I have never heard of 6 traits either, but I do not teach English.
I am a Spanish teacher who learned the Collins method while
working at an all boys K-9 school. The boys there appreciated the
clarity of the Collins method, and because the school had embraced
it as a whole, they knew what the expectations would be from year
to year, not to panic about spelling during Type 1, etc. It
alleviated anxiety and promoted neat writing and creativity within
a clear set of standards. As a foreign language teacher, one of
the biggest challenges I face is the "bad at Spanish" mentality,
which effectively prevents them from taking in new information. I
ask for Type 1 and Type 2 writing on a regular basis because it
allows them to get ideas out using specific parameters. It may be
obvious, but it is standardized, and that really helps.
Posts on this thread, including this one