Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Tops and Bottoms

By Meghan Webb

  • Reading/Writing
  • Elementary
Materials
listed
Concepts / Topics
Comprehension Skills, Reading, Writing, Speaking, and Listening
Resource Type
Lesson Plan

Students explore vegetables, hear Tops and Bottoms read aloud, predict and discuss its ending, map its main idea, play a cause-and-effect card game, and share learning through reading and artwork.

Lesson Overview

Lesson topic: Comprehension Skills. Language areas: Reading, Writing, Speaking, and Listening.

Grade level: 2nd Grade. Time required: 3–5 reading block days.

Picture book: Tops and Bottoms by Janet Stevens.

Stevens, J. (1995). Tops and Bottoms. New York, New York: Harcourt, Inc.

Rationale

This lesson teaches basic comprehension skills essential to understanding literature. Students learn to find the main idea through group activities, explore cause and effect through an educational card game, and respond creatively by predicting the ending of the story.

Content Standard

RLA.2.1.6 use basic comprehension skills to understand a story (e.g. main idea, cause/effect; predicting; drawing conclusions; and responding creatively to texts).

Performance Objectives

Upon completion of this lesson, students will be able to apply basic comprehension skills to identify the main idea of a story, identify how cause and effect are directly associated with a story’s outcome, and use prediction skills to create an alternate ending.

Essential Questions

  • What types of things can we learn from print?
  • Is there a moral to every story?

Materials

  • Tops and Bottoms by Janet Stevens
  • Raw vegetables
  • Pencils
  • Paper
  • Crayons or markers
  • Construction paper
  • Various books for independent reading
  • Predicting and Creative Writing Activity
  • Idea Web Activity
  • Artwork “Did You Know What We Learned?” Activity
  • Uno cards

Procedure

Introduction, Part I: Exploring Vegetables

To activate students’ prior knowledge, I will bring in actual samples of vegetables mentioned in the book, such as carrots, radishes, broccoli, celery, and corn. After presenting the items, I will give students a couple of minutes to taste, touch, smell, and observe some of the vegetables on display. Then I will ask students to discuss their different tastes, textures, and colors.

Optional: See the Vegetable Passport Activity.

Introduction, Part II: Picture Walk

The teacher and students may take a picture walk through at least ½ but no more than ¾ of the book. Walking through the entire book would reveal the ending students will predict. This picture walk briefly introduces the characters, setting, and main idea.

Lesson Development, Part I: Read-Aloud and Predictions

Different activities address each element listed in CSO RLA.2.1.6. This read-aloud addresses predicting, drawing conclusions, and responding creatively to the text.

First, read part of the book aloud. To keep students engaged, the teacher may give each student a character card. Whenever students hear their character mentioned, they must raise their hands. For example, a student whose card is labeled “Bear” raises a hand every time Bear’s name is mentioned; a student whose card is labeled “Hare” does the same for Hare.

After reading ½ to ¾ of the book aloud, the teacher may give each student a handout to predict the ending. The teacher may provide a specific creative-writing prompt, such as:

  1. 1. Do you think that Hare will outsmart Bear again? If so, how do you think he will do it?
  2. 2. Do you think that Bear will finally outsmart Hare? If so, how do you think he will do it?
  3. 3. What type of an agreement do you think that Bear and Hare will come to? Do you think they will agree to tops, bottoms, or something else?
  4. 4. What types of vegetables do you think Hare will plant next? Why do you think he would plant this vegetable?

Once all students have finished their predictions, the teacher may ask them to share their writing with the class. After each student has had ample opportunity to voice a prediction, ask students to read the ending aloud together. Discuss whether anyone correctly predicted the ending.

See the referenced Predicting and Creative Writing Activity.

Lesson Development, Part II: Main Idea

After reading and discussing the book, ask students to complete an idea web. Students should be able to suggest different possible main ideas and details from the story that relate to those ideas.

See the referenced Idea Map Activity.

Lesson Development, Part III: Cause and Effect

Assist students in playing a game to teach cause and effect. Possible events from the book to use include:

CauseEffect
Cause: Hare had lost a risky bet with a tortoise.Effect: Hare had to sell all of his land to Bear to pay off the debt.
Cause: Bear agreed to take the top part of the harvest and Hare agreed to take the bottom part of the harvest.Effect: Bear was outsmarted because Hare planted vegetables that grew underground.

See the referenced Cause and Effect Game.

Closure: Reading Buddies and Artwork

Assign each student a partner to serve as a reading buddy. Each pair selects one related book from those the teacher provides. Possible topics include farming, vegetables, animals, bears, and hares.

After students read their book, the teacher may give them construction paper to draw and visually represent what they learned. Each pair then presents its artwork to the class to share what they learned from reading and working together.

See the referenced List of Great Resource Books for This Lesson and the Artwork “Did You Know What We Learned?” Activity.

Assessment

Assess students through oral discussions with the teacher and one another, as well as through the written activities provided in the lesson.

  • Listening: Assess students’ attention to the story and their accuracy in holding up the cue card representing their character.
  • Predicting, drawing conclusions, and responding creatively to the text: Assess students’ understanding of predicting through the accuracy of their answers. See the referenced checklist.
  • Main idea: Assess students’ understanding through their answers on the idea web. Observe their thinking and understanding through both oral and written responses.
  • Cause and effect: Assess students’ understanding through their answers and participation in the card game.

Special Considerations for Diverse Learners

General

If students in my class needed assistance, I would pay special attention to adapting the lesson to their educational needs while also meeting the needs of the rest of the class. If required, I would work one-on-one with a student or assign a “study buddy.” I feel these supports would help provide the best possible and least restrictive learning environment for a child with a mild to moderate disability.

Vision Impairment

For a student with a vision impairment, I would provide a seat near me so the student could see the text and give all directions orally. As needed, I would enlarge activity text, provide a seat up front, provide a copy of the book, and use special lighting to minimize glare on paper.

Integrated Curriculum

This lesson can be integrated into other curriculum areas:

  • Science: How do vegetables grow? See the referenced activity.
  • Math: Students can graph the rate at which their vegetables grow. They can also use pretend money to purchase items needed to grow vegetables. See the referenced activity.
  • Health: Students can discuss the food pyramid and why vegetables are an integral part of it. See the referenced activity.
  • Art: Art is included in the closure activity above.
  • Physical Education: Students can do one jumping jack for each letter used to spell their spelling words. See the referenced spelling/vocabulary words.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/3818.html