They switched to new report cards on us this year.
The past 2 years we gave one grade for general music: a 4 was outstanding (few should get this), a 3 was average (most students), 2 was deficient in some way (either musically or behavior), 1 was non-participatory or not able to pick up on music skills (I never gave those).
I could also write around 5 sentences, where I listed the standards we covered, their positives and/or negatives, and then behavior.
Our new report cards have no space for any comments. Now we just have to score them for vocal prowess ("Student sings on pitch with good tone, rhythm, and dynamics.") and instrumental prowess ("Student plays instruments with proper technique and rhythmic accuracy.").
How am I supposed to give a picture of what goes on in my classroom with that?
And they don't want behavior to figure into their scores at all! So someone who is off task all the time can't be scored lower than someone who is a model student.
I'm just venting. I'd rather not give grades at all than have to squeeze into this kind of box.
One of our elementary music teachers used to do this. It was a great idea....but .... if you do that, make sure you give them to the teachers either ahead of time, or put them into envelopes (or folded, stapled, and with the child's name on it). Our former teacher used to hand them to me on the day that report cards were due, or (worse) two days later. I had to ask her to please fold & staple them, or envelope them, or at least give them to me by Weds (if cards were handed out on Fri). I know she was up against a rock, as she had 500+ students to grade.