Checks and Balences
- Social Studies
- Senior

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
- Resource Type
Students role-play Congress, the executive branch, the press, and the judiciary as a bill is proposed, considered, challenged, and decided, then find and summarize an article illustrating checks and balances.
Lesson Plan #1 for Stacy Thurber
Concept and Goal
Concept/topic: How the checks and balances system of our government works!
By the end of the lesson, students will have a better understanding of the organization of the United States government.
Standards Addressed
- Govt. 7a: The student will demonstrate knowledge of the organization and powers of the national government by examining the legislative, executive, and judicial branches.
- Govt. 7b: The student will demonstrate knowledge of the organization and powers of the national government by analyzing the relationship between the three branches in a system of checks and balances.
- Govt. 4c: The student will demonstrate knowledge of the Constitution of the United States of America by examining the fundamental principles upon which the Constitution is based, including the rule of law, consent of the governed, limited government, separation of powers, and federalism.
- Govt. 4d: The student will demonstrate knowledge of the Constitution of the United States of America by illustrating the structure of the national government as outlined in Article I, Article II, and Article III.
Specific Objectives
Students will be able to:
- Define the terms “separation of powers” and “checks and balances.”
- List the three separate branches of government.
- Identify each branch’s assigned powers and functions.
- Label each branch’s exerted powers over the others.
Required Materials
- Overhead projector
- Transparencies
- U.S. Constitution worksheet
- Markers
- Paper
- Pencils
- Government book
- Chalkboard
Anticipatory Set
- Display the flow chart that shows how the checks and balances system works.
- Have students fill in the flow chart given to them using the flow chart in their textbook.
Step-by-Step Procedures
- Divide students into four groups: one for each branch of government and one representing the Print and Electronic Media.
- Hand out copies of the scenarios to members of all groups. Allow students to read them and gain a better understanding of what will be asked of them.
- Divide the legislative group into two groups to represent the House and the Senate.
- Designate a President within the executive group.
- Ensure that the judicial group has an odd number of people.
- Give each group the scenario for its role.
- Inform students that each group must produce a written element in carrying out its role and that this will be graded.
- Hand out the grading rubric and review it to ensure that students understand all components of the project.
- Give students [insert set amount of time here] minutes to discuss which role each student will play within the group.
- Instruct students to decide what they will do depending on the other groups’ actions.
- Have the Congress group present a bill first to the class and then to the President.
- Have the executive group—the President and advisors—consider the bill and make a decision. The President then formally announces the decision at a press conference.
- Have members of the Print and Electronic Media group ask questions of the President or the advisors.
- Have members of the press file their lawsuit against Congress once the President has approved the bill at the press conference.
- Have members of the judicial group ask questions of the press, Congress, and the President.
- Explain to the judicial group that its questions should elicit more information about whether the new law is constitutional.
- Once the judicial group has finished asking questions, have its members discuss the merits of the case among themselves.
- Have the judicial group announce its decision in the case and state the majority and minority opinions.
Independent Practice
- Have students locate an article in a newspaper, magazine, or website that illustrates the concept of checks and balances.
- Have students write a short summary outlining the main events and concepts in the article.
- Require students to include a statement identifying which branch has the power and which branch is having its powers limited by another branch.
- Have students bring their articles and summaries for a discussion.
Closure
- Divide the class into five to six teams of four.
- Using the flow chart from earlier in the lesson, choose a student to come to the board and draw ideas relating to checks and balances for the class.
- Remind students that this is like Pictionary: no talking, words, or numbers may be used.
- Award a point to the first team that correctly guesses the concept. That team sends the next person to the board.
- If time allows, continue until all concepts have been reviewed.
Assessment Based on Objectives
Assess students through:
- Responses on the written worksheet.
- Participation in the lesson.
- The article summary.
- Several short quizzes to determine whether they understand the concepts and words presented in the lesson.
Adaptations for Students with Learning Disabilities
- Provide students who are visually impaired with all lesson materials in either Braille or large print.
- Provide students who are hearing impaired with an interpreter, and give the interpreter a copy of the lesson plan.
Extensions for Gifted Students
- Ask open-ended questions to gauge students’ knowledge of the lesson in place of the Pictionary-like game at the end.
- Have students create a presentation and teach the class about the article assigned for homework and its importance.
Connections to Other Subjects
- English/Language Arts: Writing a paragraph or bill using correct grammar and sentence structure.
- Arts: Developing a presentation explaining the possible new law and the need for it, to be sent to the different houses.
Role-Play Scenarios
The following scenarios have been used for this lesson.
1. The Legislative Branch
Congress must write a bill restricting the content that can be put on the World Wide Web. The proposed law must make it a crime to publish on the Internet any criticism of the President or the President’s advisors. List examples of the types of language that would be made illegal if the material were available on the World Wide Web.
Students in this group must write the bill, be ready to debate it in class, and vote on it. The bill must pass and be sent to the President. If the President vetoes the bill, Congress will amend it and resubmit the changed bill for the President’s approval.
2. The Judicial Branch
Congress is considering a bill that will make criticism of the President on the Internet illegal. If Congress and the President approve the bill, the Supreme Court must be ready to hear arguments for and against it.
The Supreme Court must be ready to ask Congress questions about the bill to learn facts that will lead to a decision in a lawsuit brought by the press against the bill. The Court must develop five to seven questions to ask lawyers on both sides and must vote on the bill’s constitutionality.
Those in favor of the bill and those opposed must write a majority opinion and a minority opinion in the case. A minority of students must take the position in favor of the bill, even if they disagree with it.
3. The Executive Branch
Congress is going to submit a bill to you, the executive branch, that will make it illegal to place any criticism of the President on the Internet. You must decide whether the President should approve or veto the bill.
Each of the President’s advisors must write a memorandum to the President stating their position on the bill and recommending whether it should be vetoed. Students should be ready to share their views with the class in a press conference.
If the President vetoes the bill, Congress will amend it and resubmit the changed bill to the President. The bill should ultimately be approved by the President.
4. The Print and Electronic Media
Congress is considering a bill that would make criticism of the President on the Internet illegal. The President will no doubt agree with such a bill since it would improve his image. The press is using the Internet more and more to place articles online for customers who cannot receive the print version.
If the bill becomes law, the media—TV, radio, newspapers, and magazines—must be ready to sue the federal government based on the First Amendment freedoms of press and speech.
The press will learn of the President’s decision at a press conference. Have questions ready for the President whether the decision is for or against the bill.
Members of the media must write one or more editorials opposing the bill and supporting it, even though the supporting position would be in the minority. Members of the press must be ready to answer questions from the Supreme Court about why the bill should be ruled unconstitutional, or why it should not be ruled unconstitutional.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/4271.html