The Fish's Wish
- Reading/Writing
- Elementary

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
- Resource Type
Students hear The Fish and the Fisherman, map reasons for releasing the fish, draft and revise an original ending, then copy it onto a paper fish.
The Fish's Wish
Teacher: Brittany Droddy Subject: ELA, Grade 5 Duration: One 45-minute class Date: 2/10/2006
Academic Objective
After instruction, students will be able to create an original ending to the fable “The Fish and the Fisherman” by completing a tree graph as a brainstorming exercise, writing a rough draft, and rewriting the final version on a student-drawn fish.
Standards: 5R1.145W1.5 2.2 3.1 4.1
Materials
Construction paper; crayons, colored pencils, or markers; art supplies. The activity also specifies “36x12 construction paper.”
Lesson Introduction
Tell students that they will listen to a story and complete several activities afterward, so listening closely would be a good idea.
Read “The Fish and the Fisherman” below, stopping where the fish begs the fisherman for his life. Then complete the activities with students.
Keep emphasizing that the point of the lesson is to convince the fisherman to release the fish he caught.
The Fish and the Fisherman
There once was a fisherman who was hungry and decided to go fishing to catch some lunch. He walked along until he found what he thought would be a good fishing spot. After an hour’s worth of fishing, he still hadn’t caught anything. He was so hungry and wanted to give up. He thought he would try once more, so he cast his net again and finally caught a small fish.
The fish was scared at being caught in a fisherman’s net. He was just a young fish and felt he had a long life to live before he was ready to be someone’s lunch! The young fish begged the fisherman for his life.
Instructional Process
- Students complete a tree graph, classifying 3–5 reasons that would convince a fisherman to release them.
- Students write their argument as a rough draft.
- Students revise their own writing. Check for evidence of revision from the rough draft to the final copy.
- Students make their own fish and copy their fable ending onto it in their neatest handwriting. Use art supplies and the construction paper specified above.
Thinking map guidance: The “Reasons to Live” are flexible, depending on what the student thinks is a good argument for survival.
Early Finisher or Extension Activity
Early finishers may rewrite the ending to include the fisherman’s decision and explain why he will or will not release the fish.
Assessment and Reflection
Students can be graded on effort, completeness, creativity, and revision using the rubric below. Monitor student involvement and understanding throughout the lesson.
Students may be required to participate in a fishing tournament, reading their fish fables to the class and competing for the “most convincing fish story.” Keep in mind that the object is to free the fish from the fisherman by presenting valid arguments for its life.
Rubric
- Completeness: The assignment must contain a tree graph, rough draft, and final fish.
- Revision: Evidence of student revision must be visible.
- Creativity: Evidence of creative thought must be visible through art or storytelling.
- Effort: Evidence of the above combined.
Targeted Practices
- Learning styles: The art elements interest students with kinesthetic and artistic learning styles.
- Cross-curricular connection: The lesson can be tied to ecosystems in science.
- Multiple intelligences: Linguistic and visual/spatial.
- Technology/Internet: The lesson may be connected with the Internet when taught as a cross-curricular lesson.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/3673.html