Her students came to her hating writing, but these warm-ups and mini-lessons have turned teacher Julie Bey's students on to the process of writing. Take a look, and be sure to share the link with colleagues!
Cheryl Sigmon wrote: There is no evidence that ability grouping is necessary for Differentiating Instruction. Here’s how teaching all children to read, write and grow in literacy can be accomplished.
Click below to read a dozen helpful tips for teaching - and learning - vocabulary words! (Share your vocabulary teaching ideas here or in the Comments section following the article.)
The writing genres - have them write in those genres about what they've read. Start with fiction - it's easier. They can write a narrative about what happened after the book ends - they can write an informational report about the book and then an essay arguing whether it was a good book or not.
Have them do the same with the other genres of reading that you do.
Hi! I am teaching 5th grade reading and using the reader's workshop approach. How do I get my students to write an entry into their notebooks that reflects critical thinking, or an in-depth response to what they read? Last year I got immature, surface level hog-wash! Thanks!
I would agree with the structured questions approach. Leaving it open ended produces stream of consciousness blither. Kids have no idea what to say but that they write something for you shows that they want to be compliant.
Let's not expect children or adolescents to be naturally reflective - America on the whole is not a society that fosters reflection - we're impulsive risk takers, not reflective ponderers. Nor are children naturally critical thinkers - critical thinking is a skill that takes time - sometimes years - to learn particularly as most of their classes do the 'one right answer' method of instruction. To this day I know LA and Lit teachers who teach 'there's just one right interpretation of this book'.
Understand too that critical thinking is ... risky. We want our students to be critical thinkers but we don't want them thinking too critically about school or the process of school.
ArleneOn 6/17/14, Sue wrote: > On 6/09/14, Melissa Simmons wrote: >> Hi! >> I am teaching 5th grade reading and using the reader's >> workshop approach. How do I get my students to write an > entry >> into their notebooks that reflects critical thinking, or an >> in-depth response to what they read? Last year I got >...See MoreOn 6/17/14, Sue wrote: > On 6/09/14, Melissa Simmons wrote: >> Hi! >> I am teaching 5th grade reading and using the reader's >> workshop approach. How do I get my students to write an > entry >> into their notebooks that reflects critical thinking, or an >> in-depth response to what they read? Last year I got > immature, >> surface level hog-wash! >> Thanks! > > I would agree with the structured questions approach. Leaving > it open ended produces stream of consciousness blither. Kids > have no idea what to say but that they write something for > you shows that they want to be compliant. > > Let's not expect children or adolescents to be naturally > reflective - America on the whole is not a society that > fosters reflection - we're impulsive risk takers, not > reflective ponderers. Nor are children naturally critical > thinkers - critical thinking is a skill that takes time - > sometimes years - to learn particularly as most of their > classes do the 'one right answer' method of instruction. To > this day I know LA and Lit teachers who teach 'there's just > one right interpretation of this book'. > > Understand too that critical thinking is ... risky. We want > our students to be critical thinkers but we don't want them > thinking too critically about school or the process of > school.
I have taught middle school chorus for six years. Next year, I will be reducing the number of chorus classes I teach and will be embarking on a new adventure that I am very excited about: 8th Grade Language Arts.
I teach in a high-poverty urban school (very diverse, with our largest population groups being Hispanic and African-American). I am looking ahead to next year and am trying to figure out how I am going to facilitate novel reading (we are supposed to read two during the course of the year, while also focusing a tremendous amount of time on reading). One of the novels must have themes related to the Holocaust.
I have been told that I cannot ask my students to purchase books (I wouldn't do that with my population anyway) and that we do not have enough to check the novels out to our students (we only have class sets). So - all reading will have to be completed in class. I have heard different schools of thought among my colleagues on how to facilitate this - and frankly, I'm not sold on any of them.
One of our teachers does all of the reading herself to the students aloud (expecting them to follow along). One of our teachers asks the students to do all of the reading silently in class but has told me to expect major discipline problems from the students who do not want to read (or who struggle in that area). And then another one of the teachers does popcorn reading.
And finally - one of my colleagues has suggested that I should just do excerpts of novels instead of the whole thing (but that doesn't sound pleasant, either).
ANY suggestions you could give me would be appreciated. How do I do this well while keeping my students engaged?
Also - suggestions for novels would be great, too. I was considering Alan Lawrence Sitomer's "Homeboyz," but the profanity would make reading aloud nearly impossible. I would like to avoid "The Diary of Anne Frank," and "Night" seems a bit much for that age (these are the two most commonly taught books in our building).
I can get back with some more novel suggestions - I need to recheck some titles but things like Number The Stars and The Devil's Arithmetic are coming to mind as possible Holocaust books and there's another - Stones for Water?
I use tapes/CDs - there's a place/site where you can buy/rent tapes of books and the reading is done by professionals- by actors - so the books are read well. ListeningLibrary.com was a good place to access tapes/CDs - [link removed].
And they don't 'listen' automatically - they don't know how to listen. I work on that skill and we build our endurance, our ability to listen. Some have never been read aloud to and their brains just don't know what to do with it. Listening is a learned skill.
There's no ideal way to do this - there's no perfect way and every class has its own personality. What works for one teacher in one class might not work for the next. Explain the difficulty to them - we can't take the books home so - how do we read this together in class? Try to get some buy-in from them. > I'd rather do short stories than excerpts of novels but it has happened that we start a novel and it just doesn't work out and I end it. NO book is the right book for every class.
The word 'holocaust' in Swahili is 'Maafa'. Africa has over 2,000 languages but the trans-Atlantic slave trade is called 'The Maafa' - Africa has its own Holocaust that involved 200 million lives.
The Underground Railroad saving African-Americans from slavery makes a nice connection to those who tried to save Jews from the Holocaust. Who was the Harriet Tubman of the Holocaust? Oscar Schindler was one but there are others. One many - Vry? - determined he would save as many Jewish artists and writers as he could.
Keeping students engaged is an ongoing challenge from one day to the next, from one activity to the next. There's no easy answer and again what works for one teacher in one class doesn't necessarily work for the next.
You might check out the 'Freedom Writers' film - just because those inner city kids actually brought the woman who tried to save Anne Frank and her family to the U.S. and right to their school. > > And finally - one of my colleagues has suggested that I > should just do excerpts of novels instead of the whole > thing (but that doesn't sound pleasant, either). > > ANY suggestions you could give me would be appreciated. How > do I do this well while keeping my students engaged? > > Also - suggestions for novels would be great, too. I was > considering Alan Lawrence Sitomer's "Homeboyz," but the > profanity would make reading aloud nearly impossible. I > would like to avoid "The Diary of Anne Frank," and "Night" > seems a bit much for that age (these are the two most > commonly taught books in our building). > > Thanks for your assistance! > > Best, Kevin
Sometimes, poor readers might benefit from seeing the movie first. That way they already have a framework for understanding the book better.
Check with your public library. Some libraries have book discussion kits and may have some for young adults.
In addition, do some research on lit circles. There are different roles in lit circles for the students. Students who are artistically inclined could draw/paint/create a visual impression of that day's selection. Another one could find unfamiliar vocabulary and teach the others those words,etc.
A more advanced form of lit circles is the Socratic discussion that might interest older kids more. This will take a lot of you training them in the beginning but they will benefit from learning how to, for example, disagree with someone without coming to blows.