Maxima-Minima (Differential Calculus)
- Mathematics
- Senior

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
Day 1: Introductions and Maxima–Minima
Time: 90 minutes. The day is labeled “Pre-Calculus” in the source; the lesson proper is identified as Calculus (Mathematics).
Assumption: Students in Grade 11 or 12 have studied differentiation and know how to evaluate functions using it.
Segment 1: Getting to Know Each Other (15 minutes)
Class size: 15.
Objectives
By the end of the session, students should know the teacher’s personal information and their classmates’ names.
- Cognitive: Identify the teacher’s name, address, and telephone number, and identify classmates’ names.
- Affective: Recognize the value and importance of making new friends.
- Psychomotor: Attach name tags to shirts.
Materials: Cartolina paper, Pentel pens, and masking tape.
Vocabulary: Getting to know each other; name tags.
Anticipatory Set
The teacher enters the room and attaches name tags to the shirts of one to three students.
Procedures and Activities
In the dialogue below, T means teacher and Ss means students.
- Draw language structures from students through leading questions: “Are you Tom?”
- Ask, “Are you Jason? Are you Jerry?” while attaching name tags to students’ shirts.
- Expected response: “No! I’m not Tom!” (Classmates laugh.)
- T: “Who is Tom? Where are you, Jason? Are you Jerry?”
- Ss: “I am Tom.”
- T: “There you are, Tom. Come, let me put on your name tag.” Attach Tom’s name tag with masking tape.
- T: “Where is Jason?” Jason raises his hand. “Ah, there you are.” The source then directs the teacher to attach Jerry’s name tag.
- T: “Class, what is his name?” (Point to Tom.)
- Ss: “Tom!”
- T: “Class, what is his name?” (Point to Jason.)
- Ss: “Jason!”
- T: “Now, who is Jerry?”
- Ss: Jerry raises his hand. “I’m here!”
- T: “Oh, there you are! Tom, will you give Jerry his name tag and attach it? Tell him, ‘I am Tom. How are you?’”
- Tom follows the instruction: “Hi! I am Tom! How are you?”
- Jerry: “I am Jerry. I’m fine. And you?”
- Repeat the procedure with the remaining students.
- T: “Oh, there’s one more tag left here. Whose could this be?”
- Ss, pondering: “It is yours!”
- T: “Oh, is it?”
- Ss: “Yes!”
- T: “Yes, it is mine! My name is Michael. Jason, will you put on my name tag, please?”
- Jason: “I am Jason. How are you?”
- T: “Oh, why, thank you. I am Michael. I’m great! And you?”
- Ss: “Great, too!”
- T: “Hi! My name is Michael M. Bumanlag. Will you say my name?”
- Ss: “Michael M. Bumanlag.”
- T: “I live in Angeles City, Philippines. But here, I live at #33 Valley View Drive, Michigan.”
- T: “Where do I live, class?”
- Ss: “#33 Valley View Drive, Michigan.”
- T: “My telephone number is 616-527-0463.”
- T: “What is my phone number?”
- Ss: “616-527-0463.”
- T: “Jason, will you tell Tom your address and phone number, then ask him about his?”
- Jason: “Hi, Tom! I live at 35 Pensylvania Drive, Florida. My phone number is 616-527-0465. What’s yours?”
- Repeat with the remaining students.
Check for Understanding
Use questions and answers to check understanding.
T: “What is his name again?” (Address the whole class.)
Expected response: “Jason!”
T: “Where does he live? What’s his phone number?”
Ss: “35 Pensylvania Drive, Florida. My phone number is 616-527-0465.”
Model this exchange with at least five to eight students. If time permits, direct the same questions to the whole class.
Values Reorientation
T: “Why do we have to know each other?”
Expected response: “It is important to know each other in order to meet new friends.”
T: “What is the importance of knowing each other?”
Ss: “No man is an island.”
T: “Very good! We can’t stand all alone. We need each other’s help. That’s why it is important to befriend each other.”
Reinforcement
Divide students into three animal groups: dog, cat, and pig. The first student, such as Tom, says “dog”; the second says “cat”; the third says “pig”; and the sequence repeats. Students make their animals’ sounds and find their groups by listening.
T: “Who belongs to the Dog group?” (Point to the cat group, then the pig group.)
Ss: “Tom, Jerry, Jason, Alyson, and Joshua.”
Repeat with the other groups.
Segment 2: Lesson Proper (75 minutes)
Subject: Calculus (Mathematics). Topic: Maxima–Minima (new lesson).
Objectives
By the end of the session, students should be able to state the meaning of maxima–minima and identify the locations of critical points.
- Cognitive: Plot and trace a curve from its function; solve for and locate maximum and minimum points using the First Derivative Test (FDT); and identify the steps for testing or verifying critical points using the FDT.
- Affective: Develop patience, understanding, and critical thinking or analysis; relate the topic to business, engineering, or architecture; and relate it to attitudes such as high temper and low mood.
- Psychomotor: Sketch a curve on graph paper or use a TI-82, TI-83, or TI-83+ calculator, if available.
Materials: Wire wrapped with packaging tape, Pentel pens, a foot ruler, packaging or masking tape, and Cartolina paper.
Vocabulary: Critical points, stationary points, turning points, local maximum, local minimum, relative extrema, maxima, minima, and First Derivative Test (FDT).
Anticipatory Set and Procedures
The teacher enters with wire looped around the palm of one hand.
Use leading questions to draw responses from students:
- “What do you think I will do with this wire?” Reshape the wire into a geometric curve resembling interconnected mountains.
- “What about the curve?” Expected response: “It forms the shape of a mountain!”
- “Yes! Interconnecting mountains, indeed. Very good!”
- “What geometric attributes can you give to this curve?” Expected response: “Parabola.”
- “What about the slope?”
- “What do you think is the slope at the peak and/or at the pit? Why?” Introduce maxima–minima as the point where y′ = 0.
- “In Geometry, the slope is represented by m. What about in Calculus?” The anticipated answer is dy/dx, though the author expects many students may need a clue. Ask: “We have been studying the answer since the beginning of this course. What is the derivative of y = 2x?” Students respond, “dy/dx = 2.” Continue prompting with the author’s “broken line technique” until students give dy/dx.
- Ask students for other examples of uses of maxima–minima.
- Introduce the vocabulary and its meanings.
- Relate the subject to business, engineering, or architecture.
- Draw the curve on the board (optional).
- Draw the x- and y-axes. Guide students in sketching or graphing the curve manually and/or with a graphing calculator.
- Guide students in identifying critical points.
- Give f(x), or y = 3x − x³, as the focus of discussion.
- Ask students to graph the function.
- Discuss and guide students through verifying critical points using the FDT.
- Give another example on the board for mastery.
Worked Example: First Derivative Test
Problem: Find the points where y = 3x − x³ has a maximum and a minimum using the First Derivative Test.
Step 1. Find the first derivative.
dy/dx or y’ = 3 – x3. y’ = 3 – 3x2.
Step 2. Set y′ = 0.
0 = 3 − 3x² 0 = 3(1 − x²)
Step 3. Solve for x. The equation 0 = 3 − 3x² is quadratic, as studied in Algebra.
0 = 3(1 − x²) 0 = (1 − x)(1 + x) x = 1 and x = −1
Step 4. Use the FDT to check which root corresponds to a maximum or a minimum.
Three(3) Tests for Maxima (all tests should be satisfied). Maximum @ x = 1 4.1. If the assumed value, a, is (slightly) less than x, then y’ is greater than 0 and x is a maximum.
In symbol, a 0. Note that in assuming values for a, it should be slightly less or greater than (whichever case may be) the value of x. (Not in a wider range).
Say a = 0.9. Substitute a for x in y′ = 3(1 − x²).
a = 0.9 in place of x. You must get a value less than 0 in order for the condition to be met. y’ = 3(1-(0.9)2), y’ = 0.57 > 0. Hence, the test passed. And therefore, x is a maximum.
4.2. If the assumed value, a, is equal to x, y’ equals 0. Then, x is a maximum. In symbol, a = x; y’ =0. From the equation y’ = 3(1-x2), substitute a = 1. The result is zero (0) and the second condition is satisfied. Hence, it (x) is a maximum.
4.3. If the assumed value, a, is (slightly) greater than x, then y’ is less than 0 and x is a maximum. In symbol, a > x; y’ x; y’ > 0.
From the equation: y’ = 3(1 - x2), substitute a = -0.9 in place of x. You must get a value greater than 0 in order for the condition to be met. y’ = 3(1-(-0.92)), y’ = 0.63 > 0. Hence, the test passed. And therefore, x is a minimum.
Step 5. Answers:
- At x = 1, the curve has a maximum.
- At x = −1, the curve has a minimum.
Summary Using the FDT
Test for Maximum
5.1. a 0 5.2. a = x; y’ = 0 5.3. a > x; y’ x; y’ > 0
Check for Understanding
Use questions and answers about the lesson, and invite students to ask for clarification.
T: “What is the simple meaning of maxima? Minima?”
Expected response: “Maxima or minima is the point on a curve where the slope is zero.”
T: “How sure are we that the identified point is a maximum or a minimum?”
Expected response: “Test it.”
T: “Using…?”
Expected response: “First Derivative Test, or FDT.”
T: “What are the conditions for the FDT?”
Expected response: Refer to the summary.
T: “How do we relate this topic to careers?”
Expected response: “Businesspeople encounter this topic in marginal cost analysis. Engineers encounter it in stress diagrams.”
Values Reorientation
T: “How do we relate it to our daily experiences?”
Expected response: “It calls for patience and kindness in solving problems in life and facing a given situation.”
Guided Seatwork
Find the points where each curve has a maximum or a minimum using the FDT.
- f(x) = 3x⁵ − 5x³
- y = x⁴ − 4x³
Homework
Find the points where each curve has a maximum or a minimum using the FDT.
- f(x) = x³ − 6x² + 9x − 3
- y = (1/3)x³ + (1/2)x² − 6x + 8
Use the remaining 3 minutes for additional clarification and other concerns in an open forum.
Day 2: Maxima–Minima and Volume
Time: 90 minutes.
Segment 1: Review and Reinforcement (40 minutes)
Subject: Calculus (Mathematics). Topic: Maxima–Minima, continued.
By the end of this segment, students should complete the following:
- Review the previous day’s lesson with guidance.
- Solve the homework on the board.
- Complete another guided seatwork activity.
- Take a surprise quiz.
Solve and show the solutions to the problems immediately after the quiz.
Segment 2: Volume Applications (50 minutes)
Subject: Calculus (Mathematics). Topic: Maxima–Minima, continued. Subtopic: Volume.
Objectives
By the end of this segment, students should determine solutions through correct analysis of volume problems and state the formula for volume.
- Cognitive: Explain correct steps for solving word problems involving volume; solve the given word problem using the teacher’s technique; and solve other word problems while respecting students’ techniques.
- Affective: Develop patience and understanding, and recognize that a piece of cardboard or paper can make a difference in students’ lives.
- Psychomotor: Sketch an approximate figure for the problem with paper and a pen or pencil; use a calculator as an aid; and manipulate cardboard.
Materials: A pair of scissors, cardboard, Cartolina, and Pentel pens.
Vocabulary: Volume.
Anticipatory Set and Procedures
The teacher enters, fanning with a piece of cardboard.
T: “So hot in here!” (Continue fanning.)
Begin cutting a little from the edges of the cardboard.
T: “Out of this piece of cardboard, we shall make a box, and this cardboard will make a big difference in your life. Do you believe me?”
Ss: Nod yes, eyes a little wider—perhaps a doubting Thomas.
T: “Now, what is the formula for the area of the box?”
Ss: “Sir, length × width.”
T: “Good!” Write the formula using symbols. “What about the formula for volume?”
Ss: “Sir, length × width × height.”
T: “Very good! You remember your Geometry well. Now, out of this cardboard, we solve a word problem. Here it is.”
Worked Example: Maximum Box Volume (30 minutes)
Attach the prepared written word problem to the board.
“A box is to made from a piece of cardboard 9 sq. cm. (in area) by cutting equal squares out of the corners and turning up the sides. Find the volume of the largest box that can be made in this way.”
T: “Will you read the problem?”
One student reads it.
T: “How will you interpret the problem? I’ll explain, and let us solve it.”
Step 1. Illustration.
Step 2. Given: Cardboard dimensions = 9 × 9 cm.
Step 3. Required: Vmax, the maximum volume.
Step 4. Analysis and representation: Let x be the side length of each square cut from a corner. The remaining side length for the box is 9 − 2x, and the height is x cm.
Step 5. Formula: V = s²h, where V is volume, s is the side length of the square base, and h is the box height.
Step 6. Solution and computation.
V = s²h V = (9 − 2x)²x (first equation)
Differentiate the volume with respect to x:
dv = (9-2x)(1) + (x)(2)(9-2x)(2) dx dv = (9-2x)(9-6x) dx
Set dV/dx = 0 and solve for possible values of x:
0 = (9 − 2x)(9 − 6x) 0 = 9 − 2x; x = 9/2 0 = 9 − 6x; x = 9/6 = 3/2
Test for maximum:
1. a 0
At x = 3/2, or 1.5, assume a slightly smaller value: a = 1.4.
dv = (9-2x)(9-6x) dx dv = [9-2(1.4)][9-6(1.4)] = 3.72 dx dv = 3.72 > 0 (test passed for maximum) dx 2. a = x; y’ = 0 dv = (9-2x)(9-6x) dx dv = [9-2(0)][9-6(0)] = 0 dx dv = 0 (test passed for maximum) dx 3. a > x; y’ x; y’ > 0
At x = 9/2, or 4.5, assume a slightly greater value: a = 4.6.
dv = (9-2x)(9-6x) dx dv = [9-2(4.6)][9-6(4.6)] = 3.72 dx dv = 3.72 > 0 (test passed for minimum) dx
Substitute the maximum value, x = 3/2, into the first volume equation:
V = (9-2x)2(x) V = [9-2(3/2)2][3/2] V = 54 (maximum)
Step 7. Answer and conclusion: Vmax = 54 cm³.
We took V = 54 cu.cm. as the maximum based on our testing above. Secondly, it could not be zero because the height, x, in the illustration should have a value.
T: “So, class, in what way does this problem appeal to you? Did it make a difference in your life?”
Ss: Wondering.
T: “Maybe we always see pieces of cardboard scattered around and neglect them. We did not know that we could make a word problem out of this cardboard. We should learn to value everything we see.”
We can find several uses for cardboard: fanning oneself, using it as a ruler guide or a base for writing on paper, or stiffening notebook covers. Next time, think of an ice cream cone. Can we also make a word problem out of it?
Seatwork
“A box is to made from a piece of cardboard 12 sq. cm. (in area) by cutting equal squares out of the corners and turning up the sides. Find the volume of the largest box that can be made in this way.”
Use the remaining 5 minutes for an open forum and other concerns.
Homework
Solve the following word problems using the steps above.
From a rectangular piece of metal 2 m wide and 6 m long, two squares with sides x m and (x + y) m are removed as shown in the referenced figure. The metal is folded along the dotted lines to form a closed box of height x m.
(a) Show that the volume V, in m³, is V = 2x³ − 8x² + 6x.
(b) Find x and y for which V has a maximum value, and show that this value is indeed a maximum.
2. A rectangle block has a total surface area of 1.08 m2. The dimensions of the block are x m, 2 m and h m. Show that and hence express the volume of the block in term of x. Find the value of x that makes this volume a maximum.
In an upright triangular prism, triangular base ABC is right-angled at B, AB = 5x cm, and BC = 12x cm. The sum of the lengths of all its edges is 180 cm.
(a) Show that the volume V, in cm³, is V = 1800 − 600x³.
(b) Find x for which V has a maximum value.
Day 3: Volume Review and Related Rates
Time: 90 minutes.
Assumption: Students in Grade 11 or 12 have studied differentiation and know how to evaluate functions using it.
Segment 1: Volume Review and Reinforcement (40 minutes)
Subject: Calculus (Mathematics). Topic: Maxima–Minima: Volume, continued.
By the end of this segment, students should complete the following:
- Review the previous day’s lesson with guidance.
- Solve the three homework items on the board.
- Complete another guided seatwork activity.
- Take a surprise quiz.
Solve and show the solutions to the problems immediately after the quiz.
Segment 2: Related Rates (50 minutes)
Subject: Calculus (Mathematics). Topic: Maxima–Minima: Related Rates.
Objectives
By the end of the session, students should know the treatment of rates using maxima–minima.
- Cognitive: Explain correct steps for solving word problems involving rates; solve the given word problem using the teacher’s technique; and solve other word problems while respecting students’ techniques.
- Affective: Develop kindness and patience.
- Psychomotor: Sketch an approximate figure for the problem with paper and a pen or pencil, and use a calculator as an aid.
Materials: An ice cream cone, bottled water, a small container, a pair of scissors, cardboard, Cartolina, and Pentel pens.
Vocabulary: Rates.
Anticipatory Set and Procedures
The teacher enters with a scoop of ice cream in a cone. The source specifies that the teacher should not eat the cone.
T: “So hot in here!” (Eat the scoop of ice cream.)
Bite off only a little of the cone’s tip. Students look on, wondering. Pour water into the cone so that it spills out through the other end.
T: “What went out at the other end of this cone?”
Ss: “Water.”
T: “How fast did it flow?”
Ss: “Very fast.” Others may say “slow” or “just right.”
T: “Today, we are going to study how fast water flows from the mouth of a cone through the other end. What comes to your mind when we say ‘fast’?”
Ss: “Speed.”
T: “Yes! What is the other term for speed?”
Ss: “Rates.”
T: “Good! What is your idea about rate?”
Ss: “It is the unit of distance per unit of time, like km/hr.”
T: Very good! But in this discourse, we shall be concerned about the flow of water per unit volume. Like in cubic meters, or cm3. Do you have any idea about this topic?
Ss: “Yes, a bit only.” Others may have no prior knowledge.
T: “Let me substantiate your knowledge about this topic. It is called ‘Related Rates.’ Let us have some word problems about this subject matter.”
Worked Example: Water Draining from a Conical Funnel
Water is running out of a conical funnel at 5 cm³/s. The funnel has a base radius of 10 cm and an altitude of 20 cm. Find the rate at which the water level is dropping when it is 5 cm from the top.
Step 1. Illustration.
Step 2. Given:
- dV/dt = −5 cm³/s
- Radius = 10 cm
- H = 20 cm
- Water height at the specified instant: h = 15 cm
Step 3. Required: dh/dt, the rate of change of water height when the level is 5 cm from the top.
Step 4. Analysis and representation: dV/dt = −5 cm³/s. The negative sign indicates water leaving the funnel; water entering would give a positive sign. The rate at which the water level drops is dh/dt.
Step 5. Formula: V = (1/3)πr²h.
Step 6. Solution and computation. By ratio and proportion:
r/h = 10/20 r = h/2 V = (1/3)πr²h V = (1/3)π(h/2)²h V = (π/12)h³
Differentiate both sides with respect to time t:
dV/dt = (3π/12)h²(dh/dt) dV/dt = (π/4)h²(dh/dt) dV/dt = −5 cm³/s h = 20 − 5 = 15 cm −5 = (π/4)(15)²(dh/dt)
Therefore, dh/dt = -0.028 cm3s-1
Step 7. Answer and conclusion:
dh/dt = -0.028 cm3s-1
Homework
Solve the following word problems:
- Water is flowing into a conical reservoir 20 cm deep and 10 cm across the top at 15 cm³/s. Find how fast the surface is rising when the water is 8 cm deep.
- 2. Sand falling from a chute, forms a conical pile whose altitude is always equal to 4/3 the radius of the base. (a) How fast is the volume increasing when the radius of the base is 1 m and is increasing at r = 1/8 cm3s-1? (b) how fast is the radius increasing when it is 2 m and the volume is increasing at r = 104cm3s-1?
Challenge Problems
- A box must have a volume of 800 cm³ and a square base. If it is open at one end, find the dimensions that require the least amount of material.
- Gas is escaping from a spherical balloon at 900 cm³/s. How fast is the surface area shrinking when the radius is 360 cm?
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/2976.html