Teachers.Net
JoinLog in
Teachers.Net

Law of Multiple Proportions

By Kelly O'Sullivan

  • Science
  • Senior
Activity Time
part of a lesson
Materials
Flinn's Old Foamie demo and a handout

Compare the Three Laws

I started by giving students a group writing assignment: compare and contrast the laws of conservation of mass, definite composition, and multiple proportions. They could work together, but the writing had to be in their own words.

They could all get conservation of mass—no problem—and definite composition usually doesn't give them too many problems. But multiple proportions always seems to raise questions and furrow brows. I let them work to a point of frustration in groups, then asked them to sit back down for Flinn Scientific's “Old Foamie” demonstration.

Safety and Preparation

Be sure to read Flinn's instructions for this demonstration before trying it. They give many safety instructions. Hydrogen peroxide is a strong oxidizer and can be dangerous to work with, especially when fresh. I got a white burn on my thumb from it. Remember the safety precautions for this lab.

The “Old Foamie” Demonstration

For the demonstration, put 20 mL of hydrogen peroxide in a tall graduated cylinder, add 7 mL of dish soap, then add a premeasured 10 mL of NaI and stand back.

I used water the first time instead of hydrogen peroxide and pretended something was supposed to happen. I said, “Well, let's see,” and wrote the formulas on the board as I said, “I was supposed to take H₂O₂”—but I wrote H₂O—“and add some NaI and some soap.”

Usually by this time, students say something like, “That's the formula for water, isn't it?” I say, “Ohhhhhh, that little 2 there makes a big difference, doesn't it? Let's see what happens when we use H₂O₂.”

It foams and bubbles, and they love it. I point out that hydrogen and oxygen are in two different ratios—two different proportions. The same elements can be found in different compounds, and the difference in ratios gives them very different properties.

Alternative Demonstration

The same comparison can be made with 3% hydrogen peroxide from the store: pour it on raw liver. I learned this at the Hasti conference. It smells a little, but it's gross, so the kids like it a lot. Use water the first time and then hydrogen peroxide. Do the same chalkboard discussion.

Return to the Writing Assignment

Then I let students return, individually or in groups, to the writing assignment. The difference in understanding is so neat to watch—they just start writing away with such confidence. A picture is worth a thousand words. Thanks, Flinn!

Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/638.html