I have been suggesting the book/workbook to my middle- upper grade students: First Aid for Readers. If they don't want to buy it I bring it to parent conference as an incentive. It is a good addition to my program for those kids that need the strategies available to them..
I think that teachers have to get away from "my way is the right way" idea and at least be open to learning new teaching techniques. I do not believe whole class instruction and worksheets promote learning. Worksheets, especially in mathematics, only tells the teacher whether the child can computate or memorize math facts. I have learned that math ...See MoreI think that teachers have to get away from "my way is the right way" idea and at least be open to learning new teaching techniques. I do not believe whole class instruction and worksheets promote learning. Worksheets, especially in mathematics, only tells the teacher whether the child can computate or memorize math facts. I have learned that math is building on concepts and not just regurgitating a process. You have to be able to THINK and do especially with problem solving skills. As far as Fountas & Pinnell goes...I totally support its use. Having advanced children or children who are below grade level sit and listen to a whole group reading lesson is a waste of time. Advanced children already get the grade level material and the below grade level kids must have the gaps filled in for them. You cannot do that with worksheets. I agree with the person that mentioned the modeling. It takes a good 4-6 weeks to get it down for the kids especially if they have never been in classroom where literacy centers have taken place. The teacher has to MODEL, MODEL, and MODEL some more. In my opinion, learning isn't taking place for those above or below grade level during whole group teaching either. They are tuning the teacher out and no one progresses.
On 3/28/09, anon wrote: > We are at the end of our 3rd year, and are all praying that it > doesn't get renewed. If you look at all the posts in the > chatboard, I think we all agree -- there is some good that > comes out of it, but mostly a huge amount of stress on the > teachers and in turn the students. I really don't think any > data will support that this program has done the miraculous > things it has claimed it will do. I've been teaching for a > long time now and in the past three years that we've had this > grant I've seen a drastic decrease in the students' reading > abilities -- and let's not even start talking about writing > and math skills! They are, however, getting much better at > taking multiple choice and constructed response tests. > > On 3/26/09, emma wrote: >> We are in our last year of a 3 year RF grant and our >> principal is asking for another 3 year extension. There >> is an 80% chance he will get it since we've done so well >> for the past 3 years as a school. Does anyone know what >> it's like? Is it just the same as the previous 3 years? >> So much work and testing has been loaded on to our backs >> that we don't even walk straight anymore. I have learned a >> lot of good strategies, but some of it is such useless >> stuff just to make us "earn" the grant. Everytime our >> Reading Coach and principal go to an RF meeting, we know >> they will come back with more work to pile on us. Not to >> mention that we are observed a lot and critiqued a lot, >> too. It has gotten so tiresome. Has anyone been part of >> an RF extension? I would appreciate feedback on this just >> so I know what to expect. Thanks!
While I had hoped we wouldn't get renewed, this term has been much better than the first. It just depends on who writes the application and what is in it for requirements.
I am looking for this kit. Does anyone have one they can sell me? I am looking to pay about $100. I will pay shipping and can pay via PayPal for safety.
leae, someone please explain the three Tiers that I've been hearing about. How does this fit into DIBELS, AIMSweb, and reading skils? Is Tier 1 the same as strategic?
As far as working hard to make our kids successful, I would like to know WHEN parents will help their children learn their letters, counting, number recognition so that I can take get them to meet state standards. Good grief! I am NOT a miracle worker. I have just so much energy and time, NOT!
On 10/20/09, Amen to that! wrote: > On 10/18/09, GO AWAY, RTI & NCLB & Dibels!!!!!!! wrote: >> Will education ever be the way it used to be & >> students learning like they used to?! > > Our jobs as teachers will never be the same! I'm all > for helping the struggling child but don't tell me I > have to DIBEL every kid to find the ones that need > help. What happen to trusting the teacher's decision > and give the time and money to assist these strugglers > instead of constantly testing them and requiring us to > do the paperwork. RtI is a lovely concept with 15-20 > kids in a class, but how do you give that 2-3 Tier 2 > kids an extra 30 min. while the other 25 kids are > "independently" working? It seems to me that > all this extra testing is to identify those few that > need extra help, like we wouldn't know that. Energy, > time and money needs to be spent to make sure we have > qualified teachers in the schools and find out why > these kids are struggling. You'll find most of the > problems start at the home. Meanwhile, the kids who are > doing well and need advanced instruction are not given > the time because we're so busy pulling up the > strugglers. I'm pretty sure that's why we have LD and > Spec. ED. teachers. We are expected to work miracles.
On 10/20/09, Kinder Gal wrote: > I have qui...See MoreYou sound relatively negative and overwhelmed, and really aren't seeing the positive for youngsters in all of this reform. Is there any particular reason that you are teaching? clearly you don't like it and, frankly, you give the rest of us a bad image. So, please, consider another profession.
On 10/20/09, Kinder Gal wrote: > I have quite a group of youngsters that I am struggling to > work with. My day is 90 minutes of reading, 40 min of > math interventions. Then lunch/recess, math, phonics, and > we are supposed to do 30 min of reading intervention with > the lowest kids. I have way to many to put into one > group...yet not enough time to put them into 2 groups. I > have a para pro (who can not get it through her head what > I want her to do). I have complained numerous times that > insteady of 19 kids, I have 20. One quarter down, 3 more > to go. > > As far as working hard to make our kids successful, I > would like to know WHEN parents will help their children > learn their letters, counting, number recognition so that > I can take get them to meet state standards. Good grief! > I am NOT a miracle worker. I have just so much energy > and time, NOT! > > > > On 10/20/09, Amen to that! wrote: >> On 10/18/09, GO AWAY, RTI & NCLB & Dibels!!!!!!! wrote: >>> Will education ever be the way it used to be & >>> students learning like they used to?! >> >> Our jobs as teachers will never be the same! I'm all >> for helping the struggling child but don't tell me I >> have to DIBEL every kid to find the ones that need >> help. What happen to trusting the teacher's decision >> and give the time and money to assist these strugglers >> instead of constantly testing them and requiring us to >> do the paperwork. RtI is a lovely concept with 15-20 >> kids in a class, but how do you give that 2-3 Tier 2 >> kids an extra 30 min. while the other 25 kids are >> "independently" working? It seems to me that >> all this extra testing is to identify those few that >> need extra help, like we wouldn't know that. Energy, >> time and money needs to be spent to make sure we have >> qualified teachers in the schools and find out why >> these kids are struggling. You'll find most of the >> problems start at the home. Meanwhile, the kids who are >> doing well and need advanced instruction are not given >> the time because we're so busy pulling up the >> strugglers. I'm pretty sure that's why we have LD and >> Spec. ED. teachers. We are expected to work miracles.
Hi! I am currently a high school English teacher who just got hired as a reading specialist for an intermediate school. Does anyone have any suggestions of "must-have" books or materials that may be helpful? I am looking for a "bible," so to speak, for the reading specialist. I'd appreciate any help you could offer. Thanks!!
I am moving from 3rd to 1st grade, and was wanting to get three of the Reading Rods sets: Phonemic Awareness, Word Building, and Sight Words. These fit into RTI...
MiraI have the phonemic awareness sets for K. I have used them, but not as much as I expected to.
On 5/30/09, J2911 wrote: > I am moving from 3rd to 1st grade, and was wanting to get > three of the Reading Rods sets: Phonemic Awareness, Word > Building, and Sight Words. These fit into RTI... > > Do any of you use them?
Most folks seem to have DRA. If your school doesn't use it, what else would you suggest?