Ready Set Debate!
- Social Studies
- Senior

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
Student teacher: Kathleen Abair | Date: 12-10-08 | Grade levels: 7–12
Content
Students will learn techniques for successful debates: what debates entail, what to avoid, and how debating differs from arguing. They will engage one another in constructive conversation about public and social issues, considering Core Democratic Values and the consequences of ethical and unethical decisions, behavior, and actions.
Benchmarks
Social Studies Standard VI.2: Group Discussion
All students will engage their peers in constructive conversation about matters of public concern by clarifying issues, considering opposing views, applying democratic values, anticipating consequences, and working toward making decisions.
Technology METS 2.3
Discuss possible long-range effects of unethical uses of technology (e.g., virus spreading, file pirating, hacking) on cultures and society.
Learning Resources and Materials
- Media center
- Computer access
- School auditorium for the debates
- Camcorder
Development of Lesson
Introduction
Discuss debates, including appropriate language and behavior and the differences between debating and arguing.
Discuss the topics to be used. Have students take notes on how each student understands the topic and use computers to research it. Students must choose a topic of interest and connect it to an aspect of their own lives.
Methods and Procedures
- Tell students that the debate will be videotaped. Use the camcorder throughout the project to record progress along the way.
- If there are not enough computers, students may be grouped for discussions and preliminary research. To meet the technology standard, students will choose a topic concerning an unethical use of technology—virus spreading, file pirating, or hacking—and its effect on society.
- Have students research the pros and cons of their selected issue, choose a side, and debate that side. The instructor will ensure that equal numbers of students represent the pro and con sides.
- Hold the debates in the school auditorium and videotape them.
Accommodations and Adaptations
Students with special needs will be paired with another student chosen by the instructor. Partners can research together, work on the pros and cons, develop a side, and construct an outline to use. Each student, if possible, will debate individually.
Students will work closely with the instructor to ensure that both opinions are included.
Assessment and Evaluation
Give students rubrics outlining expectations. After the debates, hold class discussions about how well students think their peers performed.
Parent volunteers will serve as debate judges and complete evaluations for students. The instructor will consider these evaluations but will have the final word, recognizing that parents may sometimes be biased.
Closure
Watch the final video as a class. Students can see their progress, identify strengths and weaknesses in their performances, and hear stronger and weaker arguments. Discuss stories about how this project affects society.
Ask students what they thought of the project, what changes could be made, and how this lesson could be used for other lessons or topics.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/4307.html