Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Anne Frank Intro

By Allison Judge

  • Literature
  • Middle
Activity Time
one - two class periods
Materials
any treats - candy, rewards, etc.
Concepts / Topics
Holocaust

Students take part in a staged ribbon-rule grammar game, write observations for homework, and discuss a misleading statistics demonstration as an introduction to the Holocaust.

Anne Frank intro

Background

Although it is history, I wanted to ease my fragile eighth graders into the subject of the Holocaust. As chance would have it, it was Dr. Seuss's birthday when I began the unit, so I read "The Sneetches" to the students, as well as "The Better Butter Battle." They made some connections to what they knew of the subject, but still couldn't understand—or believe—how people would follow such craziness.

A Staged Grammar Game

I checked out some social studies lessons and adapted one as follows. As an introduction to "The Diary of Anne Frank," I faked a grammar game. Each student picked a ribbon out of an envelope and tied it on their wrist. Half the class had green ribbons, one-quarter had gold, and one-quarter had silver. They thought gold and silver were going to be the "elite."

The rules for speaking were:

  • Green could speak anytime.
  • Gold could speak when I or someone with a green ribbon spoke to them.
  • Silver could speak when someone with a gold or green ribbon gave them permission.

Obviously, lots of rules could be made up to apply. Questions and rewards also differed by ribbon color:

  • Green: I asked easy questions, such as "Name a noun." They were rewarded whenever they answered correctly, or at least tried.
  • Gold: I asked questions that were difficult but answerable. They were only allowed to have a treat every two or three times, depending on the supply of goodies.
  • Silver: I asked virtually unanswerable questions, such as "Use a conjunction that serves as a preposition in a compound sentence which has flibbertygibbet as the objective complement."

Written Observations and Reflection

When all was said and done, I asked the students to write their observations for homework.

Here's the scary part: No one said it was unfair. They only said they were glad or sad about the color ribbon they were given. They learned something uncomfortable about themselves and the world, but they also understood the problems with indifference and going along with the crowd.

An Aside on Misleading Statistics

We also discussed "revisionists" who say that the Holocaust didn't happen. I used a misleading statistical demonstration to "prove" that no one in the class had blonde hair, although eight of them did:

"We're looking for blondes, so let's discount the brunettes. We're looking for girls, so let's discount the boys."

We ended up with −3 blondes because brunette boys had been counted twice. The students seemed to understand that they needed to be on their guard with such things.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/330.html