Teashing Tone with Writing
- Reading/Writing
- Middle

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
Presentation Setup
I used this on PowerPoint. The presentation is labeled “tone PPT” at: http://www.fortbend.k12.tx.us/campuses/bms/TeacherDocuments.cfm?TeacherIndex=27757&ResourceIndex=23503
You can also put the slides on an overhead or write them on the board. Teacher directions accompany each slide below.
Introducing Tone
Slide 1
Don’t Take That Tone With Me!
Ask students what they think you were feeling when you wrote this (anger). Then ask what they think you were feeling if you wrote it as the opening slide for a lesson on tone (witty).
Slide 2
Tone: a guide to the literary element
Ask what they think you felt on this one (informative).
Slide 3
Tone Sweet Tone
Ask what they think you felt on this one (witty).
Slide 4
Tone: not THIS literary element again!
Ask what they think you felt on this one (frustrated).
Slide 5
Tone, you already know it!
Suggested tone: optimistic.
Discuss how these openings all gave the same information—the PowerPoint would be about tone—but it wasn’t what you said; it was how you said it.
Slide 6
It’s not WHAT we say, it’s how we say it!
Poll the class: Have they ever e-mailed or texted someone meaning the words one way, but the person took them the wrong way?
Slide 7
When it comes to your e-mails, you don’t have the tone of your voice—so those on the other side of the screen will read tone into your e-mail based on the efforts you make, the formatting you integrate, and the words you choose to use.
Ask the class when they think tone will be important for them. Encourage real-world connections.
Slide 8: A Real-Life Example
A job candidate came into town to interview for a faculty position. The faculty member responsible for organizing a meet-and-greet dinner sent around an e-mail invitation that read, “Talking to the candidate is not required; just don’t embarrass us.”
Discuss how this was meant to be a joke.
Slide 9: Another Example
Betty, hi,
I haven’t been successful reaching you by phone, so I’ll try e-mail instead.
Ask students how they think the person reading this took it. She thought it was a criticism about how she refused to answer phone calls, but it wasn’t meant that way at all!
Writing in Different Tones
Slide 10: Prepare the Paper
- Fold your paper like a hotdog and then like a hamburger so you create quadrants on your page.
- Open up the paper and pick four tone words from your list. The more different they are, the better. Put one tone word at the top of each quadrant.
Have students follow these directions using a class set of tone words.
Slide 11: The Writing Task
In each quadrant, reply to the same Dear Abby question. Take on the tone written at the top of that quadrant, giving advice with a different tone in each response.
The teacher will do one as an example first.
Slide 12: Model Question
Dear Abby/Andy,
I’m trying to decide what elective to take in high school. My parents think I should do Spanish because it will be useful, but I really want to do art because I like it. We’ve agreed to go with whatever decision you make. So what do you think?
—Electing to do with your decision
Slide 13: Model Response
Dear Elect,
I remember when I was your age, I too had a passion, a dream I wished to follow. My parents wanted me to join band, but my heart lay in the world of theater. How I wished to grace the stage! To this day, playing the tuba has never satisfied me. I say follow your dreams and become an artist!
Yours dramatically, Abby
Ask students what tone you used.
Slide 14: Model Response
Dear Elect,
You do realize there are children starving in Africa, right? Get over your boo-hooing and just pick the foreign language so that way you can learn to whine in 23 other countries.
Adios, Abby
Ask what tone was used.
Slide 15: Model Response
Dear Elect,
I know high school decision making can be very stressful, and I hope you end up being happy no matter what you do! Your parents have put you in a tight spot, but they only want what is best for you. Before you pull out your hair, I would suggest writing out a four-year “game plan” with art as your elective. If you can show your parents there will be plenty of room in your schedule for Spanish later, I’m sure they will see your choice is a reasonable one.
Yours planningly, Abby
Ask what tone is being used.
Slide 16: Now You Try!
Dear Abby/Andy,
My best friend in the whole world is going to a different high school next year. She says we’ll be BFFs, but I’m afraid not seeing her every day will make our friendship fade. How do I prevent this from happening?
—Missing my friend already
Have students write responses to this question using their four selected tones.
Sharing and Identifying Tone
Slide 17
Give students time to share.
- Get into groups of three.
- Read one of your quadrants. See if your group members can figure out the tone. Tone words that are synonyms count! For example, if your tone word is “enraged” and a group member says “angry,” they get a point.
- If they can’t figure it out, tell them the four tone words you used.
- Take turns reading a quadrant.
Scoring: Earn 1 point if you guess the tone of a response. Earn 1 point if someone can figure out your tone without needing the four tone words.
You can finish by reading a class set of a text and discussing the tone used by the author.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/4103.html