Scientific Thinking and Problem Solving
- Science
- Middle

- Activity Time
- Concepts / Topics
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 1
Time: Two 50-minute class periods.
Objectives
- Assess students’ prior knowledge of scientific thinking and problem solving.
- Brainstorm how scientists think and solve problems.
Materials
- 2 large pieces of butcher paper for each class period
- Large Sharpie marker
- 1 copy of the “What Is a Scientist?” activity per student
- Colored pencils
- School picture of each student (optional)
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Students write what they think scientific thinking is on a 3 × 5 card. Have students pair and share their ideas, then turn in their cards for an assessment of prior knowledge.
Whole-class brainstorm
- Place one sheet of butcher paper on the board with the title “How Do Scientists Think?”
- Ask students to brainstorm ways scientists think and solve problems. Write down all ideas.
- Place the second sheet on the board with the title “Who Are Scientists?”
- Ask students to brainstorm characteristics of people who are scientists. Write down all ideas.
- Leave both lists on the board for reference during the next activity.
What Is a Scientist?
- On the left side of the paper, draw a scientist. Use colored pencils to add color.
- On the right side, write a short paragraph describing what it means to think like a scientist.
- Have students walk around the room and observe one another’s drawings. Discuss similarities as a group; many drawings may resemble the stereotypical mad scientist. Discuss stereotypes about what scientists look like and why students think those stereotypes exist—for example, male, white, balding or with crazy Einstein hair, wearing a lab coat, working in a lab, or wearing glasses.
- Have students pair and share their paragraphs.
- Optional: Give each student a copy of their school picture to glue over the head of their scientist drawing. Discuss how everyone is a scientist.
- End by having students look at age-appropriate books depicting scientists in different fields: male and female, young and old, and of different nationalities. Your public library or school librarian can help collect appropriate books.
Assessment
All activities provide an assessment of prior knowledge.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 2
Time: One 50-minute class period.
Objectives
- Introduce thinking scientifically and solving problems logically.
- Use what was learned from a disproved hypothesis to guide the formation of a new hypothesis.
- Work in teams to solve problems, encouraging collaboration and sharing of ideas.
Materials
- For each group of 3 students: two pieces of clothesline, about 1.5 meters each, with a slip knot tied at each end
- Rope Problem activity pages for each student
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Complete and discuss the activity’s pre-lab questions.
Rope Problem activity
- Read through the procedure with students.
- Using volunteers, demonstrate the proper way to “tangle” the ropes.
- Place students in groups of 3.
- Explain each job: Person A, Person B, and recorder.
- Hand out materials and let students start thinking and solving problems!
- Give periodic hints as needed. I usually let the kids work for about 10 minutes before giving a hint. Without hints, they soon get frustrated and give up. Remind students that scientists frequently hit dead ends and that each “failed” hypothesis is a learning point.
- Once everyone has solved the problem, have groups answer the post-lab questions.
- Discuss the post-lab questions as a class.
Assessment
Observe whether students use good problem-solving techniques and revise their hypotheses each time. Look for evidence that they learn from disproven hypotheses and use that evidence to create an improved hypothesis. I carry a class roster spreadsheet and make notes while walking around.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 3
Time: Two 50-minute class periods, depending on pacing.
Objective
Differentiate between real science and pseudoscience.
Materials
- Bill Nye the Science Guy: Pseudoscience video
- Video activity sheet—1 per student
- Scientific Method Notes—1 per student
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Ask whether astrology is real science and whether paleontology is real science. Have students pair and share reasons why or why not.
Watch Bill Nye: Pseudoscience. Introduce the following points and viewing task:
Real science must be testable and repeatable. Pseudo-science cannot be repeated and is not really a testable problem or question.
Watch for examples of real science and pseudoscience. Write them on the chart on your video worksheet.
After the video, discuss the differences between pseudoscience and real science and list examples of each.
Scientific Method Notes
- Fill in the notes together as a class.
- Discuss how this is the formal method scientists use to solve real problems, such as determining the effect of pesticides in water on frog deformities. The lesson contrasts this with trying to validate the existence of ghosts or Bigfoot: the question “Does Bigfoot exist?” is described as not testable in a systematic way, and evidence such as a video of Bigfoot could not be repeated for validity.
- Exit card: Have students define real science and pseudoscience and give an example of each.
Assessment
Use exit cards to determine whether students understand the objective or need reteaching.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 4
Time: One 50-minute class period.
Objective
Learn vocabulary and review the steps of the scientific method.
Materials and Preparation
- BrainPOP Notes page—1 per student
- BrainPOP: www.brainpop.com. The source describes a short-term free trial.
- “I Have…Who Has…” vocabulary cards. Print two copies of the master. Laminate one copy and cut out the individual game cards. Keep the other copy intact and stapled together as a teacher’s “cheat sheet” during the game.
Lesson Overview
BrainPOP activity
- View the scientific method video. Pause occasionally so students can fill in their notes.
- Review and discuss the notes as a class.
“I Have…Who Has…” vocabulary game
- Pass out one or more cards to each student until all cards are distributed. Students do not need equal numbers of cards.
- Choose an “I have…” definition to start. The starting point does not matter because the game comes full circle.
- The student with the chosen definition begins. For example: “I have controlled experiment. Who has a way of learning about the natural world?”
- The student with the term matching that definition responds: “I have science. Who has…”
- During the first few games, give plenty of hints and prompting to prevent frustration. Correct mistakes immediately so the game stays on track. As students learn the vocabulary and gain speed, turn the game into a friendly competition by recording each class period’s fastest time on the board. The students love the challenge!
- Once students know the game, use it when you have about 5 minutes to fill at the end of class.
- If students struggle with the vocabulary, make a two-column study sheet with definitions in the right column and blank spaces for terms in the left. Students fill in terms as they play and use the sheet as a reference. Gradually release students from needing the reference page. This also provides an accommodation for students receiving special education services or needing remediation.
Assessment
Monitor students’ knowledge of scientific vocabulary and the steps of the scientific method. I print a roster spreadsheet with about 8 columns and date a column whenever we play. For each student, I record ++ (have it down), + (could use additional practice), or – (needs reteaching). Use these records to provide additional practice or individual reteaching as needed.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 5
Time: Two 50-minute class periods.
Objectives
- Differentiate between observations, inferences, and predictions.
- Differentiate between qualitative and quantitative data.
Materials
- “Boy in Water” and “Ancient Coin” activity sheets—1 copy of each per student
- Observation Mini-Lab—1 per student
- Lab materials listed on the lab sheet
The “Boy in Water” and “Ancient Coin” activities are referenced at:
http://www.blm.gov/id/st/en/fo/shoshone/wilson_butte_cave/teacher_pages/Archaeology_FUNdamentals/Observation_and_Inference_activity.html
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Play a round of “I Have…Who Has…” for vocabulary review and practice.
Observation, Inference, and Prediction: “Boy in the Water” and “Ancient Coin”
- Review observation, inference, and prediction as a class. Talk through several examples of each until students are ready to try the activity in small groups.
- Distribute “Ancient Coin.” Have students work in pairs or small groups to classify each statement as an observation, inference, or prediction. Discuss answers as a class.
- Distribute “Boy in the Water.” Have students classify statements individually, then discuss answers as a class. Students correct mistakes with a colored pen and turn in the completed activity.
Observation Mini-Lab
- Discuss qualitative (descriptive) and quantitative (numerical) data. Both are equally important; an investigation may collect one type or both.
- Have students complete the lab in pairs.
- Discuss the results as a class.
- Quiz: Have students take the short formative “Observation, Inference and Understanding Check” quiz to check their understanding of the lesson objectives.
Assessment
Sort the “Boy in the Water” activities into “has it,” “a little more practice,” and “reteach” piles. Provide future reteaching and practice for students who need it and enrichment for those who have it. Use the formative quiz to decide whether to move forward or spend time reteaching concepts.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 6
Time: One 50-minute class period.
Objectives
- Practice making predictions and writing hypotheses for a real problem.
- Make qualitative observations and organize the data in a table.
Materials
- Lab activity sheet—1 per student
- 2-liter pop bottle with 3 holes in the middle of one side, approximately ½ inch apart
- Electrical tape to cover the holes
Lesson Overview
Warm-up
- Review qualitative and quantitative data.
- Review how to write an if…then hypothesis.
- Introduce independent and dependent variables and their relationship to the if and then statements. For example: “If I pull the tape from the first hole” describes the independent variable—the variable the scientist changes on purpose. “Then water will flow from the hole” describes the dependent variable—the variable that changes in response.
Three Hole Bottle activity: Follow the lab procedure.
Hints:
- Do not pull the tape past the current hole and give away what happens next.
- Replace the tape after each class period. Waterlogged tape will not stick well, and the bottle will leak.
- Make sure the lid is tight so water does not leak from a hole when it should not.
- For fun, the teacher can stand on a table holding the bottle over a student volunteer’s head while removing tape from the holes. I like to provide a big yellow rain hat, but a large plastic trash bag will do. Nothing at all and a little bit of getting wet is also fun.
- Model how to create a data table; this will likely be students’ first time creating one.
- Exit card: Write an if…then hypothesis on the board for students to copy onto a 3 × 5 card—for example, “If I give my corn plant fertilizer every day, then it will grow taller.” Have students underline the independent variable and circle the dependent variable. Extension: Students write another hypothesis themselves, underline the independent variable, and circle the dependent variable.
Assessment
Sort exit cards into “has it,” “a little more practice,” and “reteach” piles. Provide reteaching opportunities for students who need them and enrichment for students who have it.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 7
Time: Two 50-minute class periods.
Objective
Introduce solving a problem using scientific inquiry.
Materials
- Scientific Inquiry Lab page—1 per student
- Scientific Inquiry Steps Reference Page—1 per student
- 2 small beakers
- Water
- Salt and sugar—premeasured at 3 grams each per student group
- Plastic spoon
- Timer, clock, or watch
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Review independent and dependent variables. Give students examples of hypotheses and have them practice identifying the variable in the if statement and the variable in the then statement by underlining and circling the appropriate variables.
Scientific Inquiry Lab
- Project the lab sheets on the board. Since this is students’ first time completing a lab, everyone will work through it together at the same time.
- Explain that the left side of the paper is for notes and the right side is for the lab activity.
- Work through both sides of the first page together, using the supplied key.
- Fill in the information for the data section.
- Have students work in pairs to complete the lab and record data in the table.
- Work through the conclusion section together.
- Clean up.
Assessment
Have students debrief their first complete scientific inquiry on a 3 × 5 exit card using these prompts:
- I liked…
- I didn’t like…
- I feel like I really understand…
- I am confused about…
Use the cards to identify concepts needing more review in warm-ups and other instruction.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 8
Time: One 50-minute class period.
Objectives
- Assess students’ progress in understanding the unit objectives.
- Practice writing questions and hypotheses and identifying variables for a real-world scientific problem.
Materials
- “The Strange Case of Beriberi” and “How Penicillin Was Discovered” practice sheet—1 per student
- Scientific Method Quiz
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Use exit-card and observation data to review concepts needing reteaching and/or play “I Have…Who Has…” for vocabulary practice.
Scientific Method in Action: The Strange Case of Beriberi
- Explain that this was an actual event investigated through inquiry and the scientific method.
- Read the event together.
- Work through each question using pair-and-share. Give pairs about 2 minutes to discuss question 1, explain their reasoning, and write an answer. Discuss answers as a class, then repeat for questions 2–5.
- Have students work on the penicillin problem individually. Walk around and offer help, then review correct answers as a class when everyone has finished.
- Scientific Method Quiz: Have students complete and turn in the quiz.
Assessment
Use quiz results to determine whether students need whole-class reteaching, differentiated instruction for different levels of comprehension, or are ready to move on.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 9
Time: One 50-minute class period.
Objectives
- Understand that hypotheses and theories can change when new information is discovered.
- Understand that scientists may reach different conclusions even when working with the same evidence or data.
Materials
Dogs and Turnips activity pages and word cards. The source provides this link for all materials and a detailed explanation of the procedure and purpose:
http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/education/dynamic/session4/sess4_act1.htm
Lesson Overview
Dogs and Turnips activity
- Use the linked materials and procedure.
- Copy each set of word cards on a different color of paper so that accidentally mixed sets are easy to sort.
- Have students work in pairs. Groups larger than two leave too little action for each student, and students get bored.
- Exit card/assessment: Have students write the “big ideas” they took away from the activity. Use their responses to assess understanding of the lesson objectives.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 10
Time: Two 50-minute class periods.
Objective
Apply knowledge gained throughout the unit to solving a scientific problem.
Materials
- Paper Falling Lab—1 per student
- 3 pieces of scrap paper per student
- Timer, clock, or watch
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Use informal assessments and observations from the past few days to decide what to review or reteach.
Performance assessment: Paper Falling Lab
- Explain that the lab shows whether students know how to conduct a scientific inquiry themselves.
- Write the procedure on the board. Writing a procedure is difficult, and most students are not ready to do it yet, so the lab sheet does not include a place for it.
- Read the problem together and explain what each student should demonstrate on the lab paper.
- Give each student a lab sheet, 3 pieces of paper, and a timer or access to a clock. Assign a partner to help time the falling paper. The partner helps only with timing; each student conducts an independent investigation.
- Turn the students loose to investigate!
Assessment
This unit is an introductory unit for a year-long theme of science inquiry. Students are not expected to be proficient at completing an investigation independently at this point in time. This is the first of many performance assessments that students will complete throughout the year. By the end of the year students should be proficient at completing an assessment like this by themselves. This assessment is useful in showing progress (or lack of progress) toward the objective of solving a scientific problem in a logical manner.
Scientific Thinking—Lesson 11
Time: One 50-minute class period.
Objective
Demonstrate understanding of scientific thinking.
Materials
Unit Summative Assessment—1 per student.
Lesson Overview
- Warm-up: Review concepts relevant to the test.
- Have each student complete the Unit Summative Assessment.
Assessment
Use summative assessment data to plan future differentiated instruction in scientific thinking and problem solving. This introductory unit begins a year-long theme. Monitor growth toward the unit objectives throughout the year, and provide reteaching and reassessment opportunities for students who are not proficient.
References
- Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts & Literacy in History/Social Studies, Science & Technical Subjects. (2011). Common Core State Standards. Retrieved from http://www.corestandards.org/the-standards
- Jorgenson, O., Cleveland, J. & Vanosdall R., (2004). Doing good science in middle school: A practical guide to inquiry-based instruction. Arlington, Virginia: NSTA Press
- Janulaw, A., Scotchmoor, J. (1998) Dogs and turnips. Retrieved from http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/education/dynamic/session4/sess4_act1.htm
- Nye, B. (1993-1998). Bill Nye the Science Guy. Hollywood: Disney-American Broadcasting Company.
- Scientific Method [Video file]. (1999-2012). Retrieved from www.brainpop.com
- Smith, S., Moe, J., Letts, K. & Paterson, D. (1993). Ancient Coin. Retrieved from http://www.blm.gov/id/st/en/fo/shoshone/wilson_butte_cave/teacher_pages/Archaeology_FUNdamentals/Observation_and_Inference_activity.html
- Smith, S., Moe, J., Letts, K. & Paterson, D. (1993). Boy in the water. Retrieved from http://www.blm.gov/id/st/en/fo/shoshone/wilson_butte_cave/teacher_pages/Archaeology_FUNdamentals/Observation_and_Inference_activity.html
- Tyler, R. (1949). Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
- Wyoming Science Content and Performance Standards. (2008). Wyoming Content and Performance Standards. Retrieved from http://edu.wyoming.gov/Programs/standards.aspx
Student Activities and Handouts
What Is a Scientist?
How Does a Scientist Think? What Does a Scientist Look Like?
The Rope Problem
Objective: Use scientific thinking to solve the problem of separating two individuals joined by two strands of rope.
Problem: You and your partner are attached by two ropes crossed over each other. Find a way to get apart without untying or breaking the ropes.
Pre-Lab Questions
- Were you curious after reading the problem? What was the first thing you thought about?
- List as many steps as you can think of that scientists use to solve problems.
Observe Figure 1. What is your predicted answer to the problem? Describe how you and your partner will get apart.
What scientific term describes a predicted answer to a problem?
Put your predicted answer into if…then form:
If (what you are going to do)_________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________, then (what will happen)______________________________________________________
Materials
- 2 pieces of string, each 1.5 meters long
- Functioning brain
Procedure
- Decide who will direct the untangling and take notes, and which two people will be tied together as Persons A and B.
- Person A: Take one rope and slip one loop onto your right hand and the other onto your left.
- Person B: Slip one loop of your rope onto your left hand. Pass the free end between your partner’s rope and their body, then slip the remaining loop onto your right hand. See Figure 1. Congratulations—you should be joined together!
Attempt to separate yourselves. You may not:
- Cut the ropes
- Untie the knots
- Slip the loops off your hands
Yes! It is physically possible!
- While the two people work to untangle themselves, the director helps and records their steps. The tangled partners should call out each step so the director can record it precisely. Someone else will follow these instructions.
- On the next page, write your solution and every step you took to reach it. Be specific enough that you could separate another pair just by reading the directions—without pointing, helping, showing, or using names. Use numbered steps, not a paragraph.
- Good luck! Use the Force if you have the gift…
Post-Lab Thoughts
- Explain how you thought like a scientist to solve this problem.
- Was another group able to repeat the solution using your directions? A solution needs to be repeatable to be considered “real science.” Would you consider this problem and solution real science? Why or why not?
- Is it valuable for scientists to work as a team? Use today’s activity to explain why teamwork might be valuable.
| What are you going to do? | Did it work? | What are you going to change? |
|---|---|---|
| ________________ | ________________ | ________________ |
Bill Nye: Pseudoscience
Name: ____________________ Date: __________ Period: __________
Write examples of real science and pseudoscience in the boxes.
| Real Science | Pseudoscience |
|---|---|
| ________________ | ________________ |
In the Venn diagram, compare and contrast real science and pseudoscience. In the left circle, write things that apply only to real science. In the right circle, write things that apply only to pseudoscience. In the overlap, write things that apply to both.
Scientific Method Notes
Curiosities & Questions
As we make______________ about the world around us, we get curious about some things. These curiosities prompt us to form __________________.
Hypothesis
We want to figure out the answers to these questions so we make a ___________________ based on our observations. In science we call an educated prediction a ______________________. A ____________________ is a _______________, __________________, and ______________________ prediction that answers the question. Many times hypotheses are written in ______,______ format.
Experiment
________________ test the hypothesis. There are many things to consider and identify when preparing your experiment.
- Independent Variable: the part of the experiment you _________ on __________, the ____ part of the hypothesis.
- Dependent Variable: the part of the experiment you make ____________ about or take ________________ on, the ______ part of the hypothesis.
- Control Trials: The ____________ trials. What you compare the experimental trials to.
- Experimental Trials: The trials you have ______________ or done something to, the ones you hope show a _______________ from the control trials.
- Constants: Parts of the experiment you keep the __________ so you know for sure that your independent variable caused the change, not something else.
Of course you should always ______________ your entire experiment to make sure your data is ______________.
Organizing Data
Data should always be organized in a _________ and ___________ data table. The ________________________ usually goes across the _______. The ________________________ usually goes down the _________. You should always use a ___________ when drawing a data table.
Analyzing Results
Once you have organized the data in a table, look for ____________ in the data. Analyze these patterns to make __________________ (a _______________ based on ________________ and _________________). A good way to look for trends is to _________ the data and evaluate the graph.
Theory & Law
If repeated experiments support the ___________ it can become _________________________. For example, the Law of Gravity. Scientific law is accepted until new evidence proves otherwise.
Reporting Results
One of the most important concepts behind the scientific method is that experiments are __________ by others. Most results go through a process called ______________. Other scientists read and evaluate the experiment, making sure the original researchers followed all steps of the ____________ _________________.
BrainPOP: Scientific Method
- What is the first step in scientific problem solving? ______________________
- Next, make a list of things we already _______________ about the problem.
- Then make some ________________________ about the problem.
- An __________________________ is a conclusion about our observations.
- We transfer the inference into a __________________________.
- 6. A _________________________ is a testable explanation for the things you observe.
- 7. You then create an _________________________ to test the hypothesis.
- 8. In an experiment the following things are kept the same: type of pot, soil and sunlight. These are the ________________________ for the experiment. (The things that are kept the same to keep the experiment fair)
- 9. The ____________________ is the thing in an experiment that changes. There should only be one thing that changes.
- 10. After conducting the experiment, you record new _________________________
- 11. After you are done observing and recording your observations (data) you should _______________________ the data.
- 12. Once you have analyzed the data, you can make a ______________________
- 13. To be really sure of a conclusion you should __________________ the experiment several times.
- 14. If the experimental data doesn’t support the hypothesis, then the hypothesis needs to be __________________________
- 15. If lots and lots of experiments do support the hypothesis, that hypothesis can eventually become a ________________________.
- 16. A _______________ is an explanatory statement that’s been repeatedly confirmed through experimental testing.
- 17. A theory that has been confirmed over and over can become ________________.
- 18. There is no such thing as scientific ______________ because scientists are always learning new things about the world around us.
- 19. If you form a hypothesis without any observations then you are really just __________________.
“I Have…Who Has…” Vocabulary Card Master
| I have… | Who has… |
|---|---|
| Controlled Experiment | A way of learning about the natural world. |
| Science | Using one or more of your senses and sometimes tools to gather information. |
| Observation | The way that scientists study and make explanations about the natural world. |
| Scientific Inquiry | A curiosity about the natural world that comes from your experiences, observations and inferences. |
| Scientific Question | The grouping together of objects that are alike in some way. |
| Classifying | The one variable that is purposely changed. Also known as the independent variable. |
| Manipulated Variable | A summary of what you have learned from an experiment. |
| Conclusion | Observation that deals with numbers or amounts. |
| Quantitative Observation | A possible, testable answer to a question. |
| Hypothesis | Facts, figures, and other evidence gathered through qualitative and quantitative evidence. |
| Data | Comparing observations and data to reach a conclusion. |
| Evaluating | A representation of a complex object or process that cannot be studied directly. |
| Model | The change that you observe in an experiment. Also known as the dependent variable. |
| Responding Variable | A well-tested explanation of an observation or hypothesis. |
| Theory | A statement about what will happen in the future based on past experience or evidence. |
| Prediction | One of the tools that can help you interpret data. |
| Graph | Observations that are descriptive and cannot be expressed in numbers. |
| Qualitative Observation | A statement that describes what scientists expect to happen every time for a certain event. |
| Scientific Law | The variable that you purposely change in an experiment. Also known as the manipulated variable. |
| Independent Variable | An explanation for what is currently happening or has happened based on observations and evidence. |
| Inference | An experiment that has followed sound scientific principles. |
| Valid Experiment | A place where you can collect and record your data in an organized way. |
| Data Table | All the variables in an experiment that you keep the same in order for the experiment to be consistent. |
| Controlled Variables | A mistake in the design of an experiment that makes a particular result more likely. |
| Experimental Bias | Sharing scientific ideas and results through meetings, the Internet, and scientific journals. |
| Scientific Communication | Interpreting data by looking for trends or patterns. |
| Analysis | The change that you observe in an experiment. Also known as the responding variable. |
| Dependent Variable | An experiment in which only one variable is manipulated at a time. |
Observation Mini-Lab
Name: ____________________ Period: __________
* Scientists use the skill of observation to gain knowledge about the natural world.
* Quantitative observations deal with _________________________. * Qualitative observations deal with __________________________.
Materials: marbles, buttons, rulers, magnifying lenses Procedure: Observe objects both quantitatively and qualitatively.
Data
Quantitative Qualitative Observations (numbers) Observations (descriptions) 1.______________________________ 1.___________________________________ 2.______________________________ 2.___________________________________ 3.______________________________ 3.___________________________________ 4.______________________________ 4.___________________________________ 5.______________________________ 5.___________________________________
Post-Lab Evaluation
- Was it easier to make quantitative or qualitative observations? Why?
- Why is observation useful to scientists?
- Why is it important to be detailed and use complete sentences when recording observations?
- Write 2 quantitative and 2 qualitative observations about the classroom.
Quantitative Qualitative Observations (numbers) Observations (descriptions) 1.______________________________ 1.___________________________________ 2.______________________________ 2.___________________________________
Three-Hole Bottle Mystery!
Making Predictions and Writing Hypotheses
Writing Hypotheses
In this activity you will be practicing hypothesis writing. This form of predicting follows some rules. Hypotheses must be written in ______..._______ format. For example, If I give my plant 5 grams of fertilizer per week, then it will grow faster than without fertilizer. Hypotheses must also be ________________, _____________________ and ____________. Hypotheses can either be proven correct or false through ____________________.
The Activity
- 1. Sketch the bottle and label the approximate location of the holes and the tape. Make any other observations about the bottle now.
Write a hypothesis about what will happen when the tape is pulled from the first hole. Use if…then format.
If the tape is pulled from the first hole, then_____________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________
Predict and sketch how the bottle will look and the path you think the water will take.
3. Now the fun part. Pull the tape down from the FIRST HOLE ONLY. Observe what happens for a few seconds then replace the tape over the first hole. Record your observations and sketch how the bottle looked and the path that the water took.
Did your observations show your hypothesis to be correct or false?__________________.
Write a hypothesis about what will happen when the tape is pulled from the first and second holes. Use if…then format.
If the tape is pulled from the first and second holes, then__________________________ _________________________________________________________________________
Predict and sketch how the bottle will look and the path you think the water will take.
5. Pull the tape down from the FIRST AND SECOND HOLES ONLY. Observe what happens for a few seconds then replace the tape over the first hole. Record your observations and sketch how the bottle looked and the path that the water took.
Did your observations show your hypothesis to be correct or false?__________________.
Write a hypothesis about what will happen when the tape is pulled from all three holes. Use if…then format.
If ______________________________________________________, then____________ _________________________________________________________________________
Predict and sketch how the bottle will look and the path you think the water will take.
7. Pull the tape down from ALL 3 HOLES. Observe what happens for a few seconds then replace the tape over the first hole. Record your observations and sketch how the bottle looked and the path that the water took.
Did your observations show your hypothesis to be correct or false?__________________.
Data
Create a data table for your observations. There is no “right” way to do this; make sure it is easy to read and includes all your observations. Always use a ruler to draw your data table!
Part II
Turn the bottle on the horizontal, with the holes facing down and the tape in place. What will happen when the holes are uncovered in sequence? Write the hypotheses and sketches below.
1. 1st Hole uncovered If_______________________________________________________________________ Then____________________________________________________________________ Sketch: 2. 2nd Hole uncovered If_______________________________________________________________________ Then____________________________________________________________________ Sketch 3. 3rd Hole uncovered If_______________________________________________________________________ Then____________________________________________________________________ Sketch:
Data
Create a data table in which to record your observations. Always use a ruler to draw your data table!
Analyze the Data
- What surprised you about the results?
- Did your hypotheses become increasingly specific?
- Is this data quantitative or qualitative?
The Steps of Scientific Inquiry
Make a Plan
What is your independent or manipulated variable?
Independent/Manipulated Variable: The part of the experiment you change on purpose—what you will do, test, or manipulate. This is the if part of your hypothesis and the if part of your question.
What is your dependent or responding variable?
Dependent/Responding Variable: The part of the experiment you observe or measure, this is what you predict will happen as a result of your experiment. This will be the then part of your hypothesis and the Will part of your question!
Question
Use a “Will…if” question format. The question should be testable, specific, and detailed. The will part is your prediction (dependent/responding variable). The if part is what you, the scientist, are doing (independent/manipulated variable).
Abstract
Background Knowledge: In this section you talk about what you already know about the question. It is a good place to define any science terms.
What will I do? Write the numbered steps of the procedure, for example, 1…, 2…
What do I expect to happen, and why? Explain your prediction and your reasoning. Why are you making this prediction?
Hypothesis
An if…then statement that is specific, testable, and measurable and makes a prediction. The if part describes what you are doing in the experiment (independent/manipulated variable). The then part describes your prediction (dependent/responding variable).
Constants
These are the things you have to keep the same for all trials to keep your experiment fair.
Data
Data is usually organized into a table to keep it neat, organized, and easy to understand. Usually you perform 3 or more trials and find an average. Sometimes we collect class data to gather more data. ALWAYS LABEL your data. Qualitative Data: words/descriptions Quantitative Data: numbers/ measurements
Conclusion
Accept or reject the hypothesis: Analyze your data. Overall, was your hypothesis supported by your results? If it was proven true by your data, accept it. If your data does not support it, reject it.
Restate the hypothesis: Rewrite your entire hypothesis word for word.
Evidence: Prove that you made the right choice when you accepted or rejected your hypothesis by backing up your decision with data! If you have averages of data provide all the numbers! Tell all your proof for rejecting or accepting your hypothesis.
Difference? Significant? Defend your choice by finding the difference between the variables tested and indicating whether the difference in results seems significant to you.
Scientific Inquiry Introduction
Definition/Description and Example: Does sugar or salt dissolve faster?
| Definition/Description | Example | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Independent/Manipulated Variable: The part of the experiment you change on _____________, what you think the ________ is, the _____ part of your hypothesis. | Independent/Manipulated Variable: ____________________ | |||||||||||||||
| Dependent/Responding Variable: The part of the experiment you ___________ or _________ during the experiment, what you predict the _______ is, the _____ part of the hypothesis. | Dependent/Responding Variable: ____________________ | |||||||||||||||
| Question: A “_____–_______” question that is ____________, ___________, and ___________. The will part predicts how the dependent variable will be affected. The if part describes what you will do to the independent variable. | Will________________________ ___________________________ if _______________________ __________________________? | |||||||||||||||
Background Knowledge: In this section you talk about what you already _________ that relates to the ___________. It is a good place to__________ the science terms you are using. What I will do: In this section you summarize the experiment in a few brief, concise statements. What I expect to happen and why: Explain what you expect the dependent variable to do when you change the independent variable and ____________ __________ using good science! | Abstract: Background Knowledge: ____________________ What I will do: ____________________ What I expect to happen and WHY: ____________________ | |||||||||||||||
| Hypothesis: An “_____–________” statement that is specific, testable, and measurable and makes a prediction. The ___ part describes what you will do to your independent variable. The ______ part predicts how that will affect your dependent variable. | If ________________________ __________________________ then ______________________ __________________________ | |||||||||||||||
| Constants: Things you keep the ______________ for all trials to keep the experiment _____________________. | Constants: ____________________ | |||||||||||||||
Data is usually organized into a __________ to keep it neat, organized and easy to _______________. Usually you perform 3 trials, and find the ___________ for each, but if you have time, more trials are always __________. The more trials you perform, the more ____________ your data is. Class data is often collected. ALWAYS LABEL YOUR DATA!!! Qualitative Data: _________________ Quantitative Data: ___________________ | Independent Variable: ____________________ Dependent Variable: ____________________
| |||||||||||||||
Conclusion: Accept or Reject Hypothesis Analyze your data. Overall, was your hypothesis supported by your results? If it was proven true by your results, you need to ______________ it. If your results do not all support your hypothesis, you need to _____________ it. Restate Hypothesis: Re-write your entire hypothesis, __________ for ___________ Evidence:______________ that you made the right choice when you accepted or rejected your hypothesis by backing up your decision with ____________. If you have averages of data provide the numbers! This is a great moment to reveal all your PROOF for rejecting or accepting the hypothesis! Difference? Significant? ______________ your choice by finding the difference between the average results for your variable and indicating whether the difference seems _________________ to you. | Conclusion: Accept or Reject Hypothesis Based on the results of my experiment I _________ my hypothesis that If _____________ ___________________________ ___________________________ ___________________________ My evidence to support this is that the time for salt to dissolve was ________, and the time for sugar to dissolve was ___________. The difference between the time for sugar and salt to dissolve was ___________ which _________ seem significant to me. |
Scientific Inquiry Introduction—Partially Completed Version
Example: Does sugar or salt dissolve faster? The scientific question.
The supplied second version repeats the introduction worksheet above, with these completed portions:
- If it was proven true by your results, you need to accept it.
- If your results do not all support your hypothesis, you need to reject it.
- Restate Hypothesis: Rewrite your entire hypothesis, word for word.
- Evidence: Defend that you made the right choice when you accepted or rejected your hypothesis by backing up your decision with data. If you have averages, provide the numbers. Reveal all your evidence for rejecting or accepting the hypothesis.
- Difference? Significant? Support your choice by finding the difference between the average results for your variable and indicating whether the difference seems significant to you.
Based on the results of my experiment I _accept or reject____ my hypothesis that If_____________ ___________________________ ___________________________ ___________________________ My evidence to support this is that the time for salt to dissolve was __( ) sec_, and the time for sugar to dissolve was (__) sec______. The difference between the time for sugar and salt to dissolve was _______sec____ which __does or does not_______ seem significant to me.
Scientific Method in Action!
The Strange Case of Beriberi
In 1887, a strange nerve disease attacked people in the Dutch East Indies. The disease was beriberi. Symptoms included weakness and loss of appetite; victims often died of heart failure. Scientists thought bacteria might cause the disease. They injected chickens with bacteria from the blood of patients with beriberi. The injected chickens became sick, but so did chickens that were not injected.
One of the scientists, Dr. Eijkman, noticed something. Before the experiment, all the chickens had eaten whole-grain rice, but during the experiment, the chickens were fed polished rice. Dr. Eijkman researched this interesting case, and he found that polished rice lacked thiamine, a vitamin necessary for good health.
- State the problem.
- What was the hypothesis?
- How was the hypothesis tested?
- Should the hypothesis be supported or rejected based on the experiment?
- What should the new hypothesis be?
How Penicillin Was Discovered
In 1928, Sir Alexander Fleming was studying Staphylococcus bacteria growing in culture dishes. He noticed that a mold called Penicillium was also growing in some of the dishes. A clear area existed around the mold because all the bacteria that had grown in this area had died. In the culture dishes without the mold, no clear areas were present.
Fleming hypothesized that the mold must be producing a chemical that killed the bacteria. He decided to isolate this substance and test it to see if it would kill bacteria. Fleming transferred the mold to a nutrient broth solution. This solution contained all the materials the mold needed to grow. After the mold grew, he removed it from the nutrient broth. Fleming then added the nutrient broth in which the mold had grown to a culture of bacteria. He observed that the bacteria died.
6. Identify the problem.
7. What was Fleming’s hypothesis?
8. How was the hypothesis tested?
9. Should the hypothesis be supported or rejected based on the experiment?
10. This experiment led to the development of what major medical advancement?
Scientific Inquiry & Scientific Skills Quiz
Name: ____________________ Date: __________ Period: __________ Score: _____ / 30
Circle the independent variable and underline the dependent variable in questions 1-4.
- 1. If I wash my hands with soap, then I won’t get sick.
- My watermelons will be bigger if I fertilize them once a week.
- 3. I want to see if wearing sunscreen at the track meet will keep me from getting sunburned.
- 4. I wonder if I can run faster if I wear my track cleats during my race?
- The independent variable is usually the ______ statement in a hypothesis.
- The dependent variable is usually the ______ statement in a hypothesis.
- Another name for the independent variable is the _________________________ variable.
- Another name for the dependent variable is the _________________________ variable.
- The other parts of the experiment that you keep the same to keep the experiment fair are called _________________________ variables.
- Quantitative data is (numerical, descriptive).
- Qualitative data is (numerical, descriptive).
Label each example as qualitative (QL) or quantitative (QT) data.
- 25 grams ______
- Straight hair ______
- 5.0 meters ______
- 2/3 of students ______
- Straightest flight ______
- 7.2 seconds ______
Use your knowledge of scientific inquiry to answer the following questions. Trent and Suzie wanted to clean their Mom and Dad’s cars because they were REALLY dirty! Trent thought that vinegar and warm water would be the best cleaner, while Suzie thought that soap and warm water would work best. Since both cars were of equal dirtiness to begin with the kids had a contest to see which car would be the shiniest once cleaned.
- Write a scientific question.
- Write a testable hypothesis.
- What is the independent/manipulated variable?
- What is the dependent/responding variable?
- List 3 constants.
Summative Assessment: Skills Scientists Use & Scientific Inquiry
Read the following scientific scenario:
Sally wants to grow the biggest pumpkin for the Jack-O-Lantern contest. Sally thinks using “Pumpkin-Gro” fertilizer will make her pumpkins bigger. Sally decided to plant 10 pumpkin plants. She watered half of them (5 plants) with plain water. She watered the other half (5 plants) with water mixed with “Pumpkin-Gro” fertilizer. After growing the pumpkins for 4 months, Sally measured the diameter of each pumpkin. The results are shown in the data table.
Please be specific and detailed when answering the following questions:
- What is Sally’s hypothesis? Use if…then format.
- What is the control group?
- What is the independent variable?
- What is the dependent variable?
- What are 3 variables Sally needs to control?
- Based on the data, should Sally accept or reject her hypothesis? (Accept / Reject)
- What should Sally’s conclusion be?
- Is Sally’s data quantitative or qualitative?
Scientific Inquiry Lab: Paper Falling
Which shape of paper falls fastest: An unfolded sheet of paper, a paper folded in fourths, or a sheet of crumpled paper?
Make Your Plan
- What is your independent or manipulated variable?
- What is your dependent or responding variable?
- Write your question using the correct form.
- Write your hypothesis using the correct form.
- What are your constants? List at least 3.
Data
Place your data in the table. Label the dependent and independent variables.
| Independent Variable: __________ | Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 | Trial 4 | Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| __________ | _____ | _____ | _____ | _____ | _____ |
| __________ | _____ | _____ | _____ | _____ | _____ |
| __________ | _____ | _____ | _____ | _____ | _____ |
Dependent Variable: ____________________
Calculations
Show your work. To find an average, add the trials together and divide the sum by the number of trials. Here, add trials 1–4 and divide by 4.
Average for ___________ paper: _______ + _______ + _______ + _______ = ______÷ 4 = Average for ___________ paper: _______ + _______ + _______ + _______ = ______÷ 4 = Average for ___________ paper: _______ + _______ + _______ + _______ = ______÷ 4 =
Find your largest difference:
___________ paper fell in the slowest average time which was ______s. ___________ paper fell in the fastest average time which was ______s.
The difference between these two numbers, using subtraction, is ______ s.
Is this qualitative or quantitative data, and why?
Conclusion
Based on the data from my experiment, I reject or accept the hypothesis that (Restate your hypothesis WORD FOR WORD)________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
The evidence to support this is that the average time for an unfolded piece of paper was __________ s, for a sheet folded in fourths was _______s, and a crumpled sheet of paper was _______s. The difference between the _____________ piece of paper and _____________ piece of paper was __________s. This difference does or does not seem significant to me. Therefore, I conclude that ________________________ paper is the shape of paper which does significantly or does not significantly fall the fastest.
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/4586.html