Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Is This Diet Healthy?

By AHealthTeacher

  • Health
  • Senior
Activity Time
1-2 class periods
Materials
worksheet-provided, optional PowerPoint
Concepts / Topics
Nutrition, Fad Diets, Food Guide Pyramid

Students research a selected diet, answer and score ten nutrition questions about it, then present its grade; a follow-up discussion addresses diet health.

Summary

Use these 10 questions, originally based on the Mayo Clinic Food Guide Pyramid, to analyze and grade fad diets.

Goal

Students will learn questions to ask when evaluating whether a diet is healthy and use them to evaluate other diet claims.

Lesson Instructions

  1. Give background information on dieting and obesity in the United States, why Americans often choose unhealthy, quick-fix diets, and how advertisers try to persuade consumers to buy diet products. Discuss common traits of fad diets, such as promises of quick weight loss, an easy plan, famous testimonials, scientific jargon, and claims that using the diet is critical.
  2. Print and hand out the “Is This Diet Healthy?” questions to each student.
  3. Have each student choose a diet to research. This assignment can be completed in the classroom if resources are available, as homework, or in a computer lab.
  4. As students research their diets, have them fill out the 10 questions, then add up their scores to give their diets a grade.
  5. Have students present their diet’s grade to classmates. Discuss why some plans can be unhealthy and what makes a plan balanced and realistic over time. You could also discuss how habits form and what makes them easier to change.

Worksheet: Is This Diet Healthy?

Editorial note. The historical Mayo Clinic Food Guide Pyramid and the original worksheet’s fixed calorie thresholds for girls and boys are dated. The worksheet’s original serving counts and weekly weight-loss target were also removed. Use the worksheet to discuss diet claims in class. For decisions about a student’s health, consult current guidance from a qualified health care professional or registered dietitian.

YOUR NAME:_________________________ PER:________ DATE:______
NAME OF THE DIET:____________________________________________

Answer the 10 questions, then total your “yes” answers and record the score and grade for the diet. Give 1 point for each “yes” answer. Leave the answer blank for “no” or if you don’t know.

  1. Does the diet include a variety of foods daily, such as breads and grains, fruits, vegetables, and foods that provide protein or dairy? ______
  2. Does the diet program also encourage you to exercise? ______
  3. Does the diet include foods daily that will provide plenty of fiber, such as whole-grain breads, cereals, pasta, rice, vegetables, and fruit? ______
  4. Does the diet include a variety of fruits and vegetables each day? ______
  5. Does the diet keep added sugar in moderation? ______
  6. Does the diet include foods with unsaturated fats? ______
  7. Does the diet recognize that energy needs vary with age, growth, and physical activity? ______
  8. Does the diet avoid promising rapid weight loss? ______
  9. Do YOU consider this diet “healthy” and “balanced”? ______
  10. Is the diet a program that you could continue for life? Would you realistically be able to make it a lifestyle change for the rest of your life? ______

Scoring

The worksheet score ranges from 0 to 10.

PointsGrade
10A
9A−
8B
7C
6D
0–5F
Total “yes” score points: ______
The diet’s grade: ______

Diet Types Listed for Research

These examples from the original lesson are for research and discussion.

  • Low-carbohydrate diets, such as Atkins, Sugar Busters, and The Zone
  • Moderate calorie restriction diets, such as Weight Watchers and Dieting For Dummies
  • Very low calorie diets under medical supervision, such as Optifast
  • Low-fat diets, such as The Rice Diet and Fit or Fat
  • Novelty diets, such as The Beverly Hills Diet and Cabbage Soup Diet

Related Teachers Pay Teachers resource from Health Education Today. Its connection to AHealthTeacher has not been verified.

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/4583.html