Bill Of Rights Interpretation
- Social Studies
- Senior

- Activity Time
- Materials
- Concepts / Topics
Students interpret an assigned Bill of Rights amendment in pairs, research and survey opinions about their interpretations, evaluate the information, and present their findings.
Student Teacher: Emma Paton | Date: December 11, 2009 | Grade Level: 12 | Topic/Unit: Bill of Rights Interpretation
Content
Students interpret an amendment from the Bill of Rights, survey people, and research online to find out whether others agree or disagree with their interpretation. The lesson teaches students how to find useful information on the internet and how to gather surveys and evaluate their accuracy. Students then present their findings to the class.
Benchmarks
Each student will be evaluated on their interpretation of the Bill of Rights and whether they found support for that interpretation. Students will also be graded on whether they understand if their information is trustworthy and represents the whole population. The project is intended to help students better understand what makes something a fact and why it is difficult to obtain equal representation through surveys. Students should use facts in their presentations and distinguish them from other people’s opinions.
Learning Resources and Materials
- Inspiration to help students organize their projects
- Computers with internet access to find information and conduct online surveys
- Paper to conduct surveys of their peers
Development of the Lesson
Introduction
- Prepare students for learning with a lecture on Wikipedia, explaining that anyone can contribute an answer and presenting this as a reason it is not reliable for information.
- Focus students’ attention and interest by explaining the Bill of Rights and giving examples of court cases that interpreted the laws differently than we would anticipate.
- Use an example of students “misinterpreting” a rule their parents gave them and the consequences. Relate this to how a person could misinterpret the law.
Methods and Procedures
- Ask students to form pairs. Each pair interprets its assigned amendment from the Bill of Rights in two different ways.
- Each student takes one interpretation and uses surveys, both online and in person, as well as research to find out whether others agree with it.
- Allow several days in class for students to investigate whether they interpreted the amendment correctly based on people’s opinions, whether their research is reliable, and what the “right” interpretation should be.
- Have students present their findings to the class.
Accommodations and Adaptations
Each student will show me what they are working on step by step and will be able to ask questions throughout the project. For students with different learning levels, I can provide a list of websites that could help them find the answers they are looking for.
As the project progresses, I will note whether students are realizing that there is not much reliable information. Students who express this realization will receive higher grades. For feedback, I will continually ask whether sources are reliable and reinforce the idea that interpretations and personal opinions are not facts.
Any student who mentions in their presentation that reliable information is hard to come by, or that their results are not very accurate because of opinions or surveys that do not represent the population, will receive an A. Grades will be lowered according to how little students recognize the unreliable aspects of their projects.
Assessment and Evaluation
Evaluate each student’s project using these questions:
- Did the student understand the difference between reliable and unreliable information?
- Did the student use their time wisely and ask for help as needed?
- Did the student think outside the box to find information that would prove the interpretation right or wrong?
- How confident was the student in their interpretation?
Closure
After all presentations, discuss as a class how hard reliable information is to find and how much more believable an interpretation is when facts support it. Discuss how to recognize opinions versus facts, and recap why students need to be careful about treating websites as experts on a subject.
Teacher Reflection
- What three things went well in the lesson?
- Was this lesson successful?
- Did the students get the content goal out of the assignment?
- What would you change before doing the assignment again?
- Was this assignment helpful to the students or just a huge frustration?
Teachers.Net · https://teachers.net/lessons/913.html