On 11/13/16, Meghan wrote: > I have finished filming my 2 videos and have started > the writing portion of the component. In completing > the Instructional Context Sheet, can I just copy and > paste the answers for questions 1, 2, 3, and 4 for both > videos? One video focuses on small group math > instruction and the other is a whole-group social > studies lesson, but both videos have the same > students and instructional characteristics.
On 11/13/16, What Works wrote: > If...See MoreHello Meghan! I am just starting to think about what I should video...I am going to video my lesson tomorrow so that I can get my students use to being in the situation. Do you have any helpful suggestions for me when getting ready to film or actually filming? I will be filming a math class as well :)
On 11/13/16, What Works wrote: > If the information for these prompts is identical for each > video, then yes, you can copy and paste. > > > > > On 11/13/16, Meghan wrote: >> I have finished filming my 2 videos and have started >> the writing portion of the component. In completing >> the Instructional Context Sheet, can I just copy and >> paste the answers for questions 1, 2, 3, and 4 for both >> videos? One video focuses on small group math >> instruction and the other is a whole-group social >> studies lesson, but both videos have the same >> students and instructional characteristics.
On 10/22/16, Jackie H wrote: > Hi Kathy, > I am in the same boat, 6th grade teacher, embarking on EA > Math. > > > On 10/04/16, Kathy wrote: >> Hello! I am just starting out on the new adventure known as >> NBTC in the EA Math area. Looking online, it doesn't appear >> to have a large group of support groups, etc. Are there any >> other EA Math people out there who know of some places I > can >> go other than my local support circle? Any advice is >> appreciated! (I am a 6th grade math teacher so am prepping >> to update myself with the following grades.)
On 11/11/...See MoreHello! I have completed components 1 and 2 for EA Math and am working on components 3 and 4 this year. I am going to a short training on those components on Saturday and I am trying to get a trial video done tomorrow just to start to get my kids use to the camera. I too am finding that we don't have many EA math people out there!
On 11/11/16, Josh wrote: > Hi Kathy and Jackie. I have completed components 1 & 2 in > EA Math. I'm currently awaiting my scores for component 2, > and I'm starting component 3. I will be happy to help any way > I can. > > On 10/22/16, Jackie H wrote: >> Hi Kathy, >> I am in the same boat, 6th grade teacher, embarking on EA >> Math. >> >> >> On 10/04/16, Kathy wrote: >>> Hello! I am just starting out on the new adventure known > as >>> NBTC in the EA Math area. Looking online, it doesn't > appear >>> to have a large group of support groups, etc. Are there > any >>> other EA Math people out there who know of some places > I >> can >>> go other than my local support circle? Any advice is >>> appreciated! (I am a 6th grade math teacher so am > prepping >>> to update myself with the following grades.)
KittyOn 11/30/16, Susan wrote: > On 11/29/16, Kitty wrote: >> Help! >> I need ideas for this for elementary students I see once >> a week! What kind of focus group that I would collaborate >> with their classroom teachers? My husband (a 4th grade >> teacher) and I trying to figure out how we would >> collaborate. T...See MoreOn 11/30/16, Susan wrote: > On 11/29/16, Kitty wrote: >> Help! >> I need ideas for this for elementary students I see once >> a week! What kind of focus group that I would collaborate >> with their classroom teachers? My husband (a 4th grade >> teacher) and I trying to figure out how we would >> collaborate. The best I have come up with now for a >> small focus group with special needs in my students with >> physical disabilities because we also have a Physical >> therapist at our school, but it is only 3 students. Other >> than that, I do not collaborate with teachers and parents >> on much with the students other than discipline. I mean, >> yes, if their overhand throw is weak, I would love for >> the parents to practice with them, but it is not really a >> collaborative process. Any ideas? For some reason, I am >> really stumped on this. > > Kitty, > Do you use Brain Breaks in your class? It might allow for a > purposeful collaboration between you, your students, and > other colleagues. > Susan
Thanks for the idea Susan. PE is essentially Brain Breaks. I can collaborate with other teachers on to implement Brain breaks in their classroom, but that does not really meet Board Certification requirement of formative and summative assessments with a instructional unit. I don't think that would qualify for Component 4.
Just to clarify: For the student need /professional need/ learning communities part of Component 4, you do need to show collaboration. But for the formative and summative assessments, you don't need to show collaboration. The F & S assessments are assessments you give your own students on PE skills/units you teach. They are "self-contained" if you will and don't need to include others.
C4 is a learning experience for all of us. Keep digging, and good luck!
On 11/30/16, Kitty wrote: > On 11/30/16, Susan wrote: >> On 11/29/16, Kitty wrote: >>> Help! >>> I need ideas for this for elementary students I see once >>> a week! What kind of focus group that I would collaborate >>> with their classroom teachers? My husband (a 4th grade >>> teacher) and I trying to figure out how we would >>> collaborate. The best I have come up with now for a >>> small focus group with special needs in my students with >>> physical disabilities because we also have a Physical >>> therapist at our school, but it is only 3 students. Other >>> than that, I do not collaborate with teachers and parents >>> on much with the students other than discipline. I mean, >>> yes, if their overhand throw is weak, I would love for >>> the parents to practice with them, but it is not really a >>> collaborative process. Any ideas? For some reason, I am >>> really stumped on this. >> >> Kitty, >> Do you use Brain Breaks in your class? It might allow for a >> purposeful collaboration between you, your students, and >> other colleagues. >> Susan > > > Thanks for the idea Susan. PE is essentially Brain Breaks. I > can collaborate with other teachers on to implement Brain > breaks in their classroom, but that does not really meet > Board Certification requirement of formative and summative > assessments with a instructional unit. I don't think that > would qualify for Component 4.
Just beginning the renewal process in Exceptional Needs. I'm at a loss on where to begin. Can anyone offer some advice on how to get started? I thought I would just sit and type responses to the prompt like I did with my original certification, but it isn't that easy! HELP!!
Renewal is a different "animal" than your original certification. Here are some suggestions:
1. There is an active, excellent renewal group on yahoo. Go to yahoo.groups.NBCrenewal. This group should prove very helpful.
There are prompts to answer for each Component.
2.Component 1: Start by brainstorming a list of everything you can think of that you've done professionally since you originally certified. Think: workshops/ certifications/degrees, committees, programs you've started/worked on/organized, after school/community projects etc. From that list choose 4 that you feel you could discuss in depth. These are called PGEs (Professional Growth Experiences).
Component 2: Choose ONE of the four discussed in C1 and discuss it more.Demonstrate its application within your original certificate area (make a short video)
Component 3:Select ANOTHER PGE and demonstrate its direct or indirect application to student learning.
Component 4: Reflection
The 4 Components together should require about the same amount of time you put into 1 Entry when you originally certified.
Go to the NBCrenewal site for lots more help. Good Luck!
On 11/29/16, Pam wrote: > Just beginning the renewal process in Exceptional Needs. > I'm at a loss on where to begin. Can anyone offer some > advice on how to get started? I thought I would just sit > and type responses to the prompt like I did with my > original certification, but it isn't that easy! HELP!!
Renewal is a different "animal" than your original certification. Here are some suggestions:
1. There is an active, excellent renewal group on yahoo. Go to yahoo.groups.NBCrenewal. This group should prove very helpful.
There are prompts to answer for each Component.
2.Component 1: Start by brainstorming a list of everything you can think of that you've done professionally since you originally certified. Think: workshops/ certifications/degrees, committees, programs you've started/worked on/organized, after school/community projects etc. From that list choose 4 that you feel you could discuss in depth. These are called PGEs (Professional Growth Experiences).
Component 2: Choose ONE of the four discussed in C1 and discuss it more.Demonstrate its application within your original certificate area (make a short video)
Component 3:Select ANOTHER PGE and demonstrate its direct or indirect application to student learning.
Component 4: Reflection
The 4 Components together should require about the same amount of time you put into 1 Entry when you originally certified.
Go to the NBCrenewal site for lots more help. Good Luck!
On 11/29/16, Pam wrote: > Just beginning the renewal process in Exceptional Needs. > I'm at a loss on where to begin. Can anyone offer some > advice on how to get started? I thought I would just sit > and type responses to the prompt like I did with my > original certification, but it isn't that easy! HELP!!
On 11/09/16, Ann wrote: > I certified from the old process as a retake candidate. I was > sure I was going to get a congratulations or three from my > administration but I was very wrong! I do work in a NYC > school and understand that NBPTS is not very popular, > however, I know they knew how hard I worked and how much this > meant to me. I am very sad that at my school I was not > recognized as a NBCT!
Congratulations (again)! As What Works said, too often teachers who excel are not recognized. Hold your head up high and keep doing the great work you do. It's all about the kids, I know - but it sure helps if you get a pat on the back every now and then - especially when you've worked this hard!
BTW - my district did 'recognize' me. They asked me to come to a Board meeting (I went to all of them anyway!) and called me up and presented me with a certificate - framed and all. Nice, huh? Well, it was 'nice' if you have a sense of humor. It said something about 'in recognition of achieving National Board Ceritification'. Yep - spelled that way. The Board secretary recognized the error as she got to the meeting that night and told the Superintendent they'd have to hold off and get it fixed before giving it to me. He said not to bother - that I probably wouldn't notice. (I noticed - and did all I could to not laugh out loud.) The secretary DID order a new certificate, spelled correctly, and brought it to me at the next Board meeting. I thanked her for her concern, brought the new copy home and put it inside the frame - BEHIND the original. I still have it - with the incorrect spelling on top. Makes me feel proud AND laugh at the same time.
WE recognize you, Ann - and are proud of you for your persistence. Good for you! I hope you are still celebrating.
Kelly M [email removed]
> > On 11/09/16, Ann wrote: >> I certified from the old process as a retake candidate. I > was >> sure I was going to get a congratulations or three from my >> administration but I was very wrong! I do work in a NYC >> school and understand that NBPTS is not very popular, >> however, I know they knew how hard I worked and how much > this >> meant to me. I am very sad that at my school I was not >> recognized as a NBCT!
I am really struggling with what 2 writing samples to analyze..I'm currently working on more informational text with my kids, so I was thinking a summary? My student struggles with summarizing, but is that substantial enough? Was also thinking of an opinion writing paper? Does hat promote enough literacy if it's a free choice opinion paper? Please advise, I'm stressing over this!!
Choosing the writing samples is important. You want to choose samples that show growth. If you're using opinion pieces, you might choose an early sample and then a later one that shows improvement in the specific skills you've identified as the student's need.
You don't focus on just one Standard. At the beginning of your C2 instructions is a LIST of Standards. There needs to be evidence of all of them. But don't panic...the prompts are designed to elicit that evidence. When you respond to the various prompts, you show evidence for the various Standards.
Basically the sequence is approximately as follows:
1. You look at a piece of 2 students' work and analyze them for strengths and weaknesses. This is like a baseline assessment. You decide what writing skills (objectives) each needs to work on. I suggest choosing students with DIFFERENT needs so that you can show how you DIFFERENTIATE your instruction the NAME of this Component!).
HOW do you differentiate? Of course some instruction can be the same, but differentiation is important. Could you use: different topics? different graphic organizers? different strategies (1-1, peer editing, word lists etc.)? Show you are meeting EACH student's needs.
2. Now you teach lessons based on what each student needs to work on.
3. You continue to analyze (assess) their writing samples so that you can decide (reflect on) if they've learned the skill (objective)and can move on to a new skill OR if they need more practice with this one.
4. Based on your knowledge of #3, you plan the next steps.
These steps are the basis for the Architecture of Accomplished Teaching which is the NB version of an accomplished lesson/unit plan. Here is a handy acronym: SSTARS:
S=Students (Know your students) S-Set Goals (based on your knowledge) T=Teach (skills you know your students need) A=Assess (analyze student work) R=Reflect S= Start over (set new goals)
I hope this helps.
On 11/20/16, Dherald wrote: > I am struggling on what to choose for my evidence as well. I > teach fifth grade writing to all 90 of my students. We are > getting ready to begin a unit on opinion pieces, and I am > wanting to use this unit for my samples, but how do I choose > what standard to focus on? Do I focus on the writing piece > as a whole, or do I focus on one aspect of it (how the > student is able to use strong evidence)? We complete > multiple opinion pieces throughout the unit. Do I choose one > that the student completes at the beginning of the unit, and > one he/she completes at the end (similar to a pre and post > assessment)? Thank you for ANY advice. - DH
You will submit 2 videos. They want each video to focus on ONE of the THREE choices they give. So you could make a math video and a SS video. Or you could do a Science video and a math video. Or you could do a SS and a science video - whatever combination of TWO of the THREE subject areas.
Since science and math can be so naturally integrated, I've heard of teachers doing a science (with some math integration) and a SS video which essentially showcases all 3 areas. But as long as you submit 2 videos demonstrating 2 of the 3 subject areas, you'll be ok.
Within the 2 videos, you also need to show that you can teach to/manage different educational formats. That basically refers to showing you can teach whole group lessons, small group lessons and/or 1-1 lessons.
Each video should focus on ONE instructional formats. Sometimes more than one can be shown, but the focus should clearly be on ONE of the formats. So, for example, I've seen videos that begin with a whole group lesson, then transition into the teacher working with small groups. But ONE of those should predominate and be shown for a much longer period of time than the other. Then the 2nd video needs to focus on a DIFFERENT format than the first video. You have some choice about those decisions.
Hope this helps.
On 11/06/16, Ramonica wrote: > I am in the process of starting my videos and in going over > the instructions I am a little confused. The instructions > state that the videos " Together the two lessons must > demonstrate a breadth of content by addressing two of the > three areas of mathematics, science, and social studies and > different instructional formats...". I'm not sure what areas > of mathematics they are referring to and does the video have > to show all of those areas? I don't know how you would do > that in 10 minutes. Can someone help?? >
I had a colleague tell me not to submit any lessons/worksheets that I got online or from the textbook. She said everything needed to be original. Is that correct?
Wh...See MoreNo, that's not literally true. There are no statements within the instructions forbidding the use of commercial materials such as textbooks, online materials etc. I've seen candidates submit both commercial/ online instructional materials and original, teacher-created ones, as well as modifications of commercial materials - and do well.
What your colleague MIGHT have meant was that in her opinion, something original would give stronger evidence than something copied from another source. That can be true, particularly when something teacher-created very closely aligns with the goals of a lesson.
But there is no rule I could find forbidding submitting something that isn't original.
On 11/16/16, Chelsi wrote: > I had a colleague tell me not to submit any lessons/worksheets > that I got online or from the textbook. She said everything > needed to be original. Is that correct?
On 11/16/16, What Works wrote: > No, that's not literally true. There are no statements within > the instructions forbidding the use of commercial materials > such as textbooks, online materials etc. I've seen > candidates submit both commercial/ online instructional > materials and original, teacher-created ones, as well as > modifications of commercial materials - and do well. > > What your colleague MIGHT have meant was that in her > opinion, something original would give stronger evidence > than something copied from another source. That can be > true, particularly when something teacher-created very > closely aligns with the goals of a lesson. > > But there is no rule I could find forbidding submitting > something that isn't original. > > > > On 11/16/16, Chelsi wrote: >> I had a colleague tell me not to submit any > lessons/worksheets >> that I got online or from the textbook. She said everything >> needed to be original. Is that correct?
What WorksAshley, please name your certificate area and which Component you're asking about.
THANKS!
On 11/13/16, Ashley wrote: > I gave kids iPods to scan QR codes and review signal > words. I understand my technique was activity-based > instruction but what was my approach??
I am desperate for guidance on what type and the length of student samples to submit for Component 2 Literaxy Reading Language Arts. I have met with a mentor (who honestly does not know and just refers me back to website and tells me to call 1-800 number). I have been working g on an instructional unit on theme with upper grades. I have work sample...See MoreI am desperate for guidance on what type and the length of student samples to submit for Component 2 Literaxy Reading Language Arts. I have met with a mentor (who honestly does not know and just refers me back to website and tells me to call 1-800 number). I have been working g on an instructional unit on theme with upper grades. I have work samples showing the growth of the required one student in a constructed response question from literature we have read. I want to use these samples to document the child's growth in responding to a constructed response question on theme. The first response is only a couple of sentences and the second one showing the growth is a full paragraph. I can not get any clarity on whether or not this is correct. On page 5 of Component 2 Option B it says- select samples that reflect the student's ability to do different kinds of writing ( story summary, poem, story retell, original writing, report, poem, etc...) I am confused as to how am I supposed to show growth of a student if they are required to do different types of writing. If I could get some explicit guidance on what will be acceptable for the the beginning and ending work sample, it would be appreciated. Thank you
I certainly sense your frustration. Believe me, it's hard for a mentor to understand all the details of every certificate area and we all know that sometimes the Component directions are hard to decipher and interpret. Calling the 1-800 number can help in certain situations, but they wouldn't be able to respond specifically to your questions. They are office workers who are trained to know many of the "rules" of submission (format, length,etc.) but not the details of any particular certificate.
Mentors have to guard against candidates becoming too dependent on them for "answers", but I think I can provide some guidance for you - having worked with many LRLA candidates over the years. I may not have all the answers you seek either, but we'll give it a GO!
Essentially, in Component 2, the assessors are looking to see if you have implemented the Architecture of Accomplished Teaching, the red graphic found in the GENERAL Portfolio Instructions that is the NB version of an accomplished lesson/unit plan. The prompts are written to give you the opportunity to show you do those steps. Here is a user-friendly acronym to help you remember: SSTARS.
S=Students S=Set Goals T=Teach A=Assess R=Reflect S=Start Over
The type of assignments you describe in your post seem to me to be on track. Understanding "theme" is a broad topic that might be appropriate for your long-term goal because it will take place over time as a result of your teaching and the writing experiences you plan.
Let's say understanding theme is your long-term goal. You'll also need a short-term goal. Here you should get narrower and more specific. What are some elements of being able to identify and write about theme? See if you can come up with some specific skills a student would need.
Then analyze a baseline example of the student's writing to see which of those skills are lacking. This might be considered a basic assessment. It sounds like the response that's only a couple of sentences long would fill that bill.
Once you've done that, using your knowledge of that student, you plan lessons to teach those skills. The student revises and writes again, maybe using the same prompt, maybe a different one. You analyze and assess and plan the next short term goal - again one that will take the student further into understanding "theme".
Here is an opportunity to slightly change the type of writing to address the information on page 5. They want more than a baseline response to a prompt and a revision of the same prompt. They want to see that the learning can carry over into other types of writing - especially if you're working with older grade students. Make every effort to show more than 1 type of writing. Perhaps students (for the 2nd piece) could choose a theme, then write their own piece based on what they've learned (just ONE idea).
That said, when I look at the Scoring Rubrics, there is no mention of using different types of writing...so you can decide how important that is.
The thing is, that you can't submit ALL the writing a student does. Some of it you describe when you respond to the prompts. There are several prompts that allow you to do this. You can include some SHORT examples within the Written Commentary that will show the assessors the student's learning without submitting a work sample. For example, you might say something like: " After teaching ___, Susie revised her writing and added ___. When she was able to ___, I knew she had learned the skill."
You might submit that very first piece of work, then for the 2nd work sample, choose something from the last assignment.
Take special care to respond as in-depth as possible to any prompt that asks for how the assignment/your teaching connected to the reading/writing process. If you read the Scoring Rubrics, you will see that this particular aspect is VERY important and can impact a score greatly.
So I'm sure you still have questions, but I hope this helps at least some.
Keep asking questions to spur your thinking!
On 11/12/16, Hali wrote: > I am desperate for guidance on what type and the length > of student samples to submit for Component 2 Literaxy > Reading Language Arts. I have met with a mentor (who > honestly does not know and just refers me back to > website and tells me to call 1-800 number). I have been > working g on an instructional unit on theme with upper > grades. I have work samples showing the growth of the > required one student in a constructed response question > from literature we have read. I want to use these samples > to document the child's growth in responding to a > constructed response question on theme. The first > response is only a couple of sentences and the second > one showing the growth is a full paragraph. I can not get > any clarity on whether or not this is correct. On page 5 of > Component 2 Option B it says- select samples that > reflect the student's ability to do different kinds of writing ( > story summary, poem, story retell, original writing, report, > poem, etc...) I am confused as to how am I supposed to > show growth of a student if they are required to do > different types of writing. If I could get some explicit > guidance on what will be acceptable for the the beginning > and ending work sample, it would be appreciated. Thank > you
On 11/13/16, Meghan wrote: > I have finished filming my 2 videos and have started > the writing portion of the component. In completing > the Instructional Context Sheet, can I just copy and > paste the answers for questions 1, 2...See More