Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Inquiry in Science and Social Studies

By Glen D. McClary

  • Science
  • Senior
Activity Time
1 - 3 periods
Materials
As listed in lesson plans
Concepts / Topics
Critical Thinking and Current Events

Social Studies and Science Inquiry for Secondary School Students

Introduction

There has been a great deal written about the interconnections between Science and Social Studies Inquiry as a learning tool for elementary students. Since many elementary teachers work in the core curriculum and are responsible for teaching all of these subjects, it is not surprising that they are able to merge these through inquiry. It would seem that we can extend this attitude and experience into our middle and high school classrooms so that the process started in the earlier grades continues to bring fruit in the later years of education before these students go on to higher education, employment or other endeavors.

This model is developed from a constructivist paradigm of teaching and learning.

In this model, science and social studies teachers—pre-service, first-year, and experienced—develop learning experiences that help students merge science and social studies through current events or scientific history. The aim is to create a more powerful learning environment that meets the needs of today’s diverse classrooms. During common planning time, teachers would create lessons with the following goals:

  1. Improve social studies literacy.
  2. Improve science literacy.
  3. Improve reading and writing.
  4. Improve students’ ability to take responsibility for their learning.
  5. Develop improved research techniques.
  6. Develop improved critical thinking and communication skills.
  7. Help meet New York State social studies and science standards at a higher level, with emphasis on mastery.
  8. Give students an understanding of the connectivity of thematic units in social studies and science.
  9. Improve students’ class participation.
  10. Improve classroom management for the teacher.
  11. Improve teachers’ abilities as facilitators.
  12. Meet the needs of an increasingly diverse classroom population, with continued emphasis on students with special needs through inclusion.
  13. Develop and improve assessment within and across the science and social studies curricula.
  14. Help students recognize through the study of the social world that people try to harness both the natural and human-made sciences.
  15. Develop an awareness of how science affects students’ daily social world—for example, the current power outage, the invention of the computer, terrorism, and the nuclear age.

What Is Inquiry as It Relates to Science and Social Studies?

It seems appropriate to look at inquiry at the secondary level as a series of stages or stops on a trail. There are many ways to use inquiry successfully with students, and no single methodology is appropriate or applicable in every case. Teachers can move students along a continuum from teacher responsibility toward responsibility for their own learning.

The continuum includes structured inquiry, guided inquiry, and self-initiated inquiry.

Where Do Social Studies and Science Inquiry Merge in the Curricula?

  1. Current events
  2. History of science/scientific history
  3. Moral and ethical considerations in science
  4. Good citizenship and science
  5. The politics of science
  6. The economics of science
  7. Global issues and science: environment, war, famine, etc.
  8. Society and science
  9. Anthropology and sociology as a reflection of today’s science
  10. Career education

Traits for Inquiry That Apply to Social Studies and Science

  1. Connectivity through exploration and investigation: scope and sequence.
  2. Design methods for information and data collection.
  3. Research and investigation to collect, organize, and present information and data.
  4. Search for the construction of patterns and the meaning of those patterns in students’ everyday lives and the lives of those they touch in today’s society.
  5. Relate cross-curricular inquiry to improved learning and retention of material.
  6. Improve self-concept, self-esteem, and self-awareness.
  7. Exceed the minimum New York State standards in social studies and science for each grade level, 7–12.

1. Examining the Process of Globalization: The Haitian Experience with Disney

Time: 75 minutes

Overview

The purpose of this lesson is to make secondary students cognizant of the perils of globalization—“the process of transnational corporations weaving ‘global webs of production, commerce, culture and finance virtually unopposed’”—to Third World peoples across the globe (Karliner, 1997). Specifically, students will examine how the Walt Disney Company, over the past two decades, has developed manufacturing plants in Haiti for the sole purpose of maximizing profits. Disney’s thirst to feed its corporate coffers has not only left Haitian workers in the throes of poverty and pollution, but has also left many U.S. workers, those who once toiled for this “magical” corporation, permanently out of work.

National Council for the Social Studies: Standard 9

This lesson meets the Council’s standard on Global Connections: “At the high school level, students are able to think systematically about personal, national, and global decisions, interactions, and consequences, including addressing critical issues such as peace, human rights, trade, and global ecology.”

Instructional Objectives

At the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

  • Explain three factors that fueled Disney’s construction of sweatshops in Haiti.
  • Evaluate how Disney’s experiment has economically, socially, and ecologically affected the men, women, and children of Haiti by writing a one-page essay.
  • Evaluate whether Disney’s labor practices are rooted in violations of human rights.

Procedure: Motivation, Introduction, and Steps

  1. Pass out several Disney T-shirts to students and ask, “Where was this clothing made?”
  2. Ask students, “Why were the shirts made in Haiti?” List their responses on the board.
  3. Summarize students’ ideas.
  4. Lead a discussion about globalization, outlining several factors that have fueled transnational corporations to set up shop in Third World countries.
  5. Have students watch the National Labor Committee’s Disney Goes to Haiti.
  6. Have students work collaboratively in small groups of three or four to evaluate the impact of globalization in relation to Haitian workers, Haitian children, and Disney’s CEO Michael Eisner. See handout.
  7. Tell students they should also reflect on whether Disney has violated the human rights of the Haitian people. They should evaluate whether workers are paid a wage that meets their families’ basic needs, work in clean and safe environments, live in safe and sanitary conditions, and are afforded the right to a free public education.
  8. Elicit various responses from the small groups.
  9. Ask students if corporations in the United States, in some cases, violate the human rights of workers and families.

Conclusion and Summary

  • What factors facilitated Disney setting up operations in Haiti nearly 20 years ago?
  • Why have some critics of Disney’s labor practices in Haiti claimed the company is creating a modern slave system?

Assessment

Formative: The teacher will check for understanding by monitoring the cooperative activities.

Summative: The teacher will evaluate students’ essays for their understanding of key concepts.

Follow-Up

  • Students will write a two-page, typewritten essay evaluating the economic, social, cultural, and environmental impact of globalization in Haiti.
  • Students will visit the Student Committee Against Labor Exploitation’s website, http://www.nlcnet.org/scale/, to evaluate the role teens have played in fighting unjust labor practices across the globe. Students should determine whether the teens’ efforts have been effective in stemming the tide of globalization. Finally, they should determine what types of actions people in North America need to take to thwart globalization during the 21st century.

Science Lesson Plan: Is Global Warming an Issue of Ice Age Cycles or the Industrial Reality and Environmental Impact of Globalization?

Instructional Objective

At the end of this lesson, students will be able to compare and contrast scientific data on global warming and state any relationship between global warming and globalization.

Materials

Textbook, handouts, World Wide Web.

Procedure

  1. Allow students to go to the library/media center and search for materials on global warming. Give particular attention to several recent international conferences on the subject.
  2. Put students into small work groups to compile their individual materials and prioritize them as significant or insignificant.
  3. Have each group make a list of environmental effects of global warming, including causes and effects. Groups will list and explain at least five. If there are more than five, they will reach consensus on the top five.
  4. Bring students together as a large group to discuss, compare, and contrast the individual groups’ results. With the teacher’s assistance, produce a list incorporating all groups’ causes and effects, eliminating overlaps.
  5. Send students back to their small groups. Each group will produce a banner, sign, or slogan emphasizing its key cause or effect concerning global warming.

Evaluation

Students will demonstrate their knowledge of the causes and effects of global warming, including a definitive position on the effects of globalization or the natural cycle of warming and cooling of the Earth over time. They will also produce evidence of their knowledge through a poster, banner, or sign.

2. Unit Plan: The Religion of Islam

Meets National Council for Social Studies Strand 1 (Culture) and Standard 2 Idea: Use a variety of intellectual skills to demonstrate their understanding of major ideas, eras, themes, developments, and turning points in world history and examine the broad sweep of history from a variety of perspectives.

Lesson One

Instructional objective: Students will demonstrate their comprehension of religious principles by stating five tenets of Catholicism, Hinduism, and Judaism.

Materials: Textbooks, reference material, and notebooks.

Activity: This class primarily asks students to restate religious principles already studied.

Procedure:

  1. Students will form cooperative groups of five, making six groups; adjust as needed.
  2. Give each group one of the three religions and ask students to identify at least five major tenets or principles of that religion. They may use available materials as resources.
  3. Each group will report its tenets to the class.
  4. The teacher will compose a chart on the board and ask a member of each group to write the principles for comparison.

Evaluation: Students’ ability to brainstorm at least five principles of Catholicism, Hinduism, or Judaism.

Lesson Two

Instructional objective: After reading about Islam in their textbooks, students will describe the concept of the Five Pillars of Islam in a short paragraph.

Materials: Textbook, reference materials, and class notes on the principles of Catholicism, Hinduism, and Judaism.

Activity: In cooperative groups, students will read silently about the Muslim faith.

Procedure:

  1. After the reading, the teacher will ask students to identify the five major principles of Islam.
  2. In small groups, students will develop a list of principles of Islam.
  3. The class will convene as a large group and identify the five principles of Islam from the lists developed in small groups.

Evaluation: Students will describe the concept of the Five Pillars of Islam in a written paragraph.

Lesson Three

Instructional objective: Students will compare and contrast the principles of Islam with the religion they discussed in previous lessons by compiling a list of three similarities and differences.

Materials: Textbooks, notes, charts from Lesson One, and other reference materials.

Activity: The teacher will place students in cooperative groups.

Procedure:

  1. Ask students to recount the previous class on the Five Pillars of Islam.
  2. Ask students to retrieve their records on the development of their own religion.
  3. As a group, students will find and state similarities and differences between their religion and Islam.
  4. Each group will develop a list for use in a large-class discussion.
  5. As a large group, discuss Islamic principles and the principles of the other religions students established.
  6. Students will identify that their personal beliefs have more similarities with the Muslim religion than differences.

Evaluation: Compile a list of three similarities and differences between the religion students established and Islam.

Lesson Plan: Is Science a Religion?

Instructional Objective

At the end of this lesson, students will demonstrate their knowledge of the principles of science by stating five virtues common to science and religion and five virtues unique to science. The common and unique virtues are listed below.

CommonUnique
Explanation; consolation; uplift; cosmology and biology; inspirationVerification; evidence; scientific method; replication; modifiable

Materials

Reference materials, textbooks, World Wide Web, class notes, and the handout “Is Science a Religion” by R. Dawkins (1997), published in the Humanist.

Procedure

  1. Put students into small groups of four or five.
  2. List the common and unique terms shown above.
  3. Ask students to define the terms as they apply to science in their lives and give one example of each from current events.
  4. Rank the terms from most to least important to science.
  5. Ask students to define the terms as they apply to religions in their lives. Rank them from most to least important to religion.
  6. Analyze roles in the practice of science and religion. Compare and contrast these roles in chart form.
  7. Each group should reach consensus on whether science is a religion and explain the reasons for its position.

Students will answer the following questions:

  1. If science is a religion, what evidence supports that position?
  2. If science is not a religion, what sets it apart from religion to make it unique?
  3. Why is it not applicable for science to be about faith and belief?
  4. What happens to science when ethical or religious questions are raised in the public forum?
  5. Can science and religion offer balance to each other’s doctrine? If so, how? If not, why not?

Evaluation

Students will compare and contrast the principles of science and religion and determine whether science is a religion based on common and unique virtues.

3. Riding Out the Shock Wave: Whose Life Is Worth More?

The primary focus of this lesson is the decision to drop the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, knowing the destruction in the aftermath. Students will examine four different components of the opposing positions.

Instructional Objective

At the end of this lesson, students will be able to write a 500-word opinion paper using primary-source data from four of the five presented concerns to justify their position on whether Truman’s decision to drop atomic weapons on Japan was justified.

Procedure

  1. Upon entering the classroom, students will listen to “Manhattan Project” by Rush. After the song, conduct a brief brainstorming activity to evoke the images presented in the lyrics.
  2. Ask students to offer opinions contemporary to the historical events on the necessity of dropping atomic weapons on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
  3. On a word map or other graphic organizer, students will section off the following:

    1. The United States government
    2. United States popular public opinion
    3. Manhattan Project scientists
    4. Japanese society
    5. Japanese military
  4. Place students into small groups of equal size and assign each group to a unique center containing primary-source documents such as diaries, journals, notes, memos, and opinions of the Trinity Test. At each center, direct students to read and take notes on their organizer for sharing with the entire class.
  5. At pre-timed intervals, students will rotate through all the centers.
  6. After the last center, engage the groups in a whole-class conversation highlighting similarities and differences among the five categories. These can be represented on the board or overhead.

Summary Question

After reading the perspectives of all involved, has your opinion of the bombings of August 6 and 9, 1945, changed? If not, why? If so, how?

Assessment

In an opinion paper written in editorial format, present your validated view of whether Truman was justified in his decision to drop atomic weapons on Japan. Include material from at least four of the five categories read above to substantiate your answer. The paper should be at least 500 words and follow proper grammatical rules.

Science Lesson Plan: Little Boy, the Only Uranium-Based Bomb Ever Exploded!

Instructional Objective

At the end of this lesson, students will draw the components of the first atomic bomb dropped on Japan, named Little Boy. Students will also diagram the nuclear reaction, including the fissionable reactants and products. These materials will be used to develop a classroom learning center.

Materials

Selected portions of the 1989 movie Little Boy and Fat Man, starring Paul Newman; textbook; World Wide Web; the Manhattan Project Heritage Preservation Association handout; and various other handouts.

Procedure

  1. Allow students to go to the library or media center and collect scientific information on the construction of the Manhattan Project. Their materials should include diagrams of the bomb itself and the chemical chain reaction of uranium-238 that was used in making the bomb.
  2. Put students into small groups of three or four to share their research materials. Provide other materials where appropriate.
  3. After sharing their materials, groups should make a chart showing the design of the bomb and the chemical equation of the nuclear process.
  4. Bring the small groups together as a larger class to present their charts, diagrams, and chemical equations. Their presentations should include evidence of why uranium was not used further as an energy source.
  5. Students should discuss the ethics of the “dirty bomb” and whether it should have been dropped on two Japanese cities.
  6. Students will write a position paper on the bomb’s efficiency, environmental impact, and ethics, to be graded using the teacher’s rubric.
  7. Use all materials to build a learning center on the atomic bomb and its “physics.”

Evaluation

Students will demonstrate their knowledge of the chemistry of a nuclear reaction using uranium-238 in Little Boy, write a position paper, and create materials for a learning center on the Manhattan Project.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/3051.html