Prof Readings
MEMBERS
2 Members

Teaching Jobs on Teachers.Net

Post a message...
    I am halfway finished but can't wait to post this rilly silly list. Obviously, it is a work in progress, statistically speaking. If there are 3 of these out of 5 chapters, I am bound to come across at least one more. I am using my deep-structure knowledge here.

    1. On page 43, a long-cherished belief was crushed. Stomped on. Anhilated. It s...See More
    Remember how you helped me struggle as I yearned to build a meaningful 5th grade timeline? I hated the one I copied from my teammates last year (built the whole thing with kids the first week of school).

    This year I started with 1450 and labeled a cupboard. Next cupboard 1500. 1550, 1600, 1650...to 2000. The kids make a 3x5 card for a sig...See More
    view previous comments
    Sooz Only it was right in the middle of a math lesson. My principal enjoyed it and so did I.
    Jan 19, 2011
    Jan We learn so much on this board....this place is the best prof dev I've ever had. I'm so glad you are here.

    On 1/19/11, Sooz wrote: > Only it was right in the middle of a math lesson. My principal > enjoyed it and so did I.
    Jan 20, 2011
    The first thing that struck me while reading this chapter was the immediate connection to the phenomenal book by Malcolm Gladwell, Outliers.

    Willingham discusses at one point the differences between amateur and expert thinking. Gladwell details how experts in anything have to spend at least 10,000 hours perfecting their expertise. Becoming...See More
    dc I'm reading both books right now, Kim, and I agree that I find many "aha!" parallels. I like the Willingham book because I just want to SHOVE certain pages of it into certain people's faces and SAY, "SEE, SEE, this is why I do what I do! This is why our schools should do this! This is why you politicians are wrong, wrong, wrong!"

    I suppos...See More
    Jan 18, 2011
    KimK1ca Oh yes, I agree. It feels better to shove it in their faces but the frustrating thing is that they suffer from a form of cognitive dissonance and will only listen to research that satisfies their political agendas.

    Nodding my head up and down in affirmation, dc!

    :-)K
    Jan 18, 2011
    I've known this since 1975 and have never once wavered. She's never been wrong...and never proved wrong by new research. In fact, new research has validated what she taught us.
    Jan, with an excerpt The new book about this topic was written by Mike Schmoker....who I love. He has really been on top of it for a few years now. Here's an excerpt from the book:

    Chapter 1. The Importance of Simplicity, Clarity, and Priority

    As odd as it sounds, simple, well-known strategies and structures drive improvement in any organization (Pf...See More
    Jan 20, 2011
    judy5ca Jan, thanks for posting this. I like it, but I sent you an email asking about purchase. I want to say here that I am THRILLED BEYOND BELIEF to read the words "authentic literacy." We are just having this discussion now in our new collaborative group (which is a mix of 2 schools who operate quite differently). THANK YOU FOR THE AMMO! Judy

    O...See More
    Jan 23, 2011
    I haven't read it yet, but figured you'd be interested.
    view previous comments
    KimK1ca Nobody in my family agrees.

    :-)K
    Feb 1, 2011
    brad Bleah...my tastes have changed as an adult...for instance, I now enjoy brussel sprouts, cabbage and can actually tolerate a lima bean in the odd soup...but I'm still a solid NO on liver.

    brad
    Feb 2, 2011
    It should be obvious, but Willingham's discussion of the differences between experts and novices explains much and reiterates some of our most basic understandings.

    I crack up when I hear teachers say things like, "think like a scientist." How can a young learner, with limited experiences and an education that is a work in progress, think...See More
    KimK1ca I should have placed the above post under the already- established thread regarding Chapter 6. Only dc and I have contributed so far - but I look forward to everybody's thoughts about this chapter.

    :-)K
    Jan 23, 2011
    Daniel Willingham wrote on his facebook page: "Next book will definitely be published by Jossey-Bass. Working title: "When Should You Believe 'The Experts?' The shortcut guide to separating good science from bad science."
    view previous comments
    Jan I heard Gardner speak at the Effective Schools Conference several years ago. He said he never intended his multiple intelligences ideas to be used as they are. They are not learning styles, one should not be taught over the other, kids should not be analyzed for which intelligence they might have. His only idea was to give people the idea that peop...See More
    Jan 27, 2011
    Bo I am currently reading "Teaching with Love and Logic" by Jill Fay and David Funk. It is really good.

    On 1/27/11, Jan wrote: > I heard Gardner speak at the Effective Schools Conference several > years ago. He said he never intended his multiple intelligences > ideas to be used as they are. They are not learning styles, one > sho...See More
    Jan 27, 2011
    I realize we aren't done with the Willingham book yet, but I would like to suggest a professional read that isn't too long but is packed with fabulous stuff.

    "An Ethic of Excellence," by Ron Berger, was my school's book in common for this school year. Knowing most of you the way I do, I think you will absolutely love it.

    Just an...See More
    dc Would love to read it. If more are interested, chime in, because I will order it and have it ready to go when we are done with Willingham's book.

    BTW, Kim, have you gotten to the part of Outliers where he talks about the Asian language counting system vs. our English language counting system and how our kindergartners already start at a p...See More
    Jan 26, 2011
    KimK1ca I loved everything about Outliers and drove my family nuts reading portions aloud. You are right about the Asian counting system! When I listened and read (had it on two formats) I was also FASCINATED! The whole history of Asian rigor in math suddenly made sense, especially when he talked about the rice patties.

    I hope I am not stepping o...See More
    Jan 26, 2011
    Anybody read this? I did and I am charge of the book study for my team. Any help with questions that I will ask them?
    dc Scroll down to the summer discussion about this. It was quite lively. Very strong opinions one way or the other on this chatboard. I personally thought it validated lots of things we are currently being asked to do in our classrooms and explained how to do them. I'm not saying I necessarily agree with all of them, but we are told to do them, so I'm...See More
    Jan 27, 2011
    Well, I dare not admit that I'm moving on while all of you are happily continuing the conversation of the previous chapter(s)...

    I have found this chapter, for some reason, to be the best- written of all of the chapters. I feel like there is a logical cohesive argument here and he brings together all his examples in a way that bolsters his...See More
    view previous comments
    Jan On 2/01/11, brad wrote: > cavey, > > There's a lot of truth in what you post. I do wonder if what you and I see > are the differences in demographics, as I'm primarily in an urban setting > and you are suburban/rural (?) I have students who come to older grades > without a strong foundation from the earlier grades, so even though ...See More
    Feb 6, 2011
    Jan, who forgot to say... On 2/06/11, Jan wrote: > On 2/01/11, brad wrote: >> cavey, >> >> There's a lot of truth in what you post. I do wonder >> if what you and I see are the differences in >> demographics, as I'm primarily in an urban setting >> and you are suburban/rural (?) I have students who >> come to older grades without...See More
    Feb 6, 2011

    next page » « prev page



Teacher Chatboards

States

Subject Areas

Language Arts

Foreign Language