Night Compare Contrast
- Literature
- Senior

- Activity Time
- Materials
Students discuss the book and movie, collaboratively compare their elements, record similarities and differences, then begin planning a compare/contrast paper.
Lesson Context
Student teacher: Donald Freese. Date: 11/4/10. Grade level: 9. Topic/unit: English—Night. School: Monroe High School. District: Monroe Public Schools.
This lesson is part of a unit on Holocaust literature with a focus on the novel Night by Elie Wiesel. Students have researched the era, read the book, and watched the movie Life is Beautiful, which also deals with the Holocaust. Today’s lesson focuses on a compare/contrast paper about the movie and the book.
Benchmark
Students will demonstrate the ability to interpret, synthesize, and evaluate information by writing a compare/contrast paper for Night and Life is Beautiful. (ELA HSCE 1.4.4)
Learning Resources and Materials
- Students: a copy of the text, their notes from the movie, and note-taking materials.
- Teacher: a Smartboard with internet access, 30 copies of a handout, and Inspiration 9 software.
Lesson Development
Introduction
Bellwork: Give students the first 5 to 10 minutes to do a quick write about the movie. Have them complete one of the following statements:
- I liked Night better because…
- I liked Life is Beautiful better because…
Students will write their answers and then discuss them with their friends. I will use this time to take attendance and observe the room.
Call to action: After students have completed their writing and discussion, I will convene the group to share some of their responses. I will gauge how specific their answers were. Hopefully they gave specific examples; if not, we will work on that together.
Methods and Procedures
For this lesson I will attempt a constructivist approach, varying between large-group and small-group work. This will be a cooperative learning day.
Essential question: How can two completely different approaches lead to the same outcome?
- Complete the bellwork and class discussion described above.
- At the end of the discussion, divide students into groups of 4. Whenever possible, include one high achiever, one low-performing student, and 2 students who perform somewhere in the middle. Groups will fill out a graphic organizer comparing and contrasting these elements of the book and movie: tone, characters, message, setting, plot, and emotional response.
- Give groups 15 to 20 minutes to complete the graphic organizer, then reconvene as a large group. Ask each group to share all the similarities they found, and type their information into the Inspiration diagram. After each group has shared its similarities, repeat the process for differences, going around the room in reverse order.
- After completing the class list, ask each student to pick 2 similarities and 2 differences and write them in their notes.
- Assign the compare/contrast paper described below, due one week from today.
- If time allows, give students the remainder of class for prewriting activities or thesis development.
Compare/Contrast Paper
Students will use the similarities and differences they have found to write a compare/contrast paper examining whether or how the book and the movie can evoke similar responses through different approaches.
- The paper is due one week from today.
- Students will receive class time to complete the paper and will also be expected to work at home.
- Students may use up to 3 outside sources, which must be cited using correct APA format.
- Students must have a clear thesis statement and present it to me before they begin writing the paper.
Accommodations and Adaptations
I will vary groups by ability, mixing high-performing and low-performing students. I will also allow EI, LD, and ELL students to simply compare and contrast without a thesis, or provide another accommodation as needed.
Assessment and Evaluation
Group work will be assessed informally and count toward a participation grade. I will evaluate performance through class discussion and by meeting with individual groups during group work.
The paper will be formally assessed on the extent to which students meet the requirements of a compare/contrast paper. It will count for 50 points. Criteria include:
- A proper thesis.
- Relevant and accurate supporting evidence.
- Proper use of transitions.
- Organization.
- Grammar and spelling.
Students’ performance on the paper will tell me whether the expectation has been met.
Closure
Allow students 5 to 10 minutes at the end of class to ask questions about today’s work and the paper due next week.
Based on today’s lesson, I will be able to determine students’ reading and writing levels, their ability to work together as a group, and the amount of time to give a project like this.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/4456.html