:

  • 1 cup of chopped red cabbage
  • 1 cup of water
  • 3 tablespoons of vinegar
  • 3 tablespoons of baking soda
  • A piece of cheesecloth, folded over to use as a strainer
  • 2 clear plastic containers
  • Knife or scissors
  • Blender
  • Tablespoon
  • Measuring cup
  • 1 straw cut in half to make 2 stirring rods

Safety

The teacher should chop the cabbage with the knife or scissors, operate the blender and pour the red cabbage juice into the students’ containers. Students should not help with chopping or operating the blender because of the risk of injury.

If students use glass containers, review glass safety precautions. If a container breaks, students should tell the teacher immediately and should not touch the broken glass. If a student is cut, take the student to the nurse’s office immediately.

Students should not drink the solution, even though it is nontoxic. They should wear safety goggles to protect their eyes from irritants such as vinegar.

Procedure

  1. Chop 1 cup of red cabbage.
  2. Place the chopped cabbage in a blender. Add 1 cup of water and blend until the water turns dark purple.
  3. Using the cheesecloth as a strainer, pour about ½ cup of cabbage juice into each of the two containers.
  4. Add 3 tablespoons of vinegar to one container and watch what happens.
  5. Add 3 tablespoons of baking soda to the other container and watch what happens.

Observations

Students should notice that adding vinegar changes the cabbage juice from purple to a reddish color. Adding baking soda to the other container changes the cabbage juice from purple to a blue or greenish color.

Explanation of Observations

Red cabbage juice is known as an acid/base indicator because it changes color when exposed to an acid or a base. Cabbage juice is naturally neutral and has a purplish color. Adding an acid turns it reddish; adding a base turns it blue or greenish. Vinegar makes the juice turn reddish, so it is an acid. Baking soda makes the juice turn blue or greenish, so it is a base.

Questions

  1. Name two of the three chemicals that we worked with today.
  2. Why do you think the cabbage juice turned reddish when we added vinegar?
  3. What did we add to the cabbage juice to make it turn blue or greenish?
  4. Using what we learned today, what color would the cabbage juice turn if we added lemon juice?
  5. I used a blender to make the cabbage juice. Is there another way to make it?
  6. If I added water to the cabbage juice, what would happen to its color, and why?

Answers

  1. Any two of these: vinegar, baking soda or cabbage juice.
  2. The vinegar is an acid.
  3. We added a base: baking soda.
  4. The cabbage juice would turn reddish.
  5. The cabbage and water could have been boiled together.
  6. The color would not change because water is neither an acid nor a base; it is neutral.

Assignment

Now that we have done the experiment, I would like everyone to make a PowerPoint presentation about acids and bases. Go onto the Internet to find photos of different materials classified as acids or bases, and place these photos in your presentation.

References

  • “Acid-Base Reactions and Equilibria.” Encyclopedia Britannica. 1975 ed.
  • Do Science. “What's the solution? Acid, base or neutral.” 1999. March 2002.
  • Stoker, H. Stephen. Introduction to Chemical Principles. Seventh Edition. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Macmillan Publishing Company, 2002.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2654.html