Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Courtroom Testimony and Presentation

By Greg Newton

  • Social Studies
  • Senior
Activity Time
One hour
Materials
Directional handout and report form
Concepts / Topics
Understanding applications of constitutional law

Students write a police report from a scenario, exchange reports, and take prosecuting, officer, and defense roles in testimony and cross-examination.

Objectives

  • To introduce students to the adversarial court process.
  • To introduce students to the standards by which the Fourth Amendment is interpreted.
  • To give students practice in writing and reviewing reports.
  • To give students practice in the public speaking skills necessary for court presentation.

Activity Instructions

  1. Look over the scenario below.
  2. You and your partner will write a police report detailing the crime, warrant application, and subsequent facts discovered during the investigation of this scenario.
  3. Do not add to or change the scenario.
  4. Your report will be given to another student who will play the defense attorney.
  5. One of you will play the role of a prosecuting attorney, and the other will play the role of an arresting officer on the witness stand.
  6. You will testify to the facts and evidence you know, and you will provide props for evidence if needed.
  7. The defense attorney will then cross-examine you.
  8. The State may conduct redirect examination after the defense conducts cross-examination.
  9. The defense also has the right to recross-examine.

Defense Attorneys

Look over the case and prepare notes on it. Decide on a strategy to discredit the officer’s testimony. Also be willing to try to create doubt about any evidence. Check over the officer’s report and be willing to make motions that evidence be suppressed. Be able to support your motions to suppress evidence based on the Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures.

Your case guideline will be Terry v. Ohio. The State must establish that there was reasonable suspicion to detain this suspect and pat him down for weapons.

Terry Stop Scenario

On August 8, 2002, you are an officer assigned to a narcotics interdiction team. You are working a high-crime area known for the sale of crack cocaine. You and your team are serving old arrest and bench warrants to make a police presence known in this area. At approximately 2:00 p.m. in front of the Bantam Chef at 240 Augusta Rd., your team notices a Black male on a pay phone who keeps avoiding eye contact. He does not match the description of any of the warrants you are serving. You approach him and ask for identification. He keeps turning around to avoid you, and you notice he keeps putting his hand at his waist. You are suspicious of his actions. You pull your weapon and confront him. A pat-down reveals a hidden gun, and you arrest him for carrying a concealed weapon.

A check reveals the suspect to be Howard Biggs, who has prior felony convictions. Mr. Biggs is charged under a statute prohibiting the possession of a handgun by a convicted felon. In this instance, the victim is the State or society.

Police Report Form

Crime: ___________________________________________
Date: ____________________________________________
Time of crime: ____________________________________
Victim: __________________________________________
Suspect: __________________________________________
Narrative:__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/3370.html